학술논문
Poster session 3
Document Type
Article
Author
Winter, R; Lindqvist, P; Sheehan, F; Fazlinezhad, A; Vojdanparast, M; Nezafati, P; Martins Fernandes, S; Teixeira, R; Pellegrino, M; Generati, G; Bandera, F; Labate, V; Alfonzetti, E; Guazzi, M; Iriart, X; Dinet, ML; Jalal, Z; Cochet, H; Thambo, JB; Moustafa, S; Ho, TH; Shah, P; Murphy, K; Nelluri, BK; Lee, H; Wilansky, S; Mookadam, F; Stolfo, D; Tonet, E; Merlo, M; Barbati, G; Gigli, M; Pinamonti, B; Ramani, F; Zecchin, M; Sinagra, G; Bieseviciene, M; Vaskelyte, JJ; Mizariene, V; Lesauskaite, V; Verseckaite, R; Karaliute, R; Jonkaitiene, R; Patel, S; Li, L; Craft, M; Danford, D; Kutty, S; Vriz, O; Pellegrinet, M; Zito, C; Carerj, S; Di Bello, V; Cittadini, A; Bossone, E; Antonini-Canterin, F; Sarvari, S I; Rodriguez, M; Sitges, M; Sepulveda-Martinez, A; Gratacos, E; Bijnens, B; Crispi, F; Santos, M; Leite, L; Martins, R; Baptista, R; Barbosa, A; Ribeiro, N; Oliveira, A; Castro, G; Pego, M; Berezin, A; Samura, T; Kremzer, A; Stoebe, S; Tarr, A; Pfeiffer, D; Hagendorff, A; Benyounes Iglesias, N; Van Der Vynckt, C; Gout, O; Devys, JM; Cohen, A; De Chiara, B; Musca, F; D'angelo, L; Cipriani, MG; Parolini, M; Rossi, A; Santambrogio, GM; Russo, C; Giannattasio, C; Moreo, A; Soliman, A; Moharram, M; Gamal, A; Reda, A; Oni, O; Adebiyi, A; Aje, A; Ricci, F; Aquilani, R; Dipace, G; Bucciarelli, V; Bianco, F; Miniero, E; Scipioni, G; De Caterina, R; Gallina, S; Tumasyan, LR; Adamyan, KG; Chilingaryan, AL; Tunyan, LG; Kim, KH; Cho, JY; Yoon, HJ; Ahn, Y; Jeong, MH; Cho, JG; Park, JC; Popa, B A; Popa, A; Cerin, G; Ecocardiografico, Campagna Provinciale di Screening; Yiangou, K; Azina, CH; Yiangou, A; Georgiou, C; Zitti, M; Ioannides, M; Chimonides, S; Olsen, R H; Pedersen, LR; Snoer, M; Christensen, TE; Ghotbi, AA; Hasbak, P; Kjaer, A; Haugaard, SB; Prescott, E; Cacicedo, A; Velasco Del Castillo, S; Gomez Sanchez, V; Anton Ladislao, A; Onaindia Gandarias, J; Rodriguez Sanchez, I; Jimenez Melo, O; Garcia Cuenca, E; Zugazabeitia Irazabal, G; Romero Pereiro, A; Monti, L; Nardi, B; Di Giovine, G; Malanchini, G; Scardino, C; Balzarini, L; Presbitero, P; Gasparini, GL; Holte, E; Orlic, D; Tesic, M; Zamaklar-Trifunovic, D; Vujisic-Tesic, B; Borovic, M; Milasinovic, D; Zivkovic, M; Kostic, J; Belelsin, B; Ostojic, M; investigators, PATA STEMI; Trifunovic, D; Krljanac, G; Savic, L; Asanin, M; Aleksandric, S; Petrovic, M; Zlatic, N; Lasica, R; Mrdovic, I; Nucifora, G; Muser, D; Zanuttini, D; Tioni, C; Bernardi, G; Spedicato, L; Proclemer, A; Casalta, AC; Galli, E; Szymanski, C; Salaun, E; Lavoute, C; Haentjens, J; Tribouilloy, C; Mancini, J; Donal, E; Habib, G; Cavalcante, JL; Delgado-Montero, A; Dahou, A; Caballero, L; Rijal, S; Gorcsan, J; Monin, JL; Pibarot, P; Lancellotti, P; Keramida, K; Kouris, N; Kostopoulos, V; Giannaris, V; Trifou, E; Markos, L; Mihalopoulos, A; Mprempos, G; Olympios, CD; Calin, A; Mateescu, AD; Rosca, M; Beladan, CC; Enache, R; Gurzun, MM; Varga, P; Calin, C; Ginghina, C; Popescu, BA; Almeida Morais, L; Galrinho, A; Branco, L; Gomes, V; Timoteo, A T; Daniel, P; Rodrigues, I; Rosa, S; Fragata, J; Ferreira, R; Bandera, F; Generati, G; Pellegrino, M; Carbone, F; Labate, V; Alfonzetti, E; Guazzi, M; Galli, E; Leclercq, C; Samset, E; Donal, E; Kamal, H M; Oraby, MA; Eleraky, A Z; Yossuef, M A; Leite, L; Baptista, R; Teixeira, R; Ribeiro, N; Oliveira, AP; Barbosa, A; Castro, G; Martins, R; Elvas, L; Pego, M; Polte, CL; Gao, SA; Lagerstrand, KM; Johnsson, AA; Bech-Hanssen, O; Martinez Santos, P; Vilacosta, I; Batlle Lopez, E; Sanchez Sauce, B; Jimenez Valtierra, J; Espana Barrio, E; Campuzano Ruiz, R; De La Rosa Riestra, A; Alonso Bello, J; Perez Gonzalez, F; Jin, CN; Wan, S; Sun, JP; Lee, AP; Generati, G; Bandera, F; Pellegrino, M; Carbone, F; Labate, V; Alfonzetti, E; Guazzi, M; Reali, M; Cimino, S; Salatino, T; Silvetti, E; Mancone, M; Pennacchi, M; Giordano, A; Sardella, G; Agati, L; Kalcik, M; Yesin, M; Gunduz, S; Gursoy, MO; Astarcioglu, MA; Karakoyun, S; Bayam, E; Cersit, S; Ozkan, M; Cacicedo, A; Velasco Del Castillo, S; Gomez Sanchez, V; Anton Ladislao, A; Onaindia Gandarias, J; Rodriguez Sanchez, I; Jimenez Melo, O; Quintana Razcka, O; Romero Pereiro, A; Zugazabeitia Irazabal, G; Nascimento, H; Braga, M; Flores, L; Ribeiro, V; Melao, F; Dias, P; Maciel, MJ; Bettencourt, P; Ferreiro Quero, C; Mesa Rubio, M D; Ruiz Ortiz, M; Delgado Ortega, M; Sanchez Fernandez, J; Duran Jimenez, E; Morenate Navio, C; Romero, M; Pan, M; Suarez De Lezo, J; Kazum, S; Vaturi, M; Weisenberg, D; Monakier, D; Valdman, A; Vaknin- Assa, H; Assali, A; Kornowski, R; Sagie, A; Shapira, Y; Madeira, S; Ribeiras, R; Abecasis, J; Teles, R; Castro, M; Tralhao, A; Horta, E; Brito, J; Andrade, M; Mendes, M; Villagra, JM; Avegliano, G; Ronderos, R; Matta, MG; Camporrotondo, M; Castro, F; Albina, G; Aranda, A; Navia, D; Muraru, D; Siciliano, M; Migliore, F; Cavedon, S; Folino, F; Pedrizzetti, G; Bertaglia, M; Corrado, D; Iliceto, S; Badano, LP; Gobbo, M; Merlo, M; Stolfo, D; Losurdo, P; Ramani, F; Barbati, G; Pivetta, A; Pinamonti, B; Sinagra, GF; Di Lenarda, A; Generati, G; Bandera, F; Pellegrino, M; Labate, V; Carbone, F; Alfonzetti, E; Guazzi, M; D'andrea, A; Di Palma, E; Baldini, L; Verrengia, M; Vastarella, R; Limongelli, G; Bossone, E; Calabro', R; Russo, MG; Pacileo, G; Azevedo, O; Cruz, I; Correia, E; Bento, D; Teles, L; Lourenco, C; Faria, R; Domingues, K; Picarra, B; Marques, N; Group, SUNSHINE; Nucifora, G; Muser, D; Gianfagna, P; Morocutti, G; Proclemer, A; Cruz, I; Gomes, AC; Lopes, LR; Stuart, B; Caldeira, D; Morgado, G; Almeida, AR; Canedo, P; Bagulho, C; Pereira, H; Lozano Granero, VC; Pardo Sanz, A; Marco Del Castillo, A; Monteagudo Ruiz, JM; Rincon Diaz, LM; Ruiz Rejon, F; Casas, E; Hinojar, R; Fernandez-Golfin, C; Zamorano Gomez, JL; Stampfli, S F; Erhart, L; Staehli, BE; Kaufmann, BA; Tanner, FC; Marketou, M; Kontaraki, J; Parthenakis, F; Maragkoudakis, S; Zacharis, E; Patrianakos, A; Vardas, P; Bento, D; Domingues, K; Correia, E; Lopes, L; Teles, L; Picarra, B; Magalhaes, P; Faria, R; Lourenco, C; Azevedo, O; Group, SUNSHINE; Mohty, D; Boulogne, C; Magne, J; Damy, T; Martin, S; Boncoeur, MP; Aboyans, V; Jaccard, A; Hernandez Jimenez, V; Saavedra Falero, J; Alberca Vela, MT; Molina Blazquez, L; Mata Caballero, R; Serrano Rosado, JA; Elviro, R; Gascuena, R; Di Gioia, C; Fernandez Rozas, I; Manzano, MC; Martinez Sanchez, JI; Molina, M; Palma, J; Ingvarsson, A; Werther Evaldsson, A; Radegran, G; Stagmo, M; Waktare, J; Roijer, A; Meurling, CJ; Cameli, M; Righini, FM; Sparla, S; Di Tommaso, C; Focardi, M; D'ascenzi, F; Tacchini, D; Maccherini, M; Henein, M; Mondillo, S; Werther Evaldsson, A; Ingvarsson, A; Waktare, J; Thilen, U; Stagmo, M; Roijer, A; Radegran, G; Meurling, C; Greiner, S; Jud, A; Aurich, M; Katus, HA; Mereles, D; Michelsen, MM; Faber, R; Pena, A; Mygind, ND; Suhrs, HE; Zander, M; Prescott, E; El Eraky, AZZA; Handoka, NESRIN; Ghali, MONA; Eldahshan, NAHED; Ibrahim, AHMED; Kamal, H M; Al-Eraky, A Z; El Attar, M A; Omar, A S; D'ascenzi, F; Pelliccia, A; Alvino, F; Solari, M; Cameli, M; Focardi, M; Bonifazi, M; Mondillo, S; Spinelli, L; Giudice, C A; Assante Di Panzillo, E; Castaldo, D; Riccio, E; Pisani, A; Trimarco, B; Stojanovic, S; Deljanin Ilic, M; Ilic, S; Mincu, RI; Magda, LS; Florescu, M; Velcea, A; Mihalcea, D; Chiru, A; Popescu, BO; Tiu, C; Vinereanu, D; Vindis, D; Hutyra, M; Cechakova, E; Littnerova, S; Taborsky, M; Mantovani, F; Lugli, R; Bursi, F; Fabbri, M; Modena, MG; Stefanelli, G; Mussini, C; Barbieri, A; Yi, JE; Youn, HJ; O, JH; Yoon, HJ; Jung, HO; Shin, GJ; Styczynski, G; Rdzanek, A; Pietrasik, A; Kochman, J; Huczek, Z; Milewska, A; Marczewska, M; Szmigielski, C A; Battah, AHMED; Abd Eldayem, SOHA; El Magd El Bohy, ABO; O'driscoll, J; Slee, A; Peresso, V; Nazir, S; Sharma, R; Generati, G; Bandera, F; Pellegrino, M; Labate, V; Carbone, F; Alfonzetti, E; Guazzi, M; Velasco Del Castillo, S; Anton Ladislao, A; Gomez Sanchez, V; Cacidedo Fernandez Bobadilla, A; Onaindia Gandarias, JJ; Rodriguez Sanchez, I; Romero Pereira, A; Quintana Rackza, O; Jimenez Melo, O; Zugazabeitia Irazabal, G; Voilliot, D; Huttin, O; Venner, C; Deballon, R; Manenti, V; Villemin, T; Olivier, A; Sadoul, N; Juilliere, Y; Selton-Suty, C; Scali, MC; Simioniuc, A; Mandoli, GE; Dini, FL; Marzilli, M; Picano, E; Garcia Campos, A; Martin-Fernandez, M; De La Hera Galarza, JM; Corros-Vicente, C; Leon-Aguero, V; Velasco-Alonso, E; Colunga-Blanco, S; Fidalgo-Arguelles, A; Rozado-Castano, J; Moris De La Tassa, C; Opitz, B; Stelzmueller, ME; Wisser, W; Reichenfelser, W; Mohl, W; Herold, IHF; Saporito, S; Mischi, M; Bouwman, RA; Van Assen, HC; Van Den Bosch, HCM; De Lepper, A; Korsten, HHM; Houthuizen, P; Veiga, CESAR; I, JAVIER. Randulfe Juanjo Andina Jose Fanina Francisco Calvo Emilio Paredes-Galan Pablo Pazos Andres; Ageing; Diseases, Cardiovascular; Santos Furtado, M; Rodrigues, A; Leal, G; Silvestre, O; Andrade, J; Khan, UM; Hjertaas, JJ; Greve, G; Matre, K; Leite, L; Teixeira, R; Baptista, R; Barbosa, A; Ribeiro, N; Castro, G; Martins, R; Cardim, N; Goncalves, L; Pego, M; Leite, L; Teixeira, R; Baptista, R; Barbosa, A; Ribeiro, N; Castro, G; Martins, R; Cardim, N; Goncalves, L; Pego, M; Leite, L; Teixeira, R; Baptista, R; Barbosa, A; Oliveira, AP; Castro, G; Martins, R; Cardim, N; Goncalves, L; Pego, M; Keramida, K; Kouris, N; Kostopoulos, V; Markos, L; Olympios, CD; Molnar, AA; Kovacs, A; Tarnoki, AD; Tarnoki, DL; Kolossvary, M; Apor, A; Maurovich-Horvat, P; Jermendy, G; Sengupta, P; Merkely, B; Rio, P; Viveiros Monteiro, A; Galrinho, A; Pereira-Da-Silva, T; Moura Branco, L; Timoteo, A; Abreu, J; Leal, A; Varela, F; Cruz Ferreira, R; Huang, MS; Yang, LT; Tsai, WC; Papadopoulos, C; Mpaltoumas, K; Fotoglidis, A; Triantafyllou, K; Pagourelias, E; Kassimatis, E; Tzikas, S; Kotsiouros, G; Mantzogeorgou, E; Vassilikos, V; Venneri, L; Calicchio, F; Manivarmane, R; Pareek, N; Baksi, J; Rosen, S; Senior, R; Lyon, AR; Khattar, RS; Onut, R; Marinescu, C; Onciul, S; Zamfir, D; Tautu, O; Dorobantu, M; Casas Rojo, E; Carbonell San Roman, A; Rincon Diez, LM; Gonzalez Gomez, A; Fernandez Santos, S; Lazaro Rivera, C; Moreno Vinues, C; Sanmartin Fernandez, M; Fernandez-Golfin, C; Zamorano Gomez, JL; Bayat, F; Alirezaei, T; Karimi, AS; hospital, cardiovascular research center of shahid beheshti; Aggeli, C; Kakiouzi, V; Felekos, I; Panagopoulou, V; Latsios, G; Karabela, M; Petras, D; Tousoulis, D; Ben Kahla, S; Abid, L; Abid, D; Kammoun, S; Abid, L; Ben Kahla, S; Choi, JH; Lee, JW; Barreiro Perez, M; Martin Fernandez, M; Costilla Garcia, SM; Diaz Pelaez, E; Moris De La Tassa, C
Source
European Journal of Echocardiography; December 2015, Vol. 16 Issue: Supplement 2 pS102-S102, 1p
Subject
Language
ISSN
15252167; 15322114
Abstract
Purpose: We developed a transthoracic echo simulator that can measure psychomotor skill in echo to assist in training as well as for certification of competence. The simulator displays cine loops on a computer in response to the user scanning a mannequin with a mock transducer. The skill metric is the deviation angle between the image acquired by the user and the anatomically correct plane for the specified view. We sought to determine whether the simulator-based test could distinguish levels of expertise. Methods: Attendees at an echo course or at the annual meeting of the Swedish Heart Association were invited to take a 15 min test on the simulator. On the test, the user scanned the mannequin and acquired 4 views: parasternal long axis (pLAX) in patient 1, apical 4 chamber (a4c) and aLAX in patient 2, and pLAX in patient 3. Scan time was limited to 15 min. Attendees were asked regarding current work status, position, and experience with echo assessed from duration in years and procedure volume in the past 12 months. Results: Of the 61 participants there were 22 sonographers, 2 nurses, and 37 doctors who were all in practice except 1 doctor who was a resident. The data of nurses was combined with that of sonographers because their procedure volume was nearer to that of sonographers (850 ± 599 tests/yr) than doctors (312 ± 393, p < 0.001). Doctors and non-doctors had similar duration of experience (9 ± 8 vs. 12 ± 11 yrs, p=NS). The test was not completed by 12 participants (18%) but unfamiliarity with the simulator may have contributed because the deviation angle for pLAX dropped between the first and third patients (23 ± 11 to 18 ± 10 degrees, p<0.020). The average deviation angle over the 4 views was slightly lower for sonographers than for doctors (26 ± 11 vs. 30 ± 14 degrees, p=NS). The deviation angle for pLAX (55 ± 37 degrees) was higher than for a4C (17 ± 22 degrees) or either pLAX view (p<0.00001). pLAX was the only view whose deviation angle correlated significantly with experience and only with procedure volume (r=-0.302, p=0.025). Conclusions: The results of this study demonstrate that the skill metric employed, angle of deviation between the plane of an acquired view and the plane of the anatomically correct image for that view, can distinguish the relative experience of sonographers and doctors in practice. Simulation-based testing provides objective and quantitative assessment of the psychomotor skill of image acquisition and may be of value in certification of trainees and in maintenance of certification examination of practicing sonographers and doctors.