학술논문

Contributions of mean and shape of blood pressure distribution to worldwide trends and variations in raised blood pressure: a pooled analysis of 1018 population-based measurement studies with 88.6 million participants
Document Type
Author
Zhou, BinBentham, JamesDi Cesare, MariachiaraBixby, HonorDanaei, GoodarzHajifathalian, KavehTaddei, CristinaCarrillo-Larco, Rodrigo M.Djalalinia, ShirinKhatibzadeh, ShahabLugero, CharlesPeykari, NiloofarZhang, Wan ZhuBennett, JamesBilano, VerStevens, Gretchen A.Cowan, Melanie J.Riley, Leanne M.Chen, ZhengmingHambleton, Ian R.Jackson, Rod T.Kengne, Andre PascalKhang, Young-HoLaxmaiah, AvulaLiu, JingMalekzadeh, RezaNeuhauser, Hannelore K.Soric, MarojeStarc, GregorSundstrom, JohanWoodward, MarkEzzati, MajidAbarca-Gomez, LeandraAbdeen, Ziad A.Abu-Rmeileh, Niveen M.Acosta-Cazares, BenjaminAdams, Robert J.Aekplakorn, WichaiAfsana, KaosarAguilar-Salinas, Carlos A.Agyemang, CharlesAhmad, Noor AniAhmadvand, AlirezaAhrens, WolfgangAjlouni, KamelAkhtaeva, NazgulAl-Raddadi, RajaaAli, Mohamed M.Ali, OsmanAlkerwi, Ala'aAly, EmanAmarapurkar, Deepak N.Amouyel, PhilippeAmuzu, AntoinetteAndersen, Lars BoAnderssen, Sigmund A.Angquist, Lars H.Anjana, Ranjit MohanAnsong, DanielAounallah-Skhiri, HajerAraujo, JoanaAriansen, IngerAris, TahirArlappa, NimmathotaArveiler, DominiqueAryal, Krishna K.Aspelund, ThorAssah, Felix K.Assuncao, Maria Cecilia F.Avdicova, MariaAzevedo, AnaAzizi, FereidounBabu, Bontha V.Bahijri, SuhadBalakrishna, NagallaBamoshmoosh, MohamedBanach, MaciejBandosz, PiotrBanegas, Jose R.Barbagallo, Carlo M.Barcelo, AlbertoBarkat, AminaBarros, Aluisio J. D.Barros, Mauro V.Bata, IqbalBatieha, Anwar M.Batyrbek, AssembekovBaur, Louise A.Beaglehole, RobertBen Romdhane, HabibaBenet, MikhailBenson, Lowell S.Bernabe-Ortiz, AntonioBernotiene, GailuteBettiol, HeloisaBhagyalaxmi, AroorBharadwaj, SumitBhargava, Santosh K.Bi, YufangBikbov, MukharramBista, BihungumBjerregaard, PeterBjertness, EspenBjertness, Marius B.Bjorkelund, CeciliaBlokstra, AnnekeBo, SimonaBobak, MartinBoeing, HeinerBoggia, Jose G.Boissonnet, Carlos P.Bongard, VaninaBorchini, RossanaBovet, PascalBraeckman, LutgartBrajkovich, ImperiaBranca, FrancescoBreckenkamp, JuergenBrenner, HermannBrewster, Lizzy M.Bruno, GraziellaBueno-de-MesquitaBugge, AnnaBurns, ConBursztyn, MichaelCabrera de Leon, AntonioCacciottolo, JosephCai, HuiCameron, ChristineCan, GunayCandido, Ana Paula C.Capuano, VincenzoCardoso, Viviane C.Carlsson, Axel C.Carvalho, Maria J.Casanueva, Felipe F.Casas, Juan-PabloCaserta, Carmelo A.Chamukuttan, SnehalathaChan, Angelique W.Chan, QueenieChaturvedi, Himanshu K.Chaturvedi, NishiChen, Chien-JenChen, FangfangChen, HuashuaiChen, ShuohuaCheng, Ching-YuCherkaoui Dekkaki, ImaneChetrit, AngelaChiolero, ArnaudChiou, Shu-TiChirita-Emandi, AdelaChirlaque, Maria-DoloresCho, BelongCho, YumiChristofaro, Diego G.Chudek, JerzyCifkova, RenataCinteza, ElizaClaessens, FrankClays, ElsConcin, HansCooper, CyrusCooper, RachelCoppinger, Tara C.Costanzo, SimonaCottel, DominiqueCowell, ChrisCraig, Cora L.Crujeiras, Ana B.Cruz, Juan J.D'Arrigo, Graziellad'Orsi, EleonoraDallongeville, JeanDamasceno, AlbertinoDankner, RachelDantoft, Thomas M.Dauchet, LucDavletov, KairatDe Backer, GuyDe Bacquer, Dirkde Gaetano, GiovanniDe Henauw, Stefaande Oliveira, Paula DuarteDe Smedt, DelphineDeepa, MohanDehghan, AbbasDelisle, HeleneDeschamps, ValerieDhana, KlodianDi Castelnuovo, Augusto F.Dias-da-Costa, Juvenal SoaresDiaz, AlejandroDickerson, Ty T.Do, Ha T. P.Dobson, Annette J.Donfrancesco, ChiaraDonoso, Silvana P.Doering, AngelaDorobantu, MariaDoua, KouamelanDrygas, WojciechDulskiene, VirginijaDzakula, AleksandarDzerve, VilnisDziankowska-Zaborszczyk, ElzbietaEggertsen, RobertEkelund, UlfEl Ati, JalilaElliott, PaulElosua, RobertoErasmus, Rajiv T.Erem, CihangirEriksen, LouiseEriksson, Johan G.Escobedo-de la Pena, JorgeEvans, AlunFaeh, DavidFall, Caroline H.Farzadfar, FarshadFelix-Redondo, Francisco J.Ferguson, Trevor S.Fernandes, Romulo A.Fernandez-Berges, DanielFerrante, DanielFerrari, MarikaFerreccio, CatterinaFerrieres, JeanFinn, Joseph D.Fischer, KristaFoger, BernhardFoo, Leng HuatForslund, Ann-SofieForsner, Maria, 1954; Fouad, Heba M.Francis, Damian K.Franco, Maria do CarmoFranco, Oscar H.Frontera, GuillermoFuchs, Flavio D.Fuchs, Sandra C.Fujita, YukiFurusawa, TakuroGaciong, ZbigniewGalvano, FabioGarcia-de-la-Hera, ManoliGareta, DickmanGarnett, Sarah P.Gaspoz, Jean-MichelGasull, MagdaGates, LouiseGeleijnse, Johanna M.Ghasemian, AnooshehGhimire, AnupGiampaoli, SimonaGianfagna, FrancescoGill, Tiffany K.Giovannelli, JonathanGoldsmith, Rebecca A.Goncalves, HelenGonzalez-Gross, MarcelaGonzalez-Rivas, Juan P.Bonet Gorbea, MarianoGottrand, FredericGraff-Iversen, SidselGrafnetter, DusanGrajda, AnetaGrammatikopoulou, Maria G.Gregor, Ronald D.Grodzicki, TomaszGrontved, AndersGrosso, GiuseppeGruden, GabriellaGrujic, VeraGu, DongfengGuan, Ong PengGudmundsson, Elias F.Gudnason, VilmundurGuerrero, RamiroGuessous, IdrisGuimaraes, Andre L.Gulliford, Martin C.Gunnlaugsdottir, JohannaGunter, MarcGupta, Prakash C.Gupta, RajeevGureje, OyeGurzkowska, BeataGutierrez, LauraGutzwiller, FelixHadaegh, FarzadHalkjaer, JytteHardy, RebeccaKumar, Rachakulla HariHata, JunHayes, Alison J.He, JiangHe, YunaHendriks, Marleen ElisabethHenriques, AnaHernandez Cadena, LeticiaHerrala, SauliHeshmat, RaminHihtaniemi, Ilpo TapaniHo, Sai YinHo, Suzanne C.Hobbs, MichaelHofman, AlbertDinc, Gonul HorasanHorimoto, Andrea R. V. R.Hormiga, Claudia M.Horta, Bernardo L.Houti, LeilaHowitt, ChristinaHtay, Thein TheinHtet, Aung SoeHtike, Maung Maung ThanHu, YonghuaMaria Huerta, JoseHuisman, MartijnHusseini, Abdullatif S.Huybrechts, IngeHwalla, NahlaIacoviello, LiciaIannone, Anna G.Ibrahim, Mohsen M.Wong, Norazizah IbrahimIkeda, NayuIkram, M. ArfanIrazola, Vilma E.Islam, MuhammadIsmail, Aziz al-SafiIvkovic, VanjaIwasaki, MasanoriJacobs, Jeremy M.Jaddou, HashemJafar, TazeenJamrozik, KonradJanszky, ImreJasienska, GrazynaJelakovic, AnaJelakovic, BojanJennings, GarryJeong, Seung-lyealJiang, Chao QiangJoffres, MichelJohansson, MattiasJokelainen, Jari J.Jonas, Jost B.Jorgensen, TorbenJoshi, PradeepJozwiak, JacekJuolevi, AnneJurak, GregorJuresa, VesnaKaaks, RudolfKafatos, AnthonyKajantie, Eero O.Kalter-Leibovici, OfraKamaruddin, Nor AzmiKarki, Khem B.Kasaeian, AmirKatz, JoanneKauhanen, JussiKaur, PrabhdeepKavousi, MaryamKazakbaeva, GyulliKeil, UlrichBoker, Lital KeinanKeinanen-Kiukaanniemi, SirkkaKelishadi, RoyaKemper, Han C. G.Kengne, Andre P.Kerimkulova, AlinaKersting, MathildeKey, TimothyKhader, Yousef SalehKhalili, DavoodKhateeb, MohammadKhaw, Kay-TeeKiechl-Kohlendorfer, UrsulaKiechl, StefanKillewo, JaphetKim, JeongseonKim, Yeon-YongKlumbiene, JurateKnoflach, MichaelKolle, ElinKolsteren, PatrickKorrovits, PaulKoskinen, SeppoKouda, KatsuyasuKowlessur, SudhirKoziel, SlawomirKriemler, SusiKristensen, Peter LundKrokstad, SteinarKromhout, DaanKruger, Herculina S.Kubinova, RuzenaKuciene, RenataKuh, DianaKujala, Urho M.Kulaga, ZbigniewKumar, R. KrishnaKurjata, PawelKusuma, Yadlapalli S.Kuulasmaa, KariKyobutungi, CatherineLaatikainen, TiinaLachat, CarlLam, Tai HingLandrove, OrlandoLanska, VeraLappas, GeorgLarijani, BagherLaugsand, Lars E.Bao, Khanh Le NguyenLe, Tuyen D.Leclercq, CatherineLee, JeannetteLee, JeongheeLehtimaki, TerhoLeon-Munoz, Luz M.Levitt, Naomi S.Li, YanpingLilly, Christa L.Lim, Wei-YenFernanda Lima-Costa, M.Lin, Hsien-HoLin, XuLind, LarsLinneberg, AllanLissner, LaurenLitwin, MieczyslawLorbeer, RobertoLotufo, Paulo A.Eugenio Lozano, JoseLuksiene, DaliaLundqvist, AnnamariLunet, NunoLytsy, PerMa, JunMachado-Coelho, George L. L.Machi, SukaMaggi, StefaniaMagliano, Dianna J.Magriplis, EmmanuellaMajer, MarjetaMakdisse, MarciaMalhotra, RahulRao, Kodavanti MallikharjunaMalyutina, SofiaManios, YannisMann, Jim I.Manzato, EnzoMargozzini, PaulaMarques-Vidal, PedroMarques, Larissa PrunerMarrugat, JaumeMartorell, ReynaldoMathiesen, Ellisiv B.Matijasevich, AliciaMatsha, Tandi E.Mbanya, Jean Claude N.Posso, Anselmo J. Mc DonaldMcFarlane, Shelly R.McGarvey, Stephen T.McLachlan, StelaMcLean, Rachael M.McLean, Scott B.McNulty, Breige A.Mediene-Benchekor, SounniaMedzioniene, JurateMeirhaeghe, AlineMeisinger, ChristaMenezes, Ana Maria B.Menon, Geetha R.Meshram, Indrapal I.Metspalu, AndresMeyer, Haakon E.Mi, JieMikkel, KairitMiller, Jody C.Minderico, Claudia S.Francisco, JuanJaime Miranda, J.Mirrakhimov, ErkinMisigoj-Durakovic, MarjetaModesti, Pietro A.Mohamed, Mostafa K.Mohammad, KazemMohammadifard, NoushinMohan, ViswanathanMohanna, SalimYusoff, Muhammad Fadhli MohdMollehave, Line T.Moller, Niels C.Molnar, DenesMomenan, AmirabbasMondo, Charles K.Monyeki, Kotsedi Daniel K.Moon, Jin SooMoreira, Leila B.Morejon, AlainMoreno, Luis A.Morgan, KarenMoschonis, GeorgeMossakowska, MalgorzataMostafa, AyaMota, JorgeMotlagh, Mohammad EsmaeelMotta, JorgeMsyamboza, Kelias P.Mu, Thet ThetMuiesan, Maria L.Mueller-Nurasyid, MartinaMurphy, NeilMursu, JaakkoMusil, VeraNabipour, IrajNagel, GabrieleNaidu, Balkish M.Nakamura, HarunobuNamesna, JanaNang, Ei Ei K.Nangia, Vinay B.Narake, SameerNauck, MatthiasMaria Navarrete-Munoz, EvaNdiaye, Ndeye CoumbaNeal, William A.Nenko, IlonaNeovius, MartinNervi, FlavioNguyen, Chung T.Nguyen, D. NguyenNguyen, Quang NgocNguyen, Quang V.Nieto-Martinez, Ramfis E.Niiranen, Teemu J.Ning, GuangNinomiya, ToshiharuNishtar, SaniaNoale, MariannaNoboa, Oscar A.Noorbala, Ahmad AliNorat, TeresaNoto, DavideAl Nsour, MohannadO'Reilly, DermotOda, EijiOehlers, GlennOh, KyungwonOhara, KumikoOlinto, Maria Teresa A.Oliveira, Isabel O.Azahadi, MohdOnat, AltanOng, Sok KingOno, Lariane M.Ordunez, PedroOrnelas, RuiOsmond, CliveOstojic, Sergej M.Ostovar, AfshinOtero, Johanna A.Overvad, KimOwusu-Dabo, EllisPaccaud, Fred MichelPadez, CristinaPahomova, ElenaPajak, AndrzejPalli, DomenicoPalmieri, LuigiPan, Wen-HarnPanda-Jonas, SonghomitraPanza, FrancescoPapandreou, DimitriosPark, Soon-WooParnell, Winsome R.Parsaeian, MahboubehPatel, Nikhil D.Pecin, IvanPednekar, Mangesh S.Peer, NasheetaPeeters, Petra H.Peixoto, Sergio VianaPeltonen, MarkkuPereira, Alexandre C.Peters, AnnettePetersmann, AstridPetkeviciene, JaninaPham, Son ThaiPigeot, IrisPikhart, HynekPilav, AidaPilotto, LorenzaPitakaka, FredaPiwonska, AleksandraPlans-Rubio, PedroPolasek, OzrenPorta, MiquelPortegies, Marileen L. P.Pourshams, AkramPoustchi, HosseinPradeepa, RajendraPrashant, MathurPrice, Jacqueline F.Puder, Jardena J.Puiu, MariaPunab, MargusQasrawi, Radwan F.Qorbani, MostafaBao, Tran QuocRadic, IvanaRadisauskas, RicardasRahman, MahfuzarRaitakari, OlliRaj, ManuRao, Sudha RamachandraRamachandran, AmbadyRamos, ElisabeteRampal, LekhrajRampal, SanjayReina, Daniel A. RangelRedon, JosepReganit, Paul Ferdinand M.Ribeiro, RobespierreRiboli, ElioRigo, Fernandode Wit, Tobias F. RinkeRitti-Dias, Raphael M.Robinson, Sian M.Robitaille, CynthiaRodriguez-Artalejo, Fernandodel Cristo Rodriguez-Perez, MariaRodriguez-Villamizar, Laura A.Rojas-Martinez, RosalbaRomaguera, DoraRonkainen, KimmoRosengren, AnnikaRoy, Joel G. R.Rubinstein, AdolfoSandra Ruiz-Betancourt, BlancaRutkowski, MarcinSabanayagam, CharumathiSachdev, Harshpal S.Saidi, OlfaSakarya, SibelSalanave, BenoitSalazar Martinez, EduardoSalmeron, DiegoSalomaa, VeikkoSalonen, Jukka T.Salvetti, MassimoSanchez-Abanto, JoseSans, SusanaSantos, Diana A.Santos, Ina S.dos Santos, Renata NunesSantos, RuteSaramies, Jouko L.Sardinha, Luis B.Sarganas, GiselleSarrafzadegan, NizalSaum, Kai-UweSavva, SavvasScazufca, MarciaSchargrodsky, HermanSchipf, SabineSchmidt, Carsten O.Schoettker, BenSchultsz, ConstanceSchutte, Aletta E.Sein, Aye AyeSen, AbhijitSenbanjo, Idowu O.Sepanlou, Sadaf G.Sharma, Sanjib K.Shaw, Jonathan E.Shibuya, KenjiShin, Dong WookShin, YouchanSi-Ramlee, KhairilSiantar, RosalynnSibai, Abla M.Santos Silva, Diego AugustoSimon, MarySimons, JudithSimons, Leon A.Sjostrom, MichaelSkovbjerg, SineSlowikowska-Hilczer, JolantaSlusarczyk, PrzemyslawSmeeth, LiamSmith, Margaret C.Snijder, Marieke B.So, Hung-KwanSobngwi, EugeneSöderberg, StefanSolfrizzi, VincenzoSonestedt, EmilySong, YiSorensen, Thorkild I. A.Jerome, Charles SossaSoumare, AichaStaessen, Jan A.Stathopoulou, Maria G.Stavreski, BillSteene-Johannessen, JosteinStehle, PeterStein, Aryeh D.Stergiou, George S.Stessman, JochananStieber, JuttaStoeckl, DorisStocks, TanjaStokwiszewski, JakubStronks, KarienStrufaldi, Maria WanySun, Chien-AnSung, Yn-TzSuriyawongpaisal, PaibulSy, Rody G.Tai, E. ShyongTammesoo, Mari-LiisTamosiunas, AbdonasTan, Eng JooTang, XunTanser, FrankTao, YongTarawneh, Mohammed RasoulTarqui-Mamani, Carolina B.Tautu, Oana-FlorentinaTaylor, AnneTheobald, HolgerTheodoridis, XenophonThijs, LutgardeThuesen, Betina H.Tjonneland, AnneTolonen, Hanna K.Tolstrup, Janne S.Topbas, MuratTopor-Madry, RomanJose Tormo, MariaTorrent, MatiesTraissac, PierreTrichopoulos, DimitriosTrichopoulou, AntoniaTrinh, Oanh T. H.Trivedi, AtulTshepo, LechabaTulloch-Reid, Marshall K.Tullu, FikruTuomainen, Tomi-PekkaTuomilehto, JaakkoTurley, Maria L.Tynelius, PerTzourio, ChristopheUeda, PeterUgel, Eunice E.Ulmer, HannoUusitalo, Hannu M. T.Valdivia, GonzaloValvi, Damaskinivan der Schouw, Yvonne T.Van Herck, KoenMinh, Hoang Vanvan Rossem, LenieVan Schoor, Natasja M.van Valkengoed, Irene G. M.Vanderschueren, DirkVanuzzo, DiegoVatten, LarsVega, TomasVelasquez-Melendez, GustavoVeronesi, GiovanniVerschuren, W. M. MoniqueVerstraeten, RoosmarijnVictora, Cesar G.Viet, LucieViikari-Juntura, EiraVineis, PaoloVioque, JesusVirtanen, Jyrki K.Visvikis-Siest, SophieViswanathan, BharathiVlasoff, TiinaVollenweider, PeterVoutilainen, SariWade, Alisha N.Wagner, AlineWalton, JanetteBebakar, Wan Mohamad WanMohamud, Wan Nazaimoon WanWanderley, Rildo S., Jr.Wang, Ming-DongWang, QianWang, Ya XingWang, Ying-WeiWannamethee, S. GoyaWareham, NicholasWedderkopp, NielsWeerasekera, DeepaWhincup, Peter H.Widhalm, KurtWidyahening, Indah S.Wiecek, AndrzejWijga, Alet H.Wilks, Rainford J.Willeit, JohannWilleit, PeterWilliams, Emmanuel A.Wilsgaard, TomWojtyniak, BogdanWong-McClure, Roy A.Wong, Justin Y. Y.Wong, Tien YinWoo, JeanWu, Aleksander GiwercmanWu, Frederick C.Wu, ShoulingXu, HaiquanYan, WeiliYang, XiaoguangYe, XingwangYiallouros, Panayiotis K.Yoshihara, AkihiroYounger-Coleman, Novie O.Yusoff, Ahmad FaudziZainuddin, Ahmad AliZambon, SabinaZampelas, AntonisZdrojewski, TomaszZeng, YiZhao, DongZhao, WenhuaZheng, WeiZheng, YingfengZhu, DanZhussupov, BaurzhanZimmermann, EstherCisneros, Julio Zuniga
Source
International Journal of Epidemiology. 47(3):872-883i
Subject
blood pressure
hypertension
population health
global health
non-communicable disease
Language
English
ISSN
0300-5771
1464-3685
Abstract
Background: Change in the prevalence of raised blood pressure could be due to both shifts in the entire distribution of blood pressure (representing the combined effects of public health interventions and secular trends) and changes in its high-blood-pressure tail (representing successful clinical interventions to control blood pressure in the hypertensive population). Our aim was to quantify the contributions of these two phenomena to the worldwide trends in the prevalence of raised blood pressure.Methods: We pooled 1018 population-based studies with blood pressure measurements on 88.6 million participants from 1985 to 2016. We first calculated mean systolic blood pressure (SBP), mean diastolic blood pressure (DBP) and prevalence of raised blood pressure by sex and 10-year age group from 20-29 years to 70-79 years in each study, taking into account complex survey design and survey sample weights, where relevant. We used a linear mixed effect model to quantify the association between (probit-transformed) prevalence of raised blood pressure and age-group-and sex-specific mean blood pressure. We calculated the contributions of change in mean SBP and DBP, and of change in the prevalence-mean association, to the change in prevalence of raised blood pressure.Results: In 2005-16, at the same level of population mean SBP and DBP, men and women in South Asia and in Central Asia, the Middle East and North Africa would have the highest prevalence of raised blood pressure, and men and women in the high-income Asia Pacific and high-income Western regions would have the lowest. In most region-sex-age groups where the prevalence of raised blood pressure declined, one half or more of the decline was due to the decline in mean blood pressure. Where prevalence of raised blood pressure has increased, the change was entirely driven by increasing mean blood pressure, offset partly by the change in the prevalence-mean association.Conclusions: Change in mean blood pressure is the main driver of the worldwide change in the prevalence of raised blood pressure, but change in the high-blood-pressure tail of the distribution has also contributed to the change in prevalence, especially in older age groups.