학술논문

Tracking development assistance for health and for COVID-19: a review of development assistance, government, out-of-pocket, and other private spending on health for 204 countries and territories, 1990-2050
Document Type
Author
Micah, Angela E.Cogswell, Ian E.Cunningham, BrandonEzoe, SatoshiHarle, Anton C.Maddison, Emilie R.McCracken, DarrahNomura, ShuheiSimpson, Kyle E.Stutzman, Hayley N.Tsakalos, GolsumWallace, Lindsey E.Zhao, YingxiZende, Rahul R.Abbafati, CristianaAbdelmasseh, MichaelAbedi, AidinAbegaz, Kedir HusseinAbhilash, E. S.Abolhassani, HassanAbrigo, Michael R. M.Adhikari, Tara BallavAfzal, SairaAhinkorah, Bright OpokuAhmadi, SepidehAhmed, HaroonAhmed, Muktar BeshirRashid, Tarik AhmedAjami, MarjanAji, BudiAkalu, YonasAkunna, Chisom JoyqueenetAl Hamad, HanadiAlam, KhurshidAlanezi, Fahad MashhourAlanzi, Turki M.Alemayehu, YosefAlhassan, Robert KabaAlinia, CyrusAljunid, Syed MohamedAlmustanyir, Sami AlmustanyirAlvis-Guzman, NelsonAlvis-Zakzuk, Nelson J.Amini, SaeedAmini-Rarani, MostafaAmu, HubertAncuceanu, RobertAndrei, Catalina LilianaAndrei, TudorelAngell, BlakeAnjomshoa, MinaAntonio, Carl Abelardo T.Antony, Catherine M.Aqeel, MuhammadArabloo, JalalArab-Zozani, MortezaAripov, TimurArrigo, AlessandroAshraf, TahiraAtnafu, Desta DebalkieAusloos, MarcelAvila-Burgos, LeticiaAwan, Asma TahirAyano, GetinetAyanore, Martin AmogreAzari, SamadAzhar, Gulrez ShahBabalola, Tesleem KayodeBahrami, Mohammad AminBaig, Atif AminBanach, MaciejBarati, NastaranBarnighausen, Till WinfriedBarrow, AmadouBasu, SanjayBaune, Bernhard T.Bayati, MohsenBenzian, HabibBerman, Adam E.Bhagavathula, Akshaya SrikanthBhardwaj, NikhaBhardwaj, PankajBhaskar, SonuBibi, SadiaBijani, AliBodolica, VirginiaBragazzi, Nicola LuigiBraithwaite, DejanaBreitborde, Nicholas J. K.Breusov, Alexey V.Briko, Nikolay IvanovichBusse, ReinhardCahuana-Hurtado, LuceroCallander, Emily JoyCamera, Luis AlbertoCastaneda-Orjuela, Carlos A.Catala-Lopez, FerranCharan, JaykaranChatterjee, SouranshuChattu, Soosanna KumaryChattu, Vijay KumarChen, SimiaoCicero, Arrigo Francesco GiuseppeDadras, OmidDahlawi, Saad M. A.Dai, XiaochenDalal, KoustuvDandona, LalitDandona, RakhiDavitoiu, Dragos VirgilDe Neve, Jan-Walterde Sa-Junior, Antonio ReisDenova-Gutierrez, EdgarDhamnetiya, DeepakDharmaratne, Samath DhammindaDoshmangir, LeilaDube, JohnEhsani-Chimeh, ElhamZaki, Maysaa El SayedEl Tantawi, MahaEskandarieh, ShararehFarzadfar, FarshadFerede, Tomas Y.Fischer, FlorianFoigt, Nataliya A.Freitas, AlbertoFriedman, Sara D.Fukumoto, TakeshiFullman, NancyGaal, Peter AndrasGad, Mohamed M.Garcia-Gordillo, M. A.Garg, TusharGhafourifard, MansourGhashghaee, AhmadGholamian, AsadollahGholamrezanezhad, AliGhozali, GhozaliGilani, Syed AmirGlavan, Ionela-RoxanaGlushkova, Ekaterina VladimirovnaGoharinezhad, SalimeGolechha, MahaveerGoli, SrinivasGuha, AvirupGupta, Veer BalaGupta, Vivek KumarHaakenstad, AnnieHaider, Mohammad RifatHailu, AlemayehuHamidi, SamerHanif, AsifHarapan, HarapanHartono, Risky KusumaHasaballah, Ahmed I.Hassan, ShoaibHassanein, Mohamed H.Hayat, KhezarHegazy, Mohamed I.Heidari, GolnazHendrie, DeliaHeredia-Pi, IleanaHerteliu, ClaudiuHezam, KamalHolla, RameshHossain, Sheikh JamalHosseinzadeh, MehdiHostiuc, SorinHuda, Tanvir M.Hwang, Bing-FangIavicoli, IvoIdrisov, BulatIlesanmi, Olayinka StephenIrvani, Seyed Sina NaghibiIslam, Sheikh Mohammed SharifulIsmail, Nahlah ElkudssiahIsola, GaetanoJahani, Mohammad AliJahanmehr, NaderJakovljevic, MihajloJanodia, Manthan DilipkumarJavaheri, TaherehJayapal, Sathish KumarJayawardena, RanilJazayeri, Seyed BehzadJha, Ravi PrakashJonas, Jost B.Joo, TamasJoukar, FarahnazJurisson, MikkKaambwa, BillingsleyKalhor, RohollahKanchan, TanujKandel, HimalMatin, Behzad KaramiKarimi, Salah EddinKassahun, GetinetKayode, Gbenga A.Karyani, Ali KazemiKeikavoosi-Arani, LeilaKhader, Yousef SalehKhajuria, HimanshuKhalilov, RovshanKhammarnia, MohammadKhan, JunaidKhubchandani, JagdishKianipour, NedaKim, Gyu RiKim, Yun JinKisa, AdnanKisa, SezerKohler, StefanKosen, SoewartaKoteeswaran, RajasekaranLaxminarayana, Sindhura Lakshmi KoulmaneKoyanagi, AiKrishan, KewalKumar, G. AnilKusuma, DianLamnisos, DemetrisLansingh, Van CharlesLarsson, Anders O.Lasrado, SavitaLe, Long Khanh DaoLee, Shaun Wen HueyLee, Yeong YehLim, Stephen S.Lobo, Stany W.Lozano, RafaelAbd El Razek, Hassan MagdyAbd El Razek, Muhammed MagdyMahdavi, Mokhtar MahdaviMajeed, AzeemMakki, AlaaMaleki, AfshinMalekzadeh, RezaManda, Ana LauraMansour-Ghanaei, FariborzMansournia, Mohammad AliArnedo, Carlos Alberto MarrugoMartinez-Valle, AdolfoMasoumi, Seyedeh ZahraMaude, Richard JamesMckee, MartinMedina-Solis, Carlo EduardoMenezes, Ritesh G.Meretoja, AtteMeretoja, Tuomo J.Mesregah, Mohamed KamalMestrovic, TomislavKostova, Neda MilevskaMiller, Ted R.Mini, G. K.Mirica, AndreeaMirrakhimov, Erkin M.Mohajer, BahramMohamed, Teroj AbdulrahmanMohammadi, MokhtarMohammadian-Hafshejani, AbdollahMohammed, ShafiuMoitra, ModhurimaMokdad, Ali H.Molokhia, MariamMoni, Mohammad AliMoradi, YousefMorze, JakubMousavi, Seyyed MeysamMpundu-Kaambwa, ChristineMuriithi, Moses K.Muthupandian, SaravananNagarajan, Ahamarshan JayaramanNaimzada, Mukhammad DavidNangia, VinayNaqvi, Atta AbbasNarayana, Aparna IchalangodNascimento, Bruno RamosNaveed, MuhammadNayak, Biswa PrakashNazari, JavadNdejjo, RawlanceNegoi, IonutKandel, Sandhya NeupaneNguyen, Trang HuyenNonvignon, JusticeNoubiap, Jean JacquesNwatah, Vincent EbukaOancea, BogdanOjelabi, Foluke Adetola OgunyemiOlagunju, Andrew T.Olakunde, Babayemi OluwaseunOlgiati, StefanoOlusanya, Jacob OlusegunOnwujekwe, Obinna E.Otoiu, AdrianOtstavnov, NikitaOtstavnov, Stanislav S.Owolabi, Mayowa O.Padubidri, Jagadish RaoPalladino, RaffaelePanda-Jonas, SonghomitraPark, Eun-CheolKan, Fatemeh PashazadehPawar, ShrikantToroudi, Hamidreza PazokiPereira, David M.Perianayagam, ArokiasamyPesudovs, KonradPiccinelli, CristianoPostma, Maarten J.Prada, Sergio I.Rabiee, MohammadRabiee, NavidRahim, FakherRahimi-Movaghar, VafaRahman, Mohammad Hifz UrRahman, MosiurRahmani, Amir MasoudRam, UshaRanabhat, Chhabi LalRanasinghe, PriyangaRao, Chythra R.Rathi, PriyaRawaf, David LaithRawaf, SalmanRawal, LalRawassizadeh, RezaReiner, Robert C., Jr.Renzaho, Andre M. N.Reshmi, BhageerathyRiaz, Mavra A.Ripon, Rezaul KarimSaad, Anas M.Sahraian, Mohammad AliSahu, MaitreyiSalama, Joseph S.Salehi, SanaSamy, Abdallah M.Sanabria, JuanSanmarchi, FrancescoSantos, Joao VascoSantric-Milicevic, Milena M.Sathian, BrijeshSavic, MilojeSaxena, DeepakSayyah, MehdiSchwendicke, FalkSenthilkumaran, SubramanianSepanlou, Sadaf G.Seylani, AllenShahabi, SaeedShaikh, Masood AliSheikh, AzizShetty, AdithiShetty, Pavanchand H.Shibuya, KenjiShrime, Mark G.Shuja, Kanwar HamzaSingh, Jasvinder A.Skryabin, Valentin YurievichSkryabina, Anna AleksandrovnaSoltani, ShahinSoofi, MoslemSpurlock, Emma ElizabethStefan, Simona CatalinaSzerencses, ViktoriaSzocska, MiklosTabares-Seisdedos, RafaelTaddele, Biruk WogayehuTefera, Yonas GetayeThavamani, AravindTobe-Gai, RuoyanTopor-Madry, RomanTovani-Palone, Marcos RobertoTran, Bach XuanCar, Lorainne TudorUllah, AnayatUllah, SaifUmar, NasirUndurraga, Eduardo A.Valdez, Pascual R.Vasankari, Tommi JuhaniVillafane, Jorge HugoViolante, Francesco S.Vlassov, VasilyVo, BayVollmer, SebastianVos, TheoVu, Giang ThuVu, Linh GiaWamai, Richard G.Werdecker, AndreaWoldekidan, Mesfin AgachewWubishet, Befikadu LegesseXu, GelinYaya, SanniYazdi-Feyzabadi, VahidYigit, VahitYip, PaulYirdaw, Birhanu WubaleYonemoto, NaohiroYounis, Mustafa Z.Yu, ChuanhuaYunusa, IsmaeelMoghadam, Telma ZahirianZandian, HamedZastrozhin, Mikhail SergeevichZastrozhina, AnasthasiaZhang, Zhi-JiangZiapour, ArashZuniga, Yves Miel H.Hay, Simon I.Murray, Christopher J. L.Dieleman, Joseph L.
Source
The Lancet. 398(10308):1317-1343
Subject
Language
English
ISSN
0140-6736
1474-547X
Abstract
Background The rapid spread of COVID-19 renewed the focus on how health systems across the globe are financed, especially during public health emergencies. Development assistance is an important source of health financing in many low-income countries, yet little is known about how much of this funding was disbursed for COVID-19. We aimed to put development assistance for health for COVID-19 in the context of broader trends in global health financing, and to estimate total health spending from 1995 to 2050 and development assistance for COVID-19 in 2020. Methods We estimated domestic health spending and development assistance for health to generate total health-sector spending estimates for 204 countries and territories. We leveraged data from the WHO Global Health Expenditure Database to produce estimates of domestic health spending. To generate estimates for development assistance for health, we relied on project-level disbursement data from the major international development agencies' online databases and annual financial statements and reports for information on income sources. To adjust our estimates for 2020 to include disbursements related to COVID-19, we extracted project data on commitments and disbursements from a broader set of databases (because not all of the data sources used to estimate the historical series extend to 2020), including the UN Office of Humanitarian Assistance Financial Tracking Service and the International Aid Transparency Initiative. We reported all the historic and future spending estimates in inflation-adjusted 2020 US$, 2020 US$ per capita, purchasing-power parity-adjusted US$ per capita, and as a proportion of gross domestic product. We used various models to generate future health spending to 2050. Findings In 2019, health spending globally reached $8. 8 trillion (95% uncertainty interval [UI] 8.7-8.8) or $1132 (1119-1143) per person. Spending on health varied within and across income groups and geographical regions. Of this total, $40.4 billion (0.5%, 95% UI 0.5-0.5) was development assistance for health provided to low-income and middle-income countries, which made up 24.6% (UI 24.0-25.1) of total spending in low-income countries. We estimate that $54.8 billion in development assistance for health was disbursed in 2020. Of this, $13.7 billion was targeted toward the COVID-19 health response. $12.3 billion was newly committed and $1.4 billion was repurposed from existing health projects. $3.1 billion (22.4%) of the funds focused on country-level coordination and $2.4 billion (17.9%) was for supply chain and logistics. Only $714.4 million (7.7%) of COVID-19 development assistance for health went to Latin America, despite this region reporting 34.3% of total recorded COVID-19 deaths in low-income or middle-income countries in 2020. Spending on health is expected to rise to $1519 (1448-1591) per person in 2050, although spending across countries is expected to remain varied. Interpretation Global health spending is expected to continue to grow, but remain unequally distributed between countries. We estimate that development organisations substantially increased the amount of development assistance for health provided in 2020. Continued efforts are needed to raise sufficient resources to mitigate the pandemic for the most vulnerable, and to help curtail the pandemic for all. Copyright (C) 2021 The Author(s). Published by Elsevier Ltd.