학술논문

Global, regional, and national comparative risk assessment of 79 behavioural, environmental and occupational, and metabolic risks or clusters of risks in 188 countries, 1990-2013: a systematic analysis for the Global Burden of Disease Study 2013.
Document Type
Author
Forouzanfar, Mohammad HAlexander, LilyAnderson, H RossBachman, Victoria FBiryukov, StanBrauer, MichaelBurnett, RichardCasey, DanielCoates, Matthew MCohen, AaronDelwiche, KristenEstep, KaraFrostad, Joseph JAstha, K CKyu, Hmwe HMoradi-Lakeh, MaziarNg, MarieSlepak, Erica LeighThomas, Bernadette AWagner, JosephAasvang, Gunn MaritAbbafati, CristianaAbbasoglu Ozgoren, AyseAbd-Allah, FoadAbera, Semaw FAboyans, VictorAbraham, BijuAbraham, Jerry PuthenpurakalAbubakar, IbrahimAbu-Rmeileh, Niveen M EAburto, Tania CAchoki, TomAdelekan, AdemolaAdofo, KorantengAdou, Arsène KAdsuar, José CAfshin, AshkanAgardh, Emilie EAl Khabouri, Mazin JAl Lami, Faris HAlam, Sayed SaidulAlasfoor, DeenaAlbittar, Mohammed IAlegretti, Miguel AAleman, Alicia VAlemu, Zewdie AAlfonso-Cristancho, RafaelAlhabib, SamiaAli, RaghibAli, Mohammed KAlla, FrançoisAllebeck, PeterAllen, Peter JAlsharif, UbaiAlvarez, ElenaAlvis-Guzman, NelsonAmankwaa, Adansi AAmare, Azmeraw TAmeh, Emmanuel AAmeli, OmidAmini, HereshAmmar, WalidAnderson, Benjamin OAntonio, Carl Abelardo TAnwari, PalwashaArgeseanu Cunningham, SolveigArnlöv, JohanArsenijevic, Valentina S ArsicArtaman, AlAsghar, Rana JAssadi, RezaAtkins, Lydia SAtkinson, CharlesAvila, Marco AAwuah, BaffourBadawi, AlaaBahit, Maria CBakfalouni, TalalBalakrishnan, KalpanaBalalla, ShivanthiBalu, Ravi KumarBanerjee, AmitavaBarber, Ryan MBarker-Collo, Suzanne LBarquera, SimonBarregard, LarsBarrero, Lope HBarrientos-Gutierrez, TonatiuhBasto-Abreu, Ana CBasu, ArindamBasu, SanjayBasulaiman, Mohammed OBatis Ruvalcaba, CarolinaBeardsley, JustinBedi, NeerajBekele, TolesaBell, Michelle LBenjet, CorinaBennett, Derrick ABenzian, HabibBernabé, EduardoBeyene, Tariku JBhala, NeerajBhalla, AshishBhutta, Zulfiqar ABikbov, BorisBin Abdulhak, Aref ABlore, Jed DBlyth, Fiona MBohensky, Megan ABora Başara, BerrakBorges, GuilhermeBornstein, Natan MBose, DipanBoufous, SoufianeBourne, Rupert RBrainin, MichaelBrazinova, AlexandraBreitborde, Nicholas JBrenner, HermannBriggs, Adam D MBroday, David MBrooks, Peter MBruce, Nigel GBrugha, Traolach SBrunekreef, BertBuchbinder, RachelleBui, Linh NBukhman, GeneBulloch, Andrew GBurch, MichaelBurney, Peter G JCampos-Nonato, Ismael RCampuzano, Julio CCantoral, Alejandra JCaravanos, JackCárdenas, RosarioCardis, ElisabethCarpenter, David OCaso, ValeriaCastañeda-Orjuela, Carlos ACastro, Ruben ECatalá-López, FerránCavalleri, FiorellaÇavlin, AlanurChadha, Vineet KChang, Jung-ChenCharlson, Fiona JChen, HongleiChen, WanqingChen, ZhengmingChiang, Peggy PChimed-Ochir, OdgerelChowdhury, RajivChristophi, Costas AChuang, Ting-WuChugh, Sumeet SCirillo, MassimoClaßen, Thomas K DColistro, ValentinaColomar, MercedesColquhoun, Samantha MContreras, Alejandra GCooper, CyrusCooperrider, KimberlyCooper, Leslie TCoresh, JosefCourville, Karen JCriqui, Michael HCuevas-Nasu, LuciaDamsere-Derry, JamesDanawi, HadiDandona, LalitDandona, RakhiDargan, Paul IDavis, AdrianDavitoiu, Dragos VDayama, Anandde Castro, E FilipaDe la Cruz-Góngora, VanessaDe Leo, Diegode Lima, GraçaDegenhardt, Louisadel Pozo-Cruz, BorjaDellavalle, Robert PDeribe, KebedeDerrett, SarahDes Jarlais, Don CDessalegn, MulukendeVeber, Gabrielle ADevries, Karen MDharmaratne, Samath DDherani, Mukesh KDicker, DanielDing, Eric LDokova, KlaraDorsey, E RayDriscoll, Tim RDuan, LeileiDurrani, Adnan MEbel, Beth EEllenbogen, Richard GElshrek, Yousef MEndres, MatthiasErmakov, Sergey PErskine, Holly EEshrati, BabakEsteghamati, AlirezaFahimi, SamanFaraon, Emerito Jose AFarzadfar, FarshadFay, Derek F JFeigin, Valery LFeigl, Andrea BFereshtehnejad, Seyed-MohammadFerrari, Alize JFerri, Cleusa PFlaxman, Abraham DFleming, Thomas DFoigt, NataliyaForeman, Kyle JPaleo, Urbano FraFranklin, Richard CGabbe, BelindaGaffikin, LynneGakidou, EmmanuelaGamkrelidze, AmiranGankpé, Fortuné GGansevoort, Ron TGarcía-Guerra, Francisco AGasana, EvaristeGeleijnse, Johanna MGessner, Bradford DGething, PeteGibney, Katherine BGillum, Richard FGinawi, Ibrahim A MGiroud, MauriceGiussani, GiorgiaGoenka, ShifalikaGoginashvili, KetevanGomez Dantes, HectorGona, PhilimonGonzalez de Cosio, TeresitaGonzález-Castell, DinorahGotay, Carolyn CGoto, AtsushiGouda, Hebe NGuerrant, Richard LGugnani, Harish CGuillemin, FrancisGunnell, DavidGupta, RahulGupta, RajeevGutiérrez, Reyna AHafezi-Nejad, NimaHagan, HollyHagstromer, MariaHalasa, Yara AHamadeh, Randah RHammami, MouhanadHankey, Graeme JHao, YuantaoHarb, Hilda LHaregu, Tilahun NigatuHaro, Josep MariaHavmoeller, RasmusHay, Simon IHedayati, Mohammad THeredia-Pi, Ileana BHernandez, LuciaHeuton, Kyle RHeydarpour, PouriaHijar, MarthaHoek, Hans WHoffman, Howard JHornberger, John CHosgood, H DeanHoy, Damian GHsairi, MohamedHu, GuoqingHu, HowardHuang, ChengHuang, John JHubbell, Bryan JHuiart, LaetitiaHusseini, AbdullatifIannarone, Marissa LIburg, Kim MIdrisov, Bulat TIkeda, NayuInnos, KaireInoue, ManamiIslami, FarhadIsmayilova, SamayaJacobsen, Kathryn HJansen, Henrica AJarvis, Deborah LJassal, Simerjot KJauregui, AlejandraJayaraman, SudhaJeemon, PanniyammakalJensen, Paul NJha, VivekanandJiang, FanJiang, GuohongJiang, YingJonas, Jost BJuel, KnudKan, HaidongKany Roseline, Sidibe SKaram, Nadim EKarch, AndréKarema, Corine KKarthikeyan, GanesanKaul, AnilKawakami, NoritoKazi, Dhruv SKemp, Andrew HKengne, Andre PKeren, AndreKhader, Yousef SKhalifa, Shams Eldin Ali HassanKhan, Ejaz AKhang, Young-HoKhatibzadeh, ShahabKhonelidze, IrmaKieling, ChristianKim, DanielKim, SungroulKim, YunjinKimokoti, Ruth WKinfu, YohannesKinge, Jonas MKissela, Brett MKivipelto, MiiaKnibbs, Luke DKnudsen, Ann KristinKokubo, YoshihiroKose, M RifatKosen, SoewartaKraemer, AlexanderKravchenko, MichaelKrishnaswami, SanjayKromhout, HansKu, TiffanyKuate Defo, BarthelemyKucuk Bicer, BurcuKuipers, Ernst JKulkarni, ChandaKulkarni, Veena SKumar, G AnilKwan, Gene FLai, TaaviLakshmana Balaji, ArjunLalloo, RatilalLallukka, TeaLam, HiltonLan, QingLansingh, Van CLarson, Heidi JLarsson, AndersLaryea, Dennis OLavados, Pablo MLawrynowicz, Alicia ELeasher, Janet LLee, Jong-TaeLeigh, JamesLeung, RickyLevi, MiriamLi, YichongLi, YongmeiLiang, JuanLiang, XiaofengLim, Stephen SLindsay, M PatriceLipshultz, Steven ELiu, ShiweiLiu, YangLloyd, Belinda KLogroscino, GiancarloLondon, Stephanie JLopez, NancyLortet-Tieulent, JoannieLotufo, Paulo ALozano, RafaelLunevicius, RaimundasMa, JixiangMa, StefanMachado, Vasco M PMacIntyre, Michael FMagis-Rodriguez, CarlosMahdi, Abbas AMajdan, MarekMalekzadeh, RezaMangalam, SrikanthMapoma, Christopher CMarape, MarapeMarcenes, WagnerMargolis, David JMargono, ChristopherMarks, Guy BMartin, Randall VMarzan, Melvin BMashal, Mohammad TMasiye, FelixMason-Jones, Amanda JMatsushita, KunihiroMatzopoulos, RichardMayosi, Bongani MMazorodze, Tasara TMcKay, Abigail CMcKee, MartinMcLain, AbigailMeaney, Peter AMedina, CatalinaMehndiratta, Man MohanMejia-Rodriguez, FabiolaMekonnen, WubegzierMelaku, Yohannes AMeltzer, MicheleMemish, Ziad AMendoza, WalterMensah, George AMeretoja, AtteMhimbira, Francis ApolinaryMicha, RenataMiller, Ted RMills, Edward JMisganaw, AwokeMishra, SantoshMohamed Ibrahim, NorlinahMohammad, Karzan AMokdad, Ali HMola, Glen LMonasta, LorenzoMontañez Hernandez, Julio CMontico, MarcellaMoore, Ami RMorawska, LidiaMori, RintaroMoschandreas, JoannaMoturi, Wilkister NMozaffarian, DariushMueller, Ulrich OMukaigawara, MitsuruMullany, Erin CMurthy, Kinnari SNaghavi, MohsenNahas, ZiadNaheed, AliyaNaidoo, Kovin SNaldi, LuigiNand, DevinaNangia, VinayNarayan, K M VenkatNash, DenisNeal, BruceNejjari, ChakibNeupane, Sudan PNewton, Charles RNgalesoni, Frida NNgirabega, Jean de DieuNguyen, GrantNguyen, Nhung TNieuwenhuijsen, Mark JNisar, Muhammad INogueira, José RNolla, Joan MNolte, SandraNorheim, Ole FNorman, Rosana ENorrving, BoNyakarahuka, LukeOh, In-HwanOhkubo, TakayoshiOlusanya, Bolajoko OOmer, Saad BOpio, John NelsonOrozco, RicardoPagcatipunan, Rodolfo S, JrPain, Amanda WPandian, Jeyaraj DPanelo, Carlo Irwin APapachristou, ChristinaPark, Eun-KeeParry, Charles DPaternina Caicedo, Angel JPatten, Scott BPaul, Vinod KPavlin, Boris IPearce, NeilPedraza, Lilia SPedroza, AndreaPejin Stokic, LjiljanaPekericli, AyferPereira, David MPerez-Padilla, RogelioPerez-Ruiz, FernandoPerico, NorbertoPerry, Samuel A LPervaiz, AslamPesudovs, KonradPeterson, Carrie BPetzold, MaxPhillips, Michael RPhua, Hwee PinPlass, DietrichPoenaru, DanPolanczyk, Guilherme VPolinder, SuzannePond, Constance DPope, C ArdenPope, DanielPopova, SvetlanaPourmalek, FarshadPowles, JohnPrabhakaran, DorairajPrasad, Noela MQato, Dima MQuezada, Amado DQuistberg, D Alex ARacapé, LionelRafay, AnwarRahimi, KazemRahimi-Movaghar, VafaRahman, Sajjad UrRaju, MurugesanRakovac, IvoRana, Saleem MRao, MayureeRazavi, HomieReddy, K SrinathRefaat, Amany HRehm, JürgenRemuzzi, GiuseppeRibeiro, Antonio LRiccio, Patricia MRichardson, LeeRiederer, AnneRobinson, MargaretRoca, AnnaRodriguez, AlinaRojas-Rueda, DavidRomieu, IsabelleRonfani, LucaRoom, RobinRoy, NobhojitRuhago, George MRushton, LesleySabin, NsanzimanaSacco, Ralph LSaha, SukantaSahathevan, RameshSahraian, Mohammad AliSalomon, Joshua ASalvo, DeborahSampson, Uchechukwu KSanabria, Juan RSanchez, Luz MariaSánchez-Pimienta, Tania GSanchez-Riera, LidiaSandar, LoganSantos, Itamar SSapkota, AmirSatpathy, MaheswarSaunders, James ESawhney, MonikaSaylan, Mete IScarborough, PeterSchmidt, Jürgen CSchneider, Ione J CSchöttker, BenSchwebel, David CScott, James GSeedat, SorayaSepanlou, Sadaf GSerdar, BerrinServan-Mori, Edson EShaddick, GavinShahraz, SaeidLevy, Teresa ShamahShangguan, SiyiShe, JunSheikhbahaei, SaraShibuya, KenjiShin, Hwashin HShinohara, YukitoShiri, RahmanShishani, KawkabShiue, IvySigfusdottir, Inga DSilberberg, Donald HSimard, Edgar PSindi, ShireenSingh, AbhishekSingh, Gitanjali MSingh, Jasvinder ASkirbekk, VegardSliwa, KarenSoljak, MichaelSoneji, SamirSøreide, KjetilSoshnikov, SergeySposato, Luciano ASreeramareddy, Chandrashekhar TStapelberg, Nicolas J CStathopoulou, VasilikiSteckling, NadineStein, Dan JStein, Murray BStephens, NatalieStöckl, HeidiStraif, KurtStroumpoulis, KonstantinosSturua, LelaSunguya, Bruno FSwaminathan, SoumyaSwaroop, MamtaSykes, Bryan LTabb, Karen MTakahashi, KenTalongwa, Roberto TTandon, NikhilTanne, DavidTanner, MarcelTavakkoli, MohammadTe Ao, Braden JTeixeira, Carolina MTéllez Rojo, Martha MTerkawi, Abdullah STexcalac-Sangrador, José LuisThackway, Sarah VThomson, BlakeThorne-Lyman, Andrew LThrift, Amanda GThurston, George DTillmann, TaaviTobollik, MyriamTonelli, MarcelloTopouzis, FotisTowbin, Jeffrey AToyoshima, HideakiTraebert, JeffersonTran, Bach XTrasande, LeonardoTrillini, MatiasTrujillo, UlisesDimbuene, Zacharie TsalaTsilimbaris, MiltiadisTuzcu, Emin MuratUchendu, Uche SUkwaja, Kingsley NUzun, Selen Bvan de Vijver, StevenVan Dingenen, Ritavan Gool, Coen Hvan Os, JimVarakin, Yuri YVasankari, Tommi JVasconcelos, Ana Maria NVavilala, Monica SVeerman, Lennert JVelasquez-Melendez, GustavoVenketasubramanian, NVijayakumar, LakshmiVillalpando, SalvadorViolante, Francesco SVlassov, Vasiliy VictorovichVollset, Stein EmilWagner, Gregory RWaller, Stephen GWallin, Mitchell TWan, XiaWang, HaidongWang, JianLiWang, LinhongWang, WenzhiWang, YanpingWarouw, Tati SWatts, Charlotte HWeichenthal, ScottWeiderpass, ElisabeteWeintraub, Robert GWerdecker, AndreaWessells, K RyanWesterman, RonnyWhiteford, Harvey AWilkinson, James DWilliams, Hywel CWilliams, Thomas NWoldeyohannes, Solomon MWolfe, Charles D AWong, John QWoolf, Anthony DWright, Jonathan LWurtz, BrittanyXu, GelinYan, Lijing LYang, GonghuanYano, YuichiroYe, PengpengYenesew, MulukenYentür, Gökalp KYip, PaulYonemoto, NaohiroYoon, Seok-JunYounis, Mustafa ZYounoussi, ZourkaleiniYu, ChuanhuaZaki, Maysaa EZhao, YongZheng, YingfengZhou, MaigengZhu, JunZhu, ShankuanZou, XiaonongZunt, Joseph RLopez, Alan DVos, TheoMurray, Christopher J
Source
The Lancet. 386(10010):2287-2323
Subject
Language
English
ISSN
0140-6736
1474-547X
Abstract
BACKGROUND: The Global Burden of Disease, Injuries, and Risk Factor study 2013 (GBD 2013) is the first of a series of annual updates of the GBD. Risk factor quantification, particularly of modifiable risk factors, can help to identify emerging threats to population health and opportunities for prevention. The GBD 2013 provides a timely opportunity to update the comparative risk assessment with new data for exposure, relative risks, and evidence on the appropriate counterfactual risk distribution.METHODS: Attributable deaths, years of life lost, years lived with disability, and disability-adjusted life-years (DALYs) have been estimated for 79 risks or clusters of risks using the GBD 2010 methods. Risk-outcome pairs meeting explicit evidence criteria were assessed for 188 countries for the period 1990-2013 by age and sex using three inputs: risk exposure, relative risks, and the theoretical minimum risk exposure level (TMREL). Risks are organised into a hierarchy with blocks of behavioural, environmental and occupational, and metabolic risks at the first level of the hierarchy. The next level in the hierarchy includes nine clusters of related risks and two individual risks, with more detail provided at levels 3 and 4 of the hierarchy. Compared with GBD 2010, six new risk factors have been added: handwashing practices, occupational exposure to trichloroethylene, childhood wasting, childhood stunting, unsafe sex, and low glomerular filtration rate. For most risks, data for exposure were synthesised with a Bayesian meta-regression method, DisMod-MR 2.0, or spatial-temporal Gaussian process regression. Relative risks were based on meta-regressions of published cohort and intervention studies. Attributable burden for clusters of risks and all risks combined took into account evidence on the mediation of some risks such as high body-mass index (BMI) through other risks such as high systolic blood pressure and high cholesterol.FINDINGS: All risks combined account for 57·2% (95% uncertainty interval [UI] 55·8-58·5) of deaths and 41·6% (40·1-43·0) of DALYs. Risks quantified account for 87·9% (86·5-89·3) of cardiovascular disease DALYs, ranging to a low of 0% for neonatal disorders and neglected tropical diseases and malaria. In terms of global DALYs in 2013, six risks or clusters of risks each caused more than 5% of DALYs: dietary risks accounting for 11·3 million deaths and 241·4 million DALYs, high systolic blood pressure for 10·4 million deaths and 208·1 million DALYs, child and maternal malnutrition for 1·7 million deaths and 176·9 million DALYs, tobacco smoke for 6·1 million deaths and 143·5 million DALYs, air pollution for 5·5 million deaths and 141·5 million DALYs, and high BMI for 4·4 million deaths and 134·0 million DALYs. Risk factor patterns vary across regions and countries and with time. In sub-Saharan Africa, the leading risk factors are child and maternal malnutrition, unsafe sex, and unsafe water, sanitation, and handwashing. In women, in nearly all countries in the Americas, north Africa, and the Middle East, and in many other high-income countries, high BMI is the leading risk factor, with high systolic blood pressure as the leading risk in most of Central and Eastern Europe and south and east Asia. For men, high systolic blood pressure or tobacco use are the leading risks in nearly all high-income countries, in north Africa and the Middle East, Europe, and Asia. For men and women, unsafe sex is the leading risk in a corridor from Kenya to South Africa.INTERPRETATION: Behavioural, environmental and occupational, and metabolic risks can explain half of global mortality and more than one-third of global DALYs providing many opportunities for prevention. Of the larger risks, the attributable burden of high BMI has increased in the past 23 years. In view of the prominence of behavioural risk factors, behavioural and social science research on interventions for these risks should be strengthened. Many prevention and primary care policy options are available now to act on key risks.FUNDING: Bill & Melinda Gates Foundation.