학술논문

A multi-country test of brief reappraisal interventions on emotions during the COVID-19 pandemic
Document Type
Original Paper
Author
Wang, KeGoldenberg, AmitDorison, Charles A.Miller, Jeremy K.Uusberg, AnderoLerner, Jennifer S.Gross, James J.Agesin, Bamikole BamikoleBernardo, MárciaCampos, OlatzEudave, LuisGrzech, KarolinaOzery, Daphna HausmanJackson, Emily A.Garcia, Elkin Oswaldo LuisDrexler, Shira MeirJurković, Anita PenićRana, KafeelWilson, John PaulAntoniadi, MariaDesai, KermekaGialitaki, ZoiKushnir, ElizavetaNadif, KhaoulaBravo, Olalla NiñoNauman, RafiaOosterlinck, MarliesPantazi, MyrtoPilecka, NataliaSzabelska, Annavan Steenkiste, I. M. M.Filip, KatarzynaBozdoc, Andreea IoanaMarcu, Gabriela MarianaAgadullina, ElenaAdamkovič, MatúšRoczniewska, MartaReyna, CeciliaKassianos, Angelos P.Westerlund, MinjaAhlgren, LinaPöntinen, SaraAdetula, Gabriel AgboolaDursun, PinarArinze, Azuka IkechukwuArinze, Nwadiogo ChisomOgbonnaya, Chisom EstherNdukaihe, Izuchukwu L. G.Dalgar, IlkerAkkas, HandanMacapagal, Paulo ManuelLewis, SavannahMetin-Orta, IremForoni, FrancescoWillis, MeganSantos, Anabela CaetanoMokady, AvivReggev, NivKurfali, Merve A.Vasilev, Martin R.Nock, Nora L.Parzuchowski, MichalEspinoza Barría, Mauricio F.Vranka, MarekKohlová, Markéta BraunRopovik, IvanHarutyunyan, MikayelWang, ChunhuiYao, ElvinBecker, MajaManunta, EfisioKaminski, GwenaelBoudesseu, JordaneMarko, DafneEvans, KortneeLewis, David M. G.Findor, AndrejLandry, Anais ThibaultAruta, John Jamir BenzonOrtiz, Manuel S.Vally, ZahirPronizius, EkaterinaVoracek, MartinLamm, ClausGrinberg, MauriceLi, RanranValentova, Jaroslava VarellaMioni, GiovannaCellini, NicolaChen, Sau-ChinZickfeld, JanisMoon, KarisAzab, HabibaLevy, NeilKarababa, AlperBeaudry, Jennifer L.Boucher, LeanneCollins, W. MatthewTodsen, Anna Louisevan Schie, KevinVintr, JáchymBavolar, JozefKaliska, LadaKrižanić, ValerijaSamojlenko, LaraPourafshari, RaziehGeiger, Sandra J.Beitner, JuliaWarmelink, LaraRoss, Robert M.Stephen, Ian D.Hostler, Thomas J.Azouaghe, SoufianMcCarthy, RandySzala, AnnaGrano, CaterinaSolorzano, Claudio SinghAnjum, GulnazJimenez-Leal, WilliamBradford, MariaPérez, Laura CalderónCruz Vásquez, Julio E.Galindo-Caballero, Oscar J.Vargas-Nieto, Juan CamiloKácha, OndřejArvanitis, AlexiosXiao, QinyuCárcamo, RodrigoZorjan, SašaTajchman, ZuzannaVilares, IrisPavlacic, Jeffrey M.Kunst, Jonas R.Tamnes, Christian K.von Bastian, Claudia C.Atari, MohammadSharifian, MohammadHasanHricova, MonikaKačmár, PavolSchrötter, JanaRahal, Rima-MariaCohen, NogaFatahModares, SaeidehZrimsek, MihaZakharov, IlyaKoehn, Monica A.Esteban-Serna, CeliaCalin-Jageman, Robert J.Krafnick, Anthony J.Štrukelj, EvaIsager, Peder MortvedtUrban, JanSilva, Jaime R.Martončik, MarcelOčovaj, Sanja BatićŠakan, DušanaKuzminska, Anna O.Djordjevic, Jasna MilosevicAlmeida, Inês A. T.Ferreira, AnaLazarevic, Ljiljana B.Manley, HarryRicaurte, Danilo ZambranoMonteiro, Renan P.Etabari, ZahraMusser, EricaDunleavy, DanielChou, WeilunGodbersen, HendrikRuiz-Fernández, SusanaReeck, CrystalBatres, CarlotaKirgizova, KomilaMuminov, AbdumalikAzevedo, FlavioAlvarez, Daniela SerratoButt, Muhammad MussaffaLee, Jeong MinChen, ZhangVerbruggen, FrederickZiano, IgnazioTümer, MuratCharyate, Abdelilah C. A.Dubrov, DmitriiTejada Rivera, María del Carmen M. C.Aberson, ChristopherPálfi, BenceMaldonado, Mónica AlarcónHubena, BarboraSacakli, AsliCeary, Chris D.Richard, Karley L.Singer, GagePerillo, Jennifer T.Ballantyne, ToniaCyrus-Lai, WilsonFedotov, MaksimDu, HongfeiWielgus, MagdalenaPit, Ilse L.Hruška, MatejSousa, DanielaAczel, BalazsHajdu, NandorSzaszi, BarnabasAdamus, SylwiaBarzykowski, KrystianMicheli, LeticiaSchmidt, Nadya-DanielaZsido, Andras N.Paruzel-Czachura, MariolaMuda, RafałBialek, MichalKowal, MartaSorokowska, AgnieszkaMisiak, MichalMola, DéboraOrtiz, María VictoriaCorrea, Pablo SebastiánBelaus, AnabelMuchembled, FanyRibeiro, Rafael R.Arriaga, PatriciaOliveira, RaquelVaughn, Leigh AnnSzwed, PaulinaKossowska, MałgorzataCzarnek, GabrielaKielińska, JulitaAntazo, BenedictBetlehem, RubenStieger, StefanNilsonne, GustavSimonovic, NicolleTaber, JenniferGourdon-Kanhukamwe, AmélieDomurat, ArturIhaya, KeikoYamada, YukiUrooj, AnumGill, TripatČadek, MartinBylinina, LisaMesserschmidt, JohannaKurfalı, MurathanAdetula, AdeyemiBaklanova, EkaterinaAlbayrak-Aydemir, NihanKappes, Heather B.Gjoneska, BiljanaHouse, TheaJones, Marc V.Berkessel, Jana B.Chopik, William J.Çoksan, SamiSeehuus, MartinKhaoudi, AhmedBokkour, AhmedEl Arabi, Kanza AitDjamai, IkhlasIyer, AishwaryaParashar, NehaAdiguzel, ArcaKocalar, Halil EmreBundt, CarstenNorton, James O.Papadatou-Pastou, MariettaDe la Rosa-Gomez, AnabelAnkushev, VladislavBogatyreva, NataliaGrigoryev, DmitryIvanov, AleksandrPrusova, IrinaRomanova, MarinaSarieva, IrenaTerskova, MariaHristova, EvgeniyaKadreva, Veselina HristovaJanak, AllisonSchei, VidarSverdrup, Therese E.Askelund, Adrian DahlPineda, Lina Maria SanabriaKrupić, DajanaLevitan, Carmel A.Johannes, NiklasOuherrou, NihalSay, NicolasSinkolova, SladjanaJanjić, KristinaStojanovska, MarijaStojanovska, DraganaKhosla, MeetuThomas, Andrew G.Kung, Franki Y. H.Bijlstra, GijsbertMosannenzadeh, FarnazBalci, Busra BaharReips, Ulf-DietrichBaskin, ErnestIshkhanyan, ByuraknCzamanski-Cohen, JohannaDixson, Barnaby James WyldMoreau, DavidSutherland, Clare A. M.Chuan-Peng, HuNoone, ChrisFlowe, HeatherAnne, MicheleJanssen, Steve M. J.Topor, MartaMajeed, Nadyanna M.Kunisato, YoshihikoYu, KarenDaches, ShimritHartanto, AndreeVdovic, MilicaAnton-Boicuk, LisaForbes, Paul A. G.Kamburidis, JuliaMarinova, EvelinaNedelcheva-Datsova, MinaRachev, Nikolay R.Stoyanova, AlinaSchmidt, KathleenSuchow, Jordan W.Koptjevskaja-Tamm, MariaJernsäther, TeodorOlofsson, Jonas K.Bialobrzeska, OlgaMarszalek, MagdalenaTatachari, SrinivasanAfhami, RezaLaw, WilbertAntfolk, JanŽuro, BarbaraVan Doren, NataliaSoto, Jose A.Searston, RachelMiranda, JacobDamnjanović, KajaYeung, Siu KitKrupić, DinoHoyer, KarlijnJaeger, BastianRen, DongningPfuhl, GeritKlevjer, KristofferCorral-Frías, Nadia S.Frias-Armenta, MarthaLucas, Marc Y.Torres, Adriana OlayaToro, MónicaDelgado, Lady Grey JavelaVega, DiegoSolas, Sara ÁlvarezVilar, RooseveltMassoni, SébastienFrizzo, ThomasBran, AlexandreVaidis, David C.Vieira, LucParis, BastienCapizzi, MariagraziaCoelho, Gabriel Lins de HolandaGreenburgh, AnnaWhitt, Cassie M.Tullett, Alexa M.Du, XinkaiVolz, LeonhardBosma, Minke JasmijnKaraarslan, CemreSarıoğuz, EylülAllred, Tara BulutKorbmacher, MaxColloff, Melissa F.Lima, Tiago J. S.Ribeiro, Matheus Fernando FelixVerharen, Jeroen P. H.Karekla, MariaKarashiali, ChristianaSunami, NaoyukiJaremka, Lisa M.Storage, DanielHabib, SumaiyaStudzinska, AnnaHanel, Paul H. P.Holford, Dawn LiuSirota, MiroslavWolfe, KellyChiu, FaithTheodoropoulou, AndrianaAhn, El RimLin, YijunWestgate, Erin C.Brohmer, HilmarHofer, GabrielaDujols, OlivierVezirian, KevinFeldman, GiladTravaglino, Giovanni A.Ahmed, AfrojaLi, ManyuBosch, JasmijnTorunsky, NathanBai, HuiManavalan, MathiSong, XinWalczak, Radoslaw B.Zdybek, PrzemysławFriedemann, MajaRosa, Anna DallaKozma, LucaAlves, Sara G.Lins, SamuelPinto, Isabel R.Correia, Rita C.Babinčák, PeterBanik, GabrielRojas-Berscia, Luis MiguelVarella, Marco A. C.Uttley, JimBeshears, Julie E.Thommesen, Katrine KrabbeBehzadnia, BehzadGeniole, Shawn N.Silan, Miguel A.Maturan, Princess Lovella G.Vilsmeier, Johannes K.Tran, Ulrich S.Izquierdo, Sara MoralesMensink, Michael C.Sorokowski, PiotrGroyecka-Bernard, AgataRadtke, ThedaAdoric, Vera CubelaCarpentier, JoelleÖzdoğru, Asil AliJoy-Gaba, Jennifer A.Hedgebeth, Mattie V.Ishii, TatsunoriWichman, Aaron L.Röer, Jan PhilippOstermann, ThomasDavis, William E.Suter, LilianPapachristopoulos, KonstantinosZabel, ChelseaOnie, SandersanEbersole, Charles R.Chartier, Christopher R.Mallik, Peter R.Urry, Heather L.Buchanan, Erin M.Coles, Nicholas A.Primbs, Maximilian A.Basnight-Brown, Dana M.IJzerman, HansForscher, Patrick S.Moshontz, Hannah
Source
Nature Human Behaviour. 5(8):1089-1110
Subject
Language
English
ISSN
2397-3374
Abstract
The COVID-19 pandemic has increased negative emotions and decreased positive emotions globally. Left unchecked, these emotional changes might have a wide array of adverse impacts. To reduce negative emotions and increase positive emotions, we tested the effectiveness of reappraisal, an emotion-regulation strategy that modifies how one thinks about a situation. Participants from 87 countries and regions (n = 21,644) were randomly assigned to one of two brief reappraisal interventions (reconstrual or repurposing) or one of two control conditions (active or passive). Results revealed that both reappraisal interventions (vesus both control conditions) consistently reduced negative emotions and increased positive emotions across different measures. Reconstrual and repurposing interventions had similar effects. Importantly, planned exploratory analyses indicated that reappraisal interventions did not reduce intentions to practice preventive health behaviours. The findings demonstrate the viability of creating scalable, low-cost interventions for use around the world.Protocol registration: The stage 1 protocol for this Registered Report was accepted in principle on 12 May 2020. The protocol, as accepted by the journal, can be found at https://doi.org/10.6084/m9.figshare.c.4878591.v1
This Registered Report presents evidence from 87 countries and regions showing that brief emotion-regulation interventions consistently reduced negative emotions and increased positive emotions during the COVID-19 pandemic.