학술논문

Mechanical ventilation in patients with cardiogenic pulmonary edema: a sub-analysis of the LUNG SAFE study
Document Type
Clinical report
Author
Amado-Rodríguez, LauraRodríguez-Garcia, RaquelBellani, GiacomoPham, TàiFan, EddyMadotto, FabianaLaffey, John G.Albaiceta, Guillermo M.Pesenti, AntonioBrochard, LaurentEsteban, AndresGattinoni, Lucianovan Haren, FrankLarsson, AndersMcAuley, DanielFRanieri, MarcoRubenfeld, GordonTaylor Thompson, B.Wrigge, HermannSlutsky, Arthur S.Rios, FernandoVan Haren, FrankSottiaux, ThierryDepuydt, PieterLora, Fredy S.Azevedo, Luciano CesarBugedo, GuillermoQiu, HaiboGonzalez, MarcosSilesky, JuanCerny, VladimirNielsen, JonasJibaja, ManuelWrigge, HermannMatamis, DimitriosRanero, Jorge LuisAmin, PravinHashemian, S. M.Clarkson, KevinKurahashi, KiyoyasuVillagomez, AsiscloZeggwagh, Amine AliHeunks, Leo M.Laake, Jon HenrikPalo, Jose Emmanueldo Vale Fernandes, AnteroSandesc, DorelArabi, YaasenBumbasierevic, VesnaNin, NicolasLorente, Jose A.Larsson, AndersPiquilloud, LiseAbroug, FekriMcAuley, DanielFMcNamee, LiaHurtado, JavierBajwa, EdDémpaire, GabrielSula, HektorNunci, LordianCani, AlmaZazu, AlanDellera, ChristianInsaurralde, Carolina S.Las Lomas, SanatorioIsidro, SanAlejandro, Risso V.Daldin, JulioVinzio, MauricioFernandez, Ruben O.Cardonnet, Luis P.Bettini, Lisandro R.Bisso, Mariano CarboniOsman, Emilio M.Setten, Mariano G.Lovazzano, PabloAlvarez, JavierVillar, VeronicaPozo, Norberto C.Grubissich, NicolasPlotnikow, Gustavo A.Vasquez, Daniela N.Ilutovich, SantiagoTiribelli, NorbertoChena, ArielPellegrini, Carlos A.Saenz, María G.Estenssoro, ElisaBrizuela, MatiasGianinetto, HernanGomez, Pablo E.Cerrato, Valeria I.Bezzi, Marco G.Borello, Silvina A.Loiacono, Flavia A.Fernandez, Adriana M.Knowles, SerenaReynolds, ClaireInskip, Deborah M.Miller, Jennene J.Kong, JingWhitehead, ChristinaBihari, ShaileshSeven, AylinKrstevski, AmandaRodgers, Helen J.Millar, Rebecca T.McKenna, Toni E.Bailey, Irene M.Hanlon, Gabrielle C.Aneman, AndersLynch, Joan M.Azad, RamanNeal, JohnWoods, Paul W.Roberts, Brigit L.Kol, Mark R.Wong, Helen S.Riss, Katharina C.Staudinger, ThomasWittebole, XavierBerghe, CarolineBulpa, Pierre A.Dive, Alain M.Verstraete, RikLebbinck, HerveDepuydt, PieterVermassen, JorisMeersseman, PhilippeCeunen, HelgaRosa, JonasIBeraldo, Daniel O.Piras, ClaudioRampinelli, Adenilton M.Nassar Jr, Antonio P.Mataloun, SergioMoock, MarceloThompson, MarlusMGonçalves, Claudio H.Antônio, Ana Carolina P.Ascoli, AlineBiondi, Rodrigo S.Fontenele, Danielle C.Nobrega, DanielleSales, Vanessa M.BinHJAbul Wahab, Ahmad YazidIsmail, MaizatulShindhe, SureshLaffey, JohnBeloncle, FrancoisDavies, Kyle G.Cirone, RobManoharan, VenikaIsmail, MehvishGoligher, Ewan C.Jassal, MandeepNishikawa, ErinJaveed, AreejCurley, GerardRittayamai, NuttapolParotto, MatteoFerguson, Niall D.Mehta, SangeetaKnoll, JennyPronovost, AntoineCanestrini, SergioBruhn, Alejandro R.Garcia, Patricio H.Aliaga, Felipe A.Farías, Pamela A.Yumha, Jacob S.Ortiz, Claudia A.Salas, Javier E.Saez, Alejandro A.Vega, Luis D.Labarca, Eduardo F.Martinez, Felipe T.Carreéo, Nicolás G.Lora, PilarLiu, HaitaoQiu, HaiboLiu, LingTang, RuiLuo, XiaomingAn, YouzhongZhao, HuiyingGao, YanZhai, ZheYe, Zheng L.Wang, WeiLi, WenwenLi, QingdongZheng, RuiqiangYu, WenkuiShen, JuanhongLi, XinyuYu, TaoLu, WeihuaWu, Ya Q.Huang, Xiao B.He, ZhenyangLu, YuanhuaHan, HuiZhang, FanSun, RenhuaWang, Hua X.Qin, Shu H.Zhu, Bao H.Zhao, JunLiu, JianLi, BinLiu, Jing L.Zhou, Fa C.Li, Qiong J.Zhang, Xing YLi-Xin, ZhouXin-Hua, QiangJiang, LiangyanGao, Yuan N.Zhao, Xian Y.Li, Yuan Y.Li, Xiao L.Wang, ChuntingYao, QingchunYu, RongguoChen, KaiShao, HuanzhangQin, BingyuHuang, Qing Q.Zhu, Wei H.Hang, Ai Y.Hua, Ma X.Li, YiminXu, YonghaoDi, Yu D.Ling, Long L.Qin, Tie H.Wang, ShouHQin, JunpingHan, YiZhou, SumingVargas, Monica P.Jimenez, Juan I. SileskyRojas, Manuel A. GonzálezSolisQuesada, Jaime E.Ramirez-Alfaro, ChristianMMáca, JanSklienka, PeterGjedsted, JakobChristiansen, AageNielsen, JonasVillamagua, BorisGLlano, IguelBurtin, PhilippeBuzancais, GautierBeuret, PascalPelletier, NicolasMortaza, SatarMercat, AlainChelly, JonathanJochmans, SébastienTerzi, NicolasDaubin, CédricCarteaux, Guillaumede Prost, NicolasChiche, Jean-DanielDaviaud, FabriceFartoukh, MurielBarberet, GuillaumeBiehler, JeromeDellamonica, JeanDoyen, DenisArnal, Jean-MichelBriquet, AnaisHraiech, SamiPapazian, LaurentFollin, ArnaudRoux, DamienMessika, JonathanKalaitzis, EvangelosDangers, LaurenceCombes, AlainBéduneau, GaetanCarpentier, DorothéeZogheib, Elie H.Dupont, HerveRicome, SylvieSantoli, FrancescoLBesset, Sebastien L.Michel, PhilippeGelée, BrunoDanin, Pierre-EricGoubaux, BernardCrova, Philippe J.Phan, Nga T.Berkelmans, FrantzBadie, Julio C.Tapponnier, RomainGally, JosetteKhebbeb, SamyHerbrecht, Jean-EtienneSchneider, FrancisDeclercq, PierreLouis M.Rigaud, Jean-PhilippeDuranteau, JacquesHarrois, AnatoleChabanne, RussellMarin, JulienBigot, CharleneThibault, SandrineGhazi, MohammedBoukhazna, MessabiZein, Salem OuldRichecoeur, Jack R.Combaux, DanieleMGrelon, FabienLe Moal, CharleneSauvadet, ElisePRobine, AdrienLemiale, VirginieReuter, DanielleDres, MartinDemoule, AlexandreGoldgran-Toledano, DanyBaboi, LoredanaGuérin, ClaudeLohner, RalphKrassler, JensSchäfer, SusanneZacharowski, Kai D.Meybohm, PatrickReske, Andreas W.Simon, PhilippHopf, HansBernd F.Schuetz, MichaelBaltus, ThomasPapanikolaou, Metaxia N.Papavasilopoulou, Theonymfi G.Zacharas, Giannis A.Ourailogloy, VasilisMouloudi, Eleni K.Massa, Eleni V.Nagy, Eva O.Stamou, Electra E.Kiourtzieva, Ellada V.Oikonomou, Marina A.Avila, Luis E.Cortez, Cesar A.Citalán, Johanna E.Jog, Sameer A.Sable, Safal D.Shah, BhagyeshGurjar, MohanBaronia, Arvind K.Memon, MohammedfarukMuthuchellappan, RadhakrishnanRamesh, Venkatapura J.Shenoy, AnithaUnnikrishnan, RameshDixit, Subhal B.Rhayakar, RachanaVRamakrishnan, NagarajanBhardwaj, VallishKMahto, HeeraLSagar, Sudha V.Palaniswamy, VijayanandGanesan, DeebanHashemian, Seyed MohammadrezaJamaati, HamidrezaHeidari, FarshadMeaney, Edel A.Nichol, AlistairKnapman, Karl M.O'Croinin, DonallDunne, EimhinSBreen, Dorothy M.Clarkson, Kevin P.Jaafar, Rola F.Dwyer, RoryAmir, FahdAjetunmobi, Olaitan O.O'Muircheartaigh, Aogan C.Black, ColinSTreanor, NualaCollins, Daniel V.Altaf, WahidZani, GianlucaFusari, MaurizioSpadaro, SavinoVolta, Carlo A.Graziani, RomanoBrunettini, BarbaraPalmese, SalvatoreFormenti, PaoloUmbrello, MicheleLombardo, AndreaPecci, ElisabettaBotteri, MarcoSavioli, MonicaProtti, AlessandroMattei, AlessiaSchiavoni, LorenzoTinnirello, AndreaTodeschini, ManuelGiarratano, AntoninoCortegiani, AndreaSher, SaraRossi, AnnaAntonelli, Massimo M.Montini, Luca M.Casalena, PaoloScafetti, SergioPanarello, GiovannaOcchipinti, GiovannaPatroniti, NicolòPozzi, MatteoBiscione, RobertoRPoli, Michela M.Raimondi, FerdinandoAlbiero, DanielaCrapelli, GiuliaBeck, EduardoPota, VincenzoSchiavone, VincenzoMolin, AlexandreTarantino, FabioMonti, GiacomoFrati, ElenaMirabella, LuciaCinnella, GildaFossali, TommasoColombo, RiccardoTerragni, PierpaoloPattarino, IlariaMojoli, FrancescoBraschi, AntonioBorotto, Erika E.Cracchiolo, Andrea N.Palma, Daniela M.Raponi, FrancescoFoti, GiuseppeVascotto, EttoreRCoppadoro, AndreaBrazzi, LucaFloris, LedaIotti, Giorgio A.Venti, AaronYamaguchi, OsamuTakagi, ShunsukeMaeyama, Hiroki N.Watanabe, EizoYamaji, YoshihiroShimizu, KazuyoshiShiozaki, KyokoFutami, SatoruRyosuke, SekineSaito, KojiKameyama, YoshinobuUeno, KeikoIzawa, MasayoOkuda, NaoSuzuki, HiroyukiHarasawa, TomofumiNasu, MichitakaTakada, TadaakiIto, FumihitoNunomiya, ShinKoyama, KansukeAbe, ToshikazuAndoh, KohkichiKusumoto, KoheiHirata, AkiraTakaba, AkihiroKimura, HiroyasuMatsumoto, ShuheiHigashijima, UshioHonda, HiroyukiAoki, NobumasaImai, HiroshiOgino, YasuakiMizuguchi, IchikoIchikado, KazuyaNitta, KenichiMochizuki, KatsunoriHashida, TomoakiTanaka, HiroyukiNakamura, TomoyukiNiimi, DaisukeUeda, TakeshiKashiwa, YozoUchiyama, AkinoriSabelnikovs, OlegsOss, PeterisHaddad, YoussefLiew, Kong Y.Ãamendys-Silva, Silvio A.Jarquin-Badiola, YvesDSanchez-Hurtado, Luis A.Gomez-Flores, Saira S.Marin, Maria C.Villagomez, AsiscloJLemus, Jordana S.Fierro, Jonathan M.Cervantes, Mavy RamirezMejia, Francisco Javier FloresDector, DulceRojas, AlejandroGonzalez, Daniel R.Estrella, Claudia R.Sanchez-Medina, Jorge R.Ramirez-Gutierrez, AlvaroGeorge, Fernando G.Aguirre, Janet S.Buensuseso, Juan A.Poblano, ManuelDendane, TarekZeggwagh, Amine AliBalkhi, HichamElkhayari, MinaSamkaoui, NacerEzzouine, HananeBenslama, AbdellatifAmor, MouradMaazouzi, WajdiCimic, NedimBeck, OliverBruns, Monique M.Schouten, Jeroen A.Rinia, MyraRaaijmakers, MoniqueHeunks, Leo M.Van Wezel, Hellen M.Heines, SergeJStrauch, UlrichBuise, Marc P.Simonis, Fabienne D.Schultz, Marcus J.Goodson, Jennifer C.Browne, Troy S.Navarra, LeanloveHunt, AnnaHutchison, Robyn A.Bailey, Mathew B.Newby, LynetteMcArthur, ColinKalkoff, MichaelMcleod, AlexCasement, JonathanHacking, DanielleJAndersen, Finn H.Dolva, Merete S.Laake, Jon H.Barratt-Due, AndreasNoremark, Kim Andre L.Sareide, EldarSjaba, BritÃGuttormsen, AnneBLeonYoshido, Hector H.Aguilar, Ronald ZumaranOscanoa, Fredy A. MontesAlisasis, Alain U.Robles, Joanne B.Pasanting-Lim, Rossini Abbie B.Tan, Beatriz C.Andruszkiewicz, PawelJakubowska, KarinaCoxo, Cristina M.Alvarez, António M.Oliveira, Bruno S.Montanha, Gustavo M.Barros, Nelson C.Pereira, Carlos S.Messias, António M.Monteiro, Jorge M.Araujo, AnaMCatorze, NunoTMarum, Susan M.Bouw, Maria J.Gomes, Rui M.Brito, Vania A.Castro, SilviaEstilita, Joana M.Barros, Filipa M.Serra, IsabelMMartinho, Aurelia M.Tomescu, Dana R.Marcu, AlexandraBedreag, Ovidiu H.Papurica, MariusCorneci, Dan E.Negoita, Silvius IoanGrigoriev, EvgenyGritsan, Alexey I.Gazenkampf, Andrey A.Almekhlafi, GhalebAlbarrak, Mohamad M.Mustafa, Ghanem M.Maghrabi, Khalid A.Salahuddin, NawalAisa, Tharwat M.AlJabbary, AhmedSTabhan, EdgardoArabi, YaseenMArabi, Yaseen M.Trinidad, Olivia A.Al Dorzi, Hasan M.Tabhan, Edgardo E.Bumbasirevic, VesnaJovanovic, BojanBolon, StefanSmith, OliverMancebo, JordiAguirre-Bermeo, HernanLopez-Delgado, JuanCEsteve, FranciscoRialp, GemmaForteza, CatalinaDe Haro, CandelariaArtigas, AntonioAlbaiceta, GuillermoMDe Cima-Iglesias, SaraSeoane-Quiroga, LeticiaCeniceros-Barros, AlexandraRuizAguilar, AntonioLClaraco-Vega, LuisMSoler, Juan Alfonsodel CarmenLorente, MariaHermosa, CeciliaGordo, FedericoPrietoGonzález, MiryamLópez-Messa, JuanBPerez, ManuelPPerez, CesarPAllue, Raquel MontoiroRocheCampo, FerranIbaéez-Santacruz, MarcosTemprano, SusanaPintado, Maria C.De Pablo, RaulGómez, Pilar Ricart AroaRuiz, Silvia RodriguezMoles, Silvia IglesiasJurado, M. TeresaArizmendi, AlfonsPiacentini, Enrique A.Franco, NievesHonrubia, TeresaCheng, Meisy PerezLosada, Elena PerezBlanco, JavierYuste, Luis J.Carbayo-Gorriz, CeciliaCazorla-Barranquero, Francisca G.Alonso, Javier G.Alda, Rosa S.Algaba, ÃngelaNavarro, GonzaloCereijo, EnriqueDiaz-Rodriguez, EstherMarcos, Diego PastorMontero, Laura AlvarezPara, Luis HerreraSanchez, Roberto JimenezNavalpotro, Miguel Angel BlascoAbad, Ricardo DiazGonzález, Raquel MontielToribio, Dácil ParrillaCastro, Alejandro G.Artiga, Maria Jose D.Penuelas, OscarRoser, Tomas P.Olga, Moreno F.Curto, Elena GallegoSánchez, Rocío ManzanoImma, Vallverdu P.Elisabet, Garcia M.Claverias, LauraMagret, MonicaPellicer, Ana M.Rodriguez, Lucia L.Sánchez-Ballesteros, JesúsGonzález-Salamanca, ÃngelaJimenez, AntonioGHuerta, FranciscoPDiaz, Juan Carlos J. SotilloLopez, Esther BermejoMoya, David D. LlinaresAlfonso, Alec A. TalletLuis, Palazon Sanchez EugenioCesar, Palazon SanchezRafael, Sánchez I.Virgilio, CorcolesGRecio, NoeliaNAdamsson, Richard O.Rylander, Christian C.Holzgraefe, BernhardBroman, Lars MWessbergh, JoannaPersson, LinneaSchiöler, FredrikKedelv, HansTibblin, Anna OscarssonAppelberg, HenrikHedlund, LarsHelleberg, JohanEriksson, KarinEGlietsch, RitaLarsson, NiklasNygren, IngelaNunes, SilviaLMorin, Anna-KarinKander, ThomasAdolfsson, AnneZender, HervéOLeemann-Refondini, CorinneElatrous, SouheilBouchoucha, SlaheddineChouchene, ImedOuanes, IslemSouissi, Asma BenKamoun, SalmaDemirkiran, OktayAker, MustafaErbabacan, EmreCeylan, IlkayGirgin, Nermin KelebekOzcelik, MenekseÃnal, NecmettinMeco, Basak CeydaAkyol, OnatODerman, SuleymanSKennedy, BarryParhar, KenSrinivasa, LathaMcNamee, LiaMcAuley, DannyHopkins, PhilMellis, ClareKakar, VivekHadfield, DanVercueil, AndreBhowmick, KaushikHumphreys, Sally K.Ferguson, AndrewMckee, RaymondRaj, Ashok S.Fawkes, Danielle A.Watt, PhilipTwohey, LindaJha, Rajeev R.Thomas, MatthewMorton, AlexKadaba, VarshaSmith, Mark J.Hormis, Anil P.Kannan, Santhana G.Namih, MiriamReschreiter, HenrikCamsooksai, JulieKumar, AlekRugonfalvi, SzabolcsNutt, ChristopherOneill, OrlaSeasman, ColetteDempsey, GedScott, ChristopherJEllis, HelenEMckechnie, StuartHutton, PaulaJDi Tomasso, Nora N.Vitale, Michela N.Griffin, Ruth O.Dean, MichaelNCranshaw, JuliusHWillett, EmmaLIoannou, NicholasGillis, SarahCsabi, PeterMacfadyen, RosaleenDawson, HeidiPreez, PieterDWilliams, Alexandra JBoyd, Owende Gordoa, Laura Ortiz-RuizBramall, JonSymmonds, SophieChau, SimonKWenham, TimSzakmany, TamasToth-Tarsoly, PiroskaMcCalman, KatieHAlexander, PeterStephenson, LorraineCollyer, ThomasChapman, RhiannonCooper, RaphaelAllan, Russell MSim, MalcolmWrathall, David WIrvine, DonaldAZantua, Charing Kim S.Adams, John C.Burtenshaw, Andrew J.Sellors, Gareth P.Welters, Ingeborg D.Williams, Karen E.Hessell, Robert J.Oldroyd, Matthew G.Battle, Ceri E.Pillai, SureshKajtor, IstvanSivashanmugavel, MageswaranOkane, Sinead C.Donnelly, AdrianFrigyik, Aniko D.Careless, Jon P.May, Martin MStewart, RichardTrinder, T. JohnHagan, SamanthaJCole, JadeMMacFie, Caroline C.Dowling, AnnaTHurtado, JavierNin, NicolásHurtado, JavierNuéez, EdgardoPittini, GustavoRodriguez, RubenImperio, María C.Santos, CristinaFrança, Ana GEbeid, AlejandroDeicas, AlbertoSerra, CarolinaUppalapati, AdityaKamel, GhassanBannerGoodspeed, Valerie M.Beitler, Jeremy R.Mukkera, Satyanarayana ReddyKulkarni, ShreedharShinn III, John O.Gomaa, DinaTainter, ChristopherLee, JaroneMesar, TomazYeatts, DaleJWarren, JessicaLanspa, MichaelJMiller, Russel R.Grissom, ColinKBrown, SamuelMBauer, Philippe R.Gosselin, Ryan J.Kitch, Barrett T.Cohen, Jason E.Beegle, Scott H.Choudry, ShaziaGueret, Renaud M.Tulaimat, AimanStigler, WilliamBatra, HiteshHuff, Nidhi G.Lamb, Keith D.Oetting, Trevor W.Mohr, Nicholas M.Judy, ClaineSaito, ShigekiKheir, Fayez M.Kheir, FayezSchlichting, Adam B.Delsing, AngelaCrouch, Daniel R.Elmasri, MaryCrouch, Daniel R.Ismail, DinaDreyer, Kyle R.Blakeman, Thomas C.Gomaa, DinaBaro, Rebecca M.Hou, Peter C.Seethala, RaghuAisiku, ImoHenderson, GalenFrendl, GyorgyHou, Sen-KuangOwens, RobertLSchomer, Ashley
Source
Journal of Intensive Care. December 25, 2022, Vol. 10 Issue 1
Subject
United Kingdom
Language
English
ISSN
2052-0492
Abstract
Background Patients with acute respiratory failure caused by cardiogenic pulmonary edema (CPE) may require mechanical ventilation that can cause further lung damage. Our aim was to determine the impact of ventilatory settings on CPE mortality. Methods Patients from the LUNG SAFE cohort, a multicenter prospective cohort study of patients undergoing mechanical ventilation, were studied. Relationships between ventilatory parameters and outcomes (ICU discharge/hospital mortality) were assessed using latent mixture analysis and a marginal structural model. Results From 4499 patients, 391 meeting CPE criteria (median age 70 [interquartile range 59-78], 40% female) were included. ICU and hospital mortality were 34% and 40%, respectively. ICU survivors were younger (67 [57-77] vs 74 [64-80] years, p < 0.001) and had lower driving (12 [8-16] vs 15 [11-17] cmH.sub.2O, p < 0.001), plateau (20 [15-23] vs 22 [19-26] cmH.sub.2O, p < 0.001) and peak (21 [17-27] vs 26 [20-32] cmH.sub.2O, p < 0.001) pressures. Latent mixture analysis of patients receiving invasive mechanical ventilation on ICU day 1 revealed a subgroup ventilated with high pressures with lower probability of being discharged alive from the ICU (hazard ratio [HR] 0.79 [95% confidence interval 0.60-1.05], p = 0.103) and increased hospital mortality (HR 1.65 [1.16-2.36], p = 0.005). In a marginal structural model, driving pressures in the first week (HR 1.12 [1.06-1.18], p < 0.001) and tidal volume after day 7 (HR 0.69 [0.52-0.93], p = 0.015) were related to survival. Conclusions Higher airway pressures in invasively ventilated patients with CPE are related to mortality. These patients may be exposed to an increased risk of ventilator-induced lung injury. Trial registration Clinicaltrials.gov NCT02010073 Keywords: Mechanical ventilation, Cardiogenic pulmonary edema, Ventilator-induced lung injury, Driving pressure
Author(s): Laura Amado-Rodríguez[sup.1,2,3,4], Raquel Rodríguez-Garcia[sup.1,2,4], Giacomo Bellani[sup.5,6], Tài Pham[sup.7,8], Eddy Fan[sup.9,10], Fabiana Madotto[sup.11], John G. Laffey[sup.12,13], Guillermo M. Albaiceta[sup.1,2,3,4], Antonio Pesenti, Laurent Brochard, Andres Esteban, Luciano Gattinoni, Frank van Haren, [...]