학술논문

Death in hospital following ICU discharge: insights from the LUNG SAFE study
Document Type
Report
Author
Madotto, FabianaMcNicholas, BairbreRezoagli, EmanuelePham, TàiLaffey, John G.Bellani, GiacomoPesenti, AntonioBrochard, LaurentEsteban, AndresGattinoni, Lucianovan Haren, FrankRanieri, MarcoRubenfeld, GordonThompson, B. TaylorSlutsky, Arthur S.Rios, FernandoFaruq, Mohammad OmarSottiaux, T.Depuydt, P.Lora, Fredy S.Azevedo, Cesar CesarFan, EddyBugedo, GuillermoQiu, HaiboGonzalez, MarcosSilesky, JuanCerny, VladimirNielsen, JonasJibaja, ManuelWrigge, HermannMatamis, DimitriosRanero, Jorge LuisGomersall, CharlesAmin, PravinHashemian, S. M.Clarkson, KevinKurahashi, KiyoyasuKoh, YounsuckVillagomez, AsiscloZeggwagh, Amine AliHeunks, Leo M.Laake, Jon HenrikKashif, WaqarSynclair, JorgePalo, Jose Emmanueldo Vale Fernandes, AnteroSandesc, DorelArabi, YaasenBumbasierevic, VesnaNin, NicolasLorente, Jose A.Larsson, AndersPiquilloud, LisePatjanasoontorn, BoonsongAbroug, FekriMcAuley, Daniel F.McNamee, LiaHurtado, JavierBajwa, EdDémpaire, GabrielFrancois, Guy M.Rabboni, FrancescaConti, SaraSula, HektorNunci, LordianCani, AlmaZazu, AlanDellera, ChristianInsaurralde, Carolina S.Alejandro, Risso V.Daldin, JulioVinzio, MauricioFernandez, Ruben O.Cardonnet, Luis P.Bettini, Lisandro R.Bisso, Mariano CarboniOsman, Emilio M.Setten, Mariano G.Lovazzano, PabloAlvarez, JavierVillar, VeronicaPozo, Norberto C.Grubissich, NicolasPlotnikow, Gustavo A.Vasquez, Daniela N.Ilutovich, SantiagoTiribelli, NorbertoChena, ArielPellegrini, Carlos A.Saenz, María G.Estenssoro, ElisaBrizuela, MatiasGianinetto, HernanGomez, Pablo E.Cerrato, Valeria I.Bezzi, Marco G.Borello, Silvina A.Loiacono, Flavia A.Fernandez, Adriana M.Knowles, SerenaReynolds, ClaireInskip, Deborah M.Miller, Jennene J.Kong, JingWhitehead, ChristinaBihari, ShaileshSeven, AylinKrstevski, AmandaRodgers, Helen J.Millar, Rebecca T.Mckenna, Toni E.Bailey, Irene M.Hanlon, Gabrielle C.Aneman, AndersLynch, Joan M.Azad, RamanNeal, JohnWoods, Paul W.Roberts, Brigit L.Kol, Mark R.Wong, Helen S.Riss, Katharina C.Staudinger, ThomasWittebole, XavierBerghe, CarolineBulpa, Pierre A.Dive, Alain M.Verstraete, RikLebbinck, HerveDepuydt, PieterVermassen, JorisMeersseman, PhilippeCeunen, HelgaRosa, Jonas I.Beraldo, Daniel O.Piras, ClaudioRampinelli, Adenilton M.Nassar, é P.Mataloun, SergioMoock, MarceloThompson, Marlus M.Gonçalves, Claudio H.Antônio, Ana Carolina P.Ascoli, AlineBiondi, Rodrigo S.Fontenele, Danielle C.Nobrega, DanielleSales, Vanessa M.Shindhe, SureshAiman, Dk MaizatulIsmail, BPg HjLaffey, JohnBeloncle, FrancoisDavies, Kyle G.Cirone, RobManoharan, VenikaIsmail, MehvishGoligher, Ewan C.Jassal, MandeepFerguson, Niall D.Nishikawa, ErinJaveed, AreejCurley, GerardRittayamai, NuttapolParotto, MatteoMehta, SangeetaKnoll, JennyPronovost, AntoineCanestrini, SergioBruhn, Alejandro R.Garcia, Patricio H.Aliaga, Felipe A.Farías, Pamela A.Yumha, Jacob S.Ortiz, Claudia A.Salas, Javier E.Saez, Alejandro A.Vega, Luis D.Labarca, Eduardo F.Martinez, Felipe T.Carreéo, Nicolás G.Lora, PilarLiu, HaitaoLiu, LingTang, RuiLuo, XiaomingAn, YouzhongZhao, HuiyingGao, YanZhai, ZheYe, Zheng L.Wang, WeiLi, WenwenLi, QingdongZheng, RuiqiangYu, WenkuiShen, JuanhongLi, XinyuYu, TaoLu, WeihuaWu, Ya Q.Huang, Xiao B.He, ZhenyangLu, YuanhuaHan, HuiZhang, FanSun, RenhuaWang, Hua X.Qin, Shu H.Zhu, Bao H.Zhao, JunLiu, JianLi, BinLiu, Jing L.Zhou, Fa C.Li, Qiong J.Zhang, Xing Y.Li-Xin, ZhouXin-Hua, QiangJiang, LiangyanGao, Yuan N.Zhao, Xian Y.Li, Yuan Y.Li, Xiao L.Wang, ChuntingYao, QingchunYu, RongguoChen, KaiShao, HuanzhangQin, BingyuHuang, Qing Q.Zhu, Wei H.Hang, Ai Y.Hua, Ma X.Li, YiminXu, YonghaoDi, Yu D.Ling, Long L.Qin, Tie H.Wang, Shou H.Qin, JunpingHan, YiZhou, SumingVargas, Monica P.Jimenez, Juan I. SileskyRojas, Manuel A. GonzálezSolis-Quesada, Jaime E.Ramirez-Alfaro, Christian M.Máca, JanSklienka, PeterGjedsted, JakobChristiansen, AageVillamagua, Boris G.Llano, MiguelBurtin, PhilippeBuzancais, GautierBeuret, PascalPelletier, NicolasMortaza, SatarMercat, AlainChelly, JonathanJochmans, SébastienTerzi, NicolasDaubin, CédricCarteaux, Guillaumede Prost, NicolasChiche, Jean-DanielDaviaud, FabriceFartoukh, MurielBarberet, GuillaumeBiehler, JeromeDellamonica, JeanDoyen, DenisArnal, Jean-MichelBriquet, AnaisKlasen, FannyPapazian, LaurentFollin, ArnaudRoux, DamienMessika, JonathanKalaitzis, EvangelosDangers, LaurenceCombes, AlainAu, Siu-MingBéduneau, GaetanCarpentier, DorothéeZogheib, Elie H.Dupont, HerveRicome, SylvieSantoli, Francesco L.Besset, Sebastien L.Michel, PhilippeGelée, BrunoDanin, Pierre-EricGoubaux, BernardCrova, Philippe J.Phan, Nga T.Berkelmans, FrantzBadie, Julio C.Tapponnier, RomainGally, JosetteKhebbeb, SamyHerbrecht, Jean-EtienneSchneider, FrancisDeclercq, Pierre-Louis M.Rigaud, Jean-PhilippeDuranteau, JacquesHarrois, AnatoleChabanne, RussellMarin, JulienConstantin, Jean-MichelThibault, SandrineGhazi, MohammedBoukhazna, MessabiZein, Salem OuldRichecoeur, Jack R.Combaux, Daniele M.Grelon, FabienLe Moal, CharleneSauvadet, Elise P.Robine, AdrienLemiale, VirginieReuter, DanielleDres, MartinDemoule, AlexandreGoldgran-Toledano, DanyBaboi, LoredanaGuérin, ClaudeLohner, RalphKrassler, JensSchäfer, SusanneZacharowski, Kai D.Meybohm, PatrickReske, Andreas W.Simon, PhilippHopf, Hans-Bernd F.Schuetz, MichaelBaltus, ThomasPapanikolaou, Metaxia N.Papavasilopoulou, Theonymfi G.Zacharas, Giannis A.Ourailogloy, VasilisMouloudi, Eleni K.Massa, Eleni V.Nagy, Eva O.Stamou, Electra E.Kiourtzieva, Ellada V.Oikonomou, Marina A.Avila, Luis E.Cortez, Cesar A.Citalán, Johanna E.Jog, Sameer A.Sable, Safal D.Shah, BhagyeshGurjar, MohanBaronia, Arvind K.Memon, MohammedfarukMuthuchellappan, RadhakrishnanRamesh, Venkatapura J.Shenoy, AnithaUnnikrishnan, RameshDixit, Subhal B.Rhayakar, Rachana V.Ramakrishnan, NagarajanBhardwaj, Vallish K.Mahto, Heera L.Sagar, Sudha V.Palaniswamy, VijayanandGanesan, DeebanHashemian, Seyed MohammadrezaJamaati, HamidrezaHeidari, FarshadMeaney, Edel A.Nichol, AlistairKnapman, Karl M.O'Croinin, DonallDunne, Eimhin S.Breen, Dorothy M.Clarkson, Kevin P.Jaafar, Rola F.Dwyer, RoryAmir, FahdAjetunmobi, Olaitan O.O'Muircheartaigh, Aogan C.Black, Colin S.Treanor, NualaCollins, Daniel V.Altaf, WahidZani, GianlucaFusari, MaurizioSpadaro, SavinoVolta, Carlo A.Graziani, RomanoBrunettini, BarbaraPalmese, SalvatoreFormenti, PaoloUmbrello, MicheleLombardo, AndreaPecci, ElisabettaBotteri, MarcoSavioli, MonicaProtti, AlessandroMattei, AlessiaSchiavoni, LorenzoTinnirello, AndreaTodeschini, ManuelGiaccone, Policlinico P.Giarratano, AntoninoCortegiani, AndreaSher, SaraRossi, AnnaAntonelli, Massimo M.Montini, Luca M.Casalena, PaoloScafetti, SergioPanarello, GiovannaOcchipinti, GiovannaPatroniti, NicolòPozzi, MatteoBiscione, Roberto R.Poli, Michela M.Raimondi, FerdinandoAlbiero, DanielaCrapelli, GiuliaBeck, EduardoPota, VincenzoSchiavone, VincenzoMolin, AlexandreTarantino, FabioMonti, GiacomoFrati, ElenaMirabella, LuciaCinnella, GildaFossali, TommasoColombo, RiccardoPattarino, Pierpaolo Terragni IlariaMojoli, FrancescoBraschi, AntonioBorotto, Erika E.Cracchiolo, Andrea N.Palma, Daniela M.Raponi, FrancescoFoti, GiuseppeVascotto, Ettore R.Coppadoro, AndreaBrazzi, LucaFloris, LedaIotti, Giorgio A.Venti, AaronYamaguchi, OsamuTakagi, ShunsukeMaeyama, Hiroki N.Watanabe, EizoYamaji, YoshihiroShimizu, KazuyoshiShiozaki, KyokoFutami, SatoruRyosuke, SekineSaito, KojiKameyama, YoshinobuUeno, KeikoIzawa, MasayoOkuda, NaoSuzuki, HiroyukiHarasawa, TomofumiNasu, MichitakaTakada, TadaakiIto, FumihitoNunomiya, ShinKoyama, KansukeAbe, ToshikazuAndoh, KohkichiKusumoto, KoheiHirata, AkiraTakaba, AkihiroKimura, HiroyasuMatsumoto, ShuheiHigashijima, UshioHonda, HiroyukiAoki, NobumasaImai, HiroshiOgino, YasuakiMizuguchi, IchikoIchikado, KazuyaNitta, KenichiMochizuki, KatsunoriHashida, TomoakiTanaka, HiroyukiNakamura, TomoyukiNiimi, DaisukeUeda, TakeshiKashiwa, YozoUchiyama, AkinoriSabelnikovs, OlegsOss, PeterisHaddad, YoussefLiew, Kong Y.Ãamendys-Silva, Silvio A.Jarquin-Badiola, Yves D.Sanchez-Hurtado, Luis A.Gomez-Flores, Saira S.Marin, Maria C.Villagomez, Asisclo J.Lemus, Jordana S.Fierro, Jonathan M.Cervantes, Mavy RamirezMejia, Francisco Javier FloresDector, DulceDector, Dulce M.Gonzalez, Daniel R.Estrella, Claudia R.Sanchez-Medina, Jorge R.Ramirez-Gutierrez, AlvaroGeorge, Fernando G.Aguirre, Janet S.Buensuseso, Juan A.Poblano, ManuelUniversity, Mohammed V.Dendane, TarekBalkhi, HichamElkhayari, MinaSamkaoui, NacerEzzouine, HananeBenslama, AbdellatifAmor, MouradMaazouzi, WajdiCimic, NedimBeck, OliverBruns, Monique M.Schouten, Jeroen A.Rinia, MyraRaaijmakers, MoniqueVan Wezel, Hellen M.Heines, Serge J.Strauch, UlrichBuise, Marc P.Simonis, Fabienne D.Schultz, Marcus J.Goodson, Jennifer C.Browne, Troy S.Navarra, LeanloveHunt, AnnaHutchison, Robyn A.Bailey, Mathew B.Newby, LynetteMcarthur, ColinKalkoff, MichaelMcleod, AlexCasement, JonathanHacking, Danielle J.Andersen, Finn H.Dolva, Merete S.Laake, Jon H.Barratt-Due, AndreasNoremark, Kim Andre L.Sareide, EldarSjaba, Brit Ã.Guttormsen, Anne B.Yoshido, Hector H. LeonAguilar, Ronald ZumaranOscanoa, Fredy A. MontesAlisasis, Alain U.Robles, Joanne B.Pasanting-Lim, Rossini Abbie B.Tan, Beatriz C.Andruszkiewicz, PawelJakubowska, KarinaCoxo, Cristina M.Alvarez, António M.Oliveira, Bruno S.Montanha, Gustavo M.Barros, Nelson C.Pereira, Carlos S.Messias, António M.Monteiro, Jorge M.Araujo, Ana M.Catorze, Nuno T.Marum, Susan M.Bouw, Maria J.Gomes, Rui M.Brito, Vania A.Castro, SilviaEstilita, Joana M.Barros, Filipa M.Serra, Isabel M.Martinho, Aurelia M.Tomescu, Dana R.Marcu, AlexandraBedreag, Ovidiu H.Papurica, MariusCorneci, Dan E.Negoita, Silvius IoanGrigoriev, EvgenyGritsan, Alexey I.Gazenkampf, Andrey A.Almekhlafi, GhalebAlbarrak, Mohamad M.Mustafa, Ghanem M.Maghrabi, Khalid A.Salahuddin, NawalAisa, Tharwat M.Al Jabbary, Ahmed S.Tabhan, EdgardoArabi, Yaseen M.Trinidad, Olivia A.Al Dorzi, Hasan M.Tabhan, Edgardo E.Bolon, StefanSmith, OliverMancebo, JordiAguirre-Bermeo, HernanLopez-Delgado, Juan C.Esteve, FranciscoRialp, GemmaForteza, CatalinaDe Haro, CandelariaArtigas, AntonioAlbaiceta, Guillermo M.De Cima-Iglesias, SaraSeoane-Quiroga, LeticiaCeniceros-Barros, AlexandraRuiz-Aguilar, Antonio L.Claraco-Vega, Luis M.Soler, Juan Alfonsodel Carmen Lorente, MariaHermosa, CeciliaGordo, FedericoPrieto-González, MiryamLópez-Messa, Juan B.Perez, Manuel P.Perez, Cesar P.Allue, Raquel MontoiroRoche-Campo, FerranIbaéez-Santacruz, MarcosTemprano, SusanaPintado, Maria C.De Pablo, RaulGómez, Pilar Ricart AroaRuiz, Silvia RodriguezMoles, Silvia IglesiasJurado, Mª TeresaArizmendi, AlfonsPiacentini, Enrique A.Franco, NievesHonrubia, TeresaCheng, Meisy PerezLosada, Elena PerezBlanco, JavierYuste, Luis J.Carbayo-Gorriz, CeciliaCazorla-Barranquero, Francisca G.Alonso, Javier G.Alda, Rosa S.Algaba, ÃngelaNavarro, GonzaloCereijo, EnriqueDiaz-Rodriguez, EstherMarcos, Diego PastorMontero, Laura AlvarezPara, Luis HerreraSanchez, Roberto JimenezNavalpotro, Miguel Angel BlascoAbad, Ricardo Diazlez, Raquel Montiel Gonz áToribio, Dácil ParrillaCastro, Alejandro G.Artiga, Maria Jose D.Penuelas, OscarRoser, Tomas P.Olga, Moreno F.Curto, Elena GallegoSánchez, Rocío ManzanoImma, Vallverdu P.Elisabet, Garcia M.Claverias, LauraMagret, MonicaPellicer, Ana M.Rodriguez, Lucia L.Sánchez-Ballesteros, JesúsGonzález-Salamanca, ÃngelaJimenez, Antonio G.Huerta, Francisco P.Diaz, Juan Carlos J. SotilloLopez, Esther BermejoMoya, David D. LlinaresAlfonso, Alec A. TalletLuis, Palazon Sanchez EugenioCesar, Palazon SanchezRafael, Sánchez I.Virgilio, Corcoles G.Recio, Noelia N.Adamsson, Richard O.Rylander, Christian C.Holzgraefe, BernhardBroman, Lars M.Wessbergh, JoannaPersson, LinneaSchiöler, FredrikKedelv, HansTibblin, Anna OscarssonAppelberg, HenrikHedlund, LarsHelleberg, JohanEriksson, Karin E.Glietsch, RitaLarsson, NiklasNygren, IngelaNunes, Silvia L.Morin, Anna-KarinKander, ThomasAdolfsson, AnneZender, Hervé O.Leemann-Refondini, CorinneElatrous, SouheilBouchoucha, SlaheddineChouchene, ImedOuanes, IslemMarsa, LaSouissi, Asma BenKamoun, SalmaDemirkiran, OktayAker, MustafaErbabacan, EmreCeylan, IlkayGirgin, Nermin KelebekOzcelik, MenekseÃnal, NecmettinMeco, Basak CeydaAkyol, Onat O.Derman, Suleyman S.Kennedy, BarryParhar, KenSrinivasa, LathaMcAuley, DannyHopkins, PhilMellis, ClareKakar, VivekHadfield, DanVercueil, AndreBhowmick, KaushikHumphreys, Sally K.Ferguson, AndrewMckee, RaymondRaj, Ashok S.Fawkes, Danielle A.Watt, PhilipTwohey, LindaThomas, Rajeev R. JhaMatthewMorton, AlexKadaba, VarshaSmith, Mark J.Hormis, Anil P.Kannan, Santhana G.Namih, MiriamReschreiter, HenrikCamsooksai, JulieKumar, AlekRugonfalvi, SzabolcsNutt, ChristopherOneill, OrlaSeasman, ColetteDempsey, GedScott, Christopher J.Ellis, Helen E.Mckechnie, StuartHutton, Paula J.Di Tomasso, Nora N.Vitale, Michela N.Griffin, Ruth O.Dean, Michael N.Cranshaw, Julius H.Willett, Emma L.Ioannou, NicholasGillis, SarahCsabi, PeterMacfadyen, RosaleenDawson, HeidiPreez, Pieter D.Williams, Alexandra J.Boyd, OwenDe Gordoa, Laura Ortiz-RuizBramall, JonSymmonds, SophieChau, Simon K.Wenham, TimSzakmany, TamasToth-Tarsoly, PiroskaMccalman, Katie H.Alexander, PeterStephenson, LorraineCollyer, ThomasChapman, RhiannonCooper, RaphaelAllan, Russell M.Sim, MalcolmWrathall, David W.Irvine, Donald A.Zantua, Kim S.Adams, John C.Burtenshaw, Andrew J.Sellors, Gareth P.Welters, Ingeborg D.Williams, Karen E.Hessell, Robert J.Oldroyd, Matthew G.Battle, Ceri E.Pillai, SureshKajtor, IstvanSivashanmugavel, MageswaranOkane, Sinead C.Donnelly, AdrianFrigyik, Aniko D.Careless, Jon P.May, Martin M.Stewart, RichardTrinder, T. JohnHagan, Samantha J.Wise, Matt P.Cole, Jade M.MacFie, Caroline C.Dowling, Anna T.Nin, NicolásNuéez, EdgardoPittini, GustavoRodriguez, RubenImperio, María C.Santos, CristinaDeicas, AlbertoSerra, CarolinaUppalapati, AdityaKamel, GhassanBanner-Goodspeed, Valerie M.Beitler, Jeremy R.Mukkera, Satyanarayana ReddyKulkarni, ShreedharLee, JaroneMesar, TomazShinn Iii, John O.Gomaa, DinaTainter, ChristopherYeatts, Dale J.Warren, JessicaLanspa, Michael J.Miller, Russel R.Grissom, Colin K.Brown, Samuel M.Bauer, Philippe R.Gosselin, Ryan J.Kitch, Barrett T.Cohen, Jason E.Beegle, Scott H.Gueret, Renaud M.Tulaimat, AimanChoudry, ShaziaStigler, WilliamBatra, HiteshHuff, Nidhi G.Lamb, Keith D.Oetting, Trevor W.Mohr, Nicholas M.Judy, ClaineSaito, ShigekiKheir, Fayez M.Kheir, FayezSchlichting, Adam B.Delsing, AngelaCrouch, Daniel R.Elmasri, MaryIsmail, DinaDreyer, Kyle R.Blakeman, Thomas C.Baron, Rebecca M.Grijalba, Carolina QuintanaHou, Peter C.Seethala, RaghuAisiku, ImoHenderson, GalenFrendl, GyorgyHou, Sen-KuangOwens, Robert L.Schomer, AshleyBumbasirevic, VesnaJovanovic, BojanSurbatovic, MajaVeljovic, Milic
Source
Critical Care. April 13, 2021, Vol. 25 Issue 1
Subject
Statistics
Patient outcomes
Hospital patients -- Statistics
Intensive care units -- Statistics
Adult respiratory distress syndrome -- Statistics -- Patient outcomes
World health -- Research -- Statistics
Acute respiratory distress syndrome -- Statistics -- Patient outcomes
Language
English
ISSN
1364-8535
Abstract
Author(s): Fabiana Madotto[sup.1] , Bairbre McNicholas[sup.2,3] , Emanuele Rezoagli[sup.4,5] , Tài Pham[sup.6,7] , John G. Laffey[sup.2,3] , Giacomo Bellani[sup.4,5] , Antonio Pesenti[sup.] , John G. Laffey[sup.] , Laurent Brochard[sup.] , [...]
Background To determine the frequency of, and factors associated with, death in hospital following ICU discharge to the ward. Methods The Large observational study to UNderstand the Global impact of Severe Acute respiratory FailurE study was an international, multicenter, prospective cohort study of patients with severe respiratory failure, conducted across 459 ICUs from 50 countries globally. This study aimed to understand the frequency and factors associated with death in hospital in patients who survived their ICU stay. We examined outcomes in the subpopulation discharged with no limitations of life sustaining treatments ('treatment limitations'), and the subpopulations with treatment limitations. Results 2186 (94%) patients with no treatment limitations discharged from ICU survived, while 142 (6%) died in hospital. 118 (61%) of patients with treatment limitations survived while 77 (39%) patients died in hospital. Patients without treatment limitations that died in hospital after ICU discharge were older, more likely to have COPD, immunocompromise or chronic renal failure, less likely to have trauma as a risk factor for ARDS. Patients that died post ICU discharge were less likely to receive neuromuscular blockade, or to receive any adjunctive measure, and had a higher pre- ICU discharge non-pulmonary SOFA score. A similar pattern was seen in patients with treatment limitations that died in hospital following ICU discharge. Conclusions A significant proportion of patients die in hospital following discharge from ICU, with higher mortality in patients with limitations of life-sustaining treatments in place. Non-survivors had higher systemic illness severity scores at ICU discharge than survivors. Trial Registration: ClinicalTrials.gov NCT02010073. Keywords: Acute hypoxemic respiratory failure, Acute respiratory distress syndrome, Hospital survival, ICU discharge, LUNG SAFE