학술논문
Effectiveness of a national quality improvement programme to improve survival after emergency abdominal surgery (EPOCH): a stepped-wedge cluster-randomised trial
Document Type
Academic Journal
Author
Peden, Carol J; Stephens, Tim; Martin, Graham; Kahan, Brennan C; Thomson, Ann; Rivett, Kate; Wells, Duncan; Richardson, Gerry; Kerry, Sally; Bion, Julian; Pearse, Rupert M; Pearse, Rupert; Peden, Carol; Kahan, Brennan; Brett, Stephen; Ackland, Gareth; Grocott, Mike; Holt, Peter; Robert, Glenn; Ukoumunne, Obioha; Waring, Justin; Everingham, Kirsty; Phull, Mandeep; Cromwell, David; Evley, Rachel; Lilford, Richard; Kocman, David; Asaria, Miqdad; Tarrant, Carolyn; Yang, Fan; Abraham, Ajit; Bothma, Pieter; Conway, Daniel; Stapleton, Clare; Edwards, Mark; Minto, Gary; Saunders, David; Owen, Tom; Waldmann, Carl; Hayden, Paul; Gillies, Michael; Tighe, Sean; Smith, Neil; Mythen, Monty; Murray, David; Lobo, Dileep; Leuwer, Martin; Kirk-Bayley, Justin; Howell, Simon; Gordon, Anthony; Anderson, Iain; Lourtie, Jose; Walker, Simon; Drake, Sharon; Murray, Dave; Watson, Nick; Szakmany, Tamas; Sutcliffe, Robert; Mahajan, Ravi; Girling, Alan; Forbes, Gordon; Faiz, Omar; Blunt, Mark; Singh, Surjait; Steel, Alistair; Wong, Kate; Cabreros, Leilani; Chitre, Vivek; Obideyi, Ayodele; Ali, Dhiraj; Blenk, Karl; Broad, Dan; Brodbeck, Andreas; Dumpala, Rajesh; Engel, Arnth; Ganepola, Ranjit; Garg, Sudha; Gay, Mike; Karlikowsk, Michael; Lams, Edward; Millican, Dean; Misane, Inga; Mull, Ajaya; Naik, Veena; Pushpa, Nathan; Nutt, Chris; Sagadai, Saravanna; Stuart, Hazel; Noble, Paul; Van De Velde, Niko; Hudson, Liam; Benlloch, Raoul; Singh, Satish; Verma, Karan; Laba, Damian; Carmichael, Jack; Richardson, Peter; Wilson, Graham; Lewis, Ricky; Surendran, Karthik; El-Damatty, Essam; Gurung, Sarada; Raulusaite, Ilona; Gerstina, Nabua; Rochester, Chloe; Kuldip, Rai; Lindner, Andrew; Murray, Therese; Vivek, Chitre; Lal, Roshan; Downey, Sarah; Velchuru, Vamsi; Aryal, Kamal; Guruswamy, Raman; Shankar, Kirosh; Porter, Helen; Tutton, Matthew; Agostini, Helen; Fletcher, Simon; Wharton, Richard; Hutchinson, Steve; Maiya, Bala; Howard-Griffin, Richard; Crabtree, Michael; Kushakovsky, Vlad; Omer, Abdel; Nadarajavan, Senthil; Bell, Stephanie; Patil, Vishal; Jah, Asif; Mahroof, Razeen; Watson, Nicholas; Tansley, John; Moncaster, Gareth; Flint, Neil; Miller, Andrew; Wood, Marcus; Prematie, Andreou; Roth, Sally; Bowery, Sarah; Hales, Dawn; Shah, Tanuja; Tierney, Gill; Morris, Craig; Iftikhar, Syed; Shukla, Amit; O'Dwyer, Grainne; Wolverson, Adam; Adams, Ferdinand; Perrin-Brown, Laura; White, Tim; Beavis, Sarah; Banks, Victoria; Abercrombie, John; Mole, Jonathon; Chana, Avninder; Banerjea, Ayan; Humes, David; Dhingsa, Rajpal; Wells, John; Brown, Stephanie; Adegoke, Kenneth; Tofte, Barclay; Alegria, Ana; Natarajan, Nat; Akhtar, Mansoor; Doughan, Samer; Mackinnon, John; Aravind, Biju; Cook, Esther; Snazelle, Mark; Gardner, Matt; Baldwin, Lee; Bailey, Simon; Lawton, Greg; Divekar, Nandita; Kukreja, Neil; Sange, Mansoor; Watson, Mark; Satisha, Mallikarjunappa; Protopapas, Michael; Belagodu, Zakaulla; Sarfi, Shameem; Raju, Pasupathy; Stacey, Brenda; Campbell-Smith, Tim; Parrington, Simon; Desikan, Somi; Brennan, Andrew; Griffith, John; Fletcher, Steve; Farrow, Catherine; Prestwich, Stewart; Graham, Laura; Northey, Martin; Gokhale, Jay; Mosley, Frances; Alexander, Peter; Sharma, Abhiram; Brady, Will; Hopper, John; Hill, Oliver; Varma, Sandeep; Macklin, Christopher; Rose, Alastair; Narula, Harjeet; Buckley, Sarah; Simeson, Karen; Sim, Kevin; Chadwick, Michael; Kuduvalli, Preeti; Dowling, Susan; McCairn, Amanda; Wilson, Lawrence; Vimalchandran, Dale; Jhamatt, Anita; Robin, Nicole; Monk, David; Bottomley, David; Zuzan, Oliver; Welters, Ingeborg; Ross-Anderson, Davina; Knowles, Charles; Bunker, Nick; Hu, Ying; Januszewska, Marta; Bodger, Phoebe; Niebrzegowska, Edyta; Correia, Carmen; Haslop, Richard; Abbott, Tom; Tanqueray, Tabitha; Wijeykoon, Sanjay; Jain, Susan; Full, Jens; Cuming, Tamzin; Bailey, Flora; Chatzimichail, Stelios; Cunha, Pedro; Rehman, Almas; Mohanty, Manab; Radford, Nicola; Mohr, Otto; Patel, Hitesh; Mateo, Dolores; Raj, Ashok; Machesney, Michael; Abdul, Nazar; Jemmet, Kim; Campbell, Marta; Inglis, David; Parker, Thomas; Medici, Thomas; Chan, Peter; Borgeaud, Nathan; Mukherjee, Dipankar; Odejinmi, Oluremi; Jovaisa, Tomas; Harwood, Elizabeth; Moonesinghe, Ramani; Mccullough, Jonathan; Modha, Jigna; Patel, Sanjiv; Limb, James; Bengeri, Sheshagiri; Rafi, Amir; Hall, Elizabeth; Brown, James; Gibson, Bruce; McNelis, Una; Bradburn, Mike; Lawson, Maria; Pick, Sara; Gaughan, Matthew; Browell, David; Linnett, Vanessa; Ritzema, Jenny; O'Loughlin, Paul; Cope, Sean; Corson, John; Roy, Alistair; Furneval, Julie; Holtham, Anitha; Noblett, Sophie; Dawson, Chris; McMenemie, Fiona; Pulsa, Stefan; Clement, Ian; Calder, Verity; Allen, Katherine; Rimmer, Catherine; Reed, Helen; Boyd, Christine; Monkhouse, Diane; Davies, Peter; Mullenheim, Jost; Cirstea, Emanuel; Cain, Martyn; Baillie, Kirsty; Bhowmick, Arnab; Jovestani, Keiarash; Mcmullan, Sean; Durant, Emma; Williams, Alexandra; Doyle, Donna; Cupitt, Jason; Barker, Jonathon; Harper, Nick; Brennan, Emma; Subar, Daren; Shawcross, Robert; Sebastian, Dominic; Patel, Panna; O'Connell, Gillian; Karvonen, Jyrki; Ishaan, Maitra; Hool, Alison; Burns, Karen; Mcarthur, Carol; Stergios, Tezas; Gursevak, Singh; Sonia, Makvana; Pratt, Heather; Lynne, Kaighan; McAfee, Sean; Lewis, Chris; Khalaf, Wael; Coldwell, Chris; Bronder, Christine; Wilkinson, Mark; Davis, Emma; Arnold, Glenn; Ziprin, Paul; Bartlett, Rachel; Stotz, Martin; D'souza, Rovan; Pemberton, Phillippa; Agarwal, Banwari; Sugavanam, Anita; Tan, Melanie; Varcada, Massimo; Lyness, Craig; Thorniley, Andrew; Prabhudesai, Ash; Griffin, Ruth; Vashisht, Shubha; Harris, James; Wakeford, Julie; Vaganov, Sergei; Mohsen, Yasser; Myers, Alister; Iqbal, Qamar; Harris, Simon; Ijaz, Sami; Burrow, James; Rubulotta, Francesca; El-Masry, Nabil; Stranix, Nicola; Rope, Tamsin; Liasis, Lampros; Husain, Tariq; Watfah, Josef; Griffiths, Megan; Warusavitarne, Janindra; Cartwright, Charles; Baxter, Linden; Visavadia, Rakhee; Sim, Malcolm; Wilson, Chris; Harrison, Paul; Williams, Dewi; Bews-Hair, Maria; Wrathall, Wayne; Jardine, Catherine; Mclaren, Paul; Dreyer, Fanus; Collins, Paddy; Edwards, Jennifer; Moug, Susan; Rooney, Kevin; Mcilveen, Erin; Henderson, Steven; Graham, Linda; Stark, Gail; Taylor, Lynn; Munro, Mark; Stewart, Lynn; Dickinson, Natalie; Rooney, Laura; Bailey, Lindsay; Murray, Diane; Geary, Tim; Gibson, Simon; Pow, Colin; Tan, Kerwei; Stevenson, Richard; Harrison, Ewen; Lamb, Peter; Carey, Kate; Fitton, Laura; Cook, Fabian; Schwarz, Magen; Morrison, Alan; Bryce, Gavin; Razouk, Khaled; Cain, Kathryn; Kunst, Gudrun; Papagrigoriadis, Savvas; Hopkins, Phil; Fawcet, Adrian; O'Carroll-Kuehn, Britta; Girgis, Amira; Janokowski, Stas; Farhat, Sami; Vig, Stella; Hadi, Nada; Parsons, Anthony; Cecconi, Maurizio; Melville, David; Hartopp, Richard; Woods, Justin; Karat, Isabella; Gerrard, David; Curtis, Edward; Somasekar, Krishnamurthy; Morgan-Jones, Tom; Martin, Michael; Henwood, Mark; Milne, Gordon; Sivasankaranand, Ajit; Scott, Alexandra; Escofet, Xavier; Toth-Tarsoly, Piroska; Al Shama, Majed; Hilton, Valerie; Davis, Huw; Williams, Gail; Harvard, Tim; Fitzgerald, Peter; Hurford, Dom; Muthuswamy, Babu; Williams, Gethin; Parry Jones, Jack; Mason, Nick; Rajagopal, Ramesh; Shenoy, Shrisha; Khater, Magdy; Morgan, Richard; Makris, Nikolaos; Hermandes, Anil; White, Andrew; Finch, Guy; Outram, Matt; Wilkinson, Jonny; Spimpolo, Jennifer; Shaw, Debbie; Obichere, Marion; Brescia, Giovanni; Menezes, Flavia; Stafford, Helena; Watters, Malcolm; Thorn, Chris; Stone, Julian; Andrews, Sam; Lythell, Nicola; Langton, Helen; Baxter, Stephen; Fernandes, Roy; Sunthareswaran, Rame; Ankers, Alastair; Panikkar, Kumar; Sleight, Simon; Cornforth, Belinda; Bell, Louise; Dodd, Phil; Welsh, Fenella; Watson, Geoff; Dorman, Frankie; Nash, Guy; Bromilow, James; Haigh, Fran; Pogson, David; Mercer, Stuart; Tucker, Vanessa; Way, Carolyn; Kirby-Bott, James; McLachan, Jenny; Chambers, Rob; Craven, Rachael; Blazeby, Jane; Freshwater-Turner, Dan; Burrows, Lorna; Howes, Helen; Christie, Iain; Coleman, Mark; Waddy, Sam; Sanders, Grant; Patrick, Abigail; Pitman, Catherine; Tyson, Susan; Smith, Hannah; Rousseau, Guy; Cartmell, Mark; Hanousek, Jan; Hollister, Nigel; Kightly, Lynsey; Pulletz, Mark; Talwar, Anjay; Baker, Susie; Thomas, Ruth; Gibbs, Richard; Noble, Hamish; Silsby, Joseph; Black, Helen; Evans, Thomas; DeBrunner, Robert; Cook, Nicola; Hodges, Stacy; Stevens, Amanda; Felipe, Rowena; Paddle, Jonathan; May, Denzil; Pickford, Alison; Riddington, Sid; Tucker, Olga; Smart, Simon; Marwick, Jeremy; Suggett, Nigel; Griffiths, Ewen; Riddington, David; Gill, Kathryn; Cruickshank, Neil; Susarla, Jay; Leno, Emma; Colley, Julie; Burtenshaw, Andrew; Lake, Stephen; Greenwood, Jamie; Bhardwaj, Sian; Thrush, Jessica; Wollaston, Julie; Sonksen, Julian; Patel, Rajan; Jennings, Adrian; Stanley, David; Wright, Jenny; Horner, Chris; Baig, Faisal; Cooke, Katie; Singh, Jagdeep; Claxton, Andrew; Mirza, Nazzia; Hester, Simon; Knight, Georgia; Kumar, Peeyush; Saran, Taj; Marangoni, Gabriele; Townsend, Roger; Thacker, Andy; Scase, Anne; Sharma, Meghna; Hale, Beth
Source
The Lancet. June 1, 2019, Vol. 393 Issue 10187, 2213
Subject
Language
English
ISSN
0140-6736
Abstract
Summary Background Emergency abdominal surgery is associated with poor patient outcomes. We studied the effectiveness of a national quality improvement (QI) programme to implement a care pathway to improve survival for these patients. Methods We did a stepped-wedge cluster-randomised trial of patients aged 40 years or older undergoing emergency open major abdominal surgery. Eligible UK National Health Service (NHS) hospitals (those that had an emergency general surgical service, a substantial volume of emergency abdominal surgery cases, and contributed data to the National Emergency Laparotomy Audit) were organised into 15 geographical clusters and commenced the QI programme in a random order, based on a computer-generated random sequence, over an 85-week period with one geographical cluster commencing the intervention every 5 weeks from the second to the 16th time period. Patients were masked to the study group, but it was not possible to mask hospital staff or investigators. The primary outcome measure was mortality within 90 days of surgery. Analyses were done on an intention-to-treat basis. This study is registered with the ISRCTN registry, number ISRCTN80682973. Findings Treatment took place between March 3, 2014, and Oct 19, 2015. 22,754 patients were assessed for elegibility. Of 15,873 eligible patients from 93 NHS hospitals, primary outcome data were analysed for 8482 patients in the usual care group and 7374 in the QI group. Eight patients in the usual care group and nine patients in the QI group were not included in the analysis because of missing primary outcome data. The primary outcome of 90-day mortality occurred in 1210 (16%) patients in the QI group compared with 1393 (16%) patients in the usual care group (HR 1*11, 0*96--1*28). Interpretation No survival benefit was observed from this QI programme to implement a care pathway for patients undergoing emergency abdominal surgery. Future QI programmes should ensure that teams have both the time and resources needed to improve patient care. Funding National Institute for Health Research Health Services and Delivery Research Programme.