학술논문

군사법원의 독립성과 관할 문제에 관한 연구 - 개정 「군사법원법」의 내용 분석을 중심으로
A Study on the Independence and Jurisdiction of Military Courts - Focusing on the analysis of the contents of the revised Military Court Act
Document Type
Article
Text
Source
비교법연구, 12/31/2021, Vol. 21, Issue 3, p. 135-166
Subject
군사법원
군판사
군검찰관
관할관
심판관
military courts-martial
convening authority
line-officer judg
Language
한국어(KOR)
ISSN
1598-3285
Abstract
The most important and essential issue in military law is whether courts-martial as peacetime special courts are necessary. The earliest form of military justice system in Republic of Korea was the court-martial established by the Defense Security Law, promulgated on 07. 05. 1948. Similarly to its U.S. counterpart the system put heavy emphasis on the role and authority of commanders. While the commander-centered justice system may be effective during wartime or in comparably exigent circumstances, its peacetime application has been at substantial odds with the popular legal sentiment, mainly because the military system operates under goals and ideologies that are different from those of the civilian system. In order to bridge this discrepancy, legislators have enacted a series of amendments aiming to fortify the independence of courts-martial from the influence of the commanders, and thus to make them more akin to civilian courts. In the case of the revision bill of the government legislation and the military court law proposed by the National Assembly, the purpose and purpose of the amendment bill are to establish a fair military law system through the reform of the military law and to ensure that soldiers have the same level of jurisdiction as the private court. The contents conflicting with the criminal procedure law, which is a system, are so unconstitutional that it is necessary to review the main problems and to suggest improvements in the revised bill.