학술논문

Mapping geographical inequalities in access to drinking water and sanitation facilities in low-income and middle-income countries, 2000–17
Document Type
article
Author
Aniruddha DeshpandeMolly K Miller-PetriePaulina A LindstedtMathew M BaumannKimberly B JohnsonBrigette F BlackerHedayat AbbastabarFoad Abd-AllahAhmed AbdelalimIbrahim AbdollahpourKedir Hussein AbegazAyenew Negesse AbejieLucas Guimarães AbreuMichael R.M. AbrigoAhmed AbualhasanManfred Mario Kokou AccrombessiAbdu A AdamuOladimeji M AdebayoIsaac Akinkunmi AdedejiRufus Adesoji AdedoyinVictor AdekanmbiOlatunji O AdetokunbohTara Ballav AdhikariMohsen AfaridehMarcela Agudelo-BoteroMehdi AhmadiKeivan AhmadiMuktar Beshir AhmedAnwar E AhmedTemesgen Yihunie AkaluAli S AkandaFares AlahdabZiyad Al-AlySamiah AlamNoore AlamGenet Melak AlameneTurki M AlanziJames AlbrightAmmar AlbujeerJacqueline Elizabeth Alcalde-RabanalAnimut AlebelZewdie Aderaw AlemuMuhammad AliMehran AlijanzadehVahid AlipourSyed Mohamed AljunidAli AlmasiAmir Almasi-HashianiHesham M Al-MekhlafiKhalid A AltirkawiNelson Alvis-GuzmanNelson J. Alvis-ZakzukSaeed AminiArianna Maever L. AmitGianna Gayle Herrera AmulCatalina Liliana AndreiMina AnjomshoaAnsariadi AnsariadiCarl Abelardo T. AntonioBenny AntonyErnoiz AntriyandartiJalal ArablooHany Mohamed Amin ArefOlatunde AremuBahram ArmoonAmit AroraKrishna K AryalAfsaneh ArzaniMehran Asadi-AliabadiDaniel AsmelashHagos Tasew AtalaySeyyede Masoume AthariSeyyed Shamsadin AthariSachin R AtreMarcel AusloosShally AwasthiNefsu AwokeBeatriz Paulina Ayala QuintanillaGetinet AyanoMartin Amogre AyanoreYared Asmare AynalemSamad AzariAndrew S AzmanEbrahim BabaeeAlaa BadawiMojtaba BagherzadehShankar M BakkannavarSenthilkumar BalakrishnanMaciej BanachJoseph Adel Mattar BanoubAleksandra BaracMiguel A BarbozaTill Winfried BärnighausenSanjay BasuVo Dinh BayMohsen BayatiNeeraj BediMahya BeheshtiMeysam BehzadifarMasoud BehzadifarDiana Fernanda Bejarano RamirezMichelle L BellDerrick A. BennettHabib BenzianDessalegn Ajema BerbadaRobert S BernsteinAnusha Ganapati BhatKrittika BhattacharyyaSoumyadeep BhaumikZulfiqar A BhuttaAli BijaniBoris BikbovMuhammad Shahdaat Bin SayeedRaaj Kishore BiswasSomayeh BohlouliSoufiane BoufousOliver J BradyAndrey Nikolaevich BrikoNikolay Ivanovich BrikoGabrielle B BrittonAlexandria BrownSharath Burugina NagarajaZahid A ButtLuis Alberto CámeraIsmael R Campos-NonatoJulio Cesar Campuzano RinconJorge CanoJosip CarRosario CárdenasFelix CarvalhoCarlos A Castañeda-OrjuelaFranz CastroEster CerinBinaya ChaliseVijay Kumar ChattuKen Lee ChinDevasahayam J ChristopherDinh-Toi ChuNatalie Maria CormierVera Marisa CostaElizabeth A CromwellAbel Fekadu Fekadu DadiTukur DahiruSaad M A DahlawiRakhi DandonaLalit DandonaAnh Kim DangFarah DaoudAso Mohammad DarweshAmira Hamed DarwishAhmad DaryaniJai K DasRajat Das GuptaAditya Prasad DashClaudio Alberto Dávila-CervantesNicole Davis WeaverFernando Pio De la HozJan-Walter De NeveDereje Bayissa DemissieGebre Teklemariam DemozEdgar Denova-GutiérrezKebede DeribeAssefa DesalewSamath Dhamminda DharmaratnePreeti DhillonMeghnath DhimalGovinda Prasad DhunganaDaniel DiazIsaac Oluwafemi DipeoluHoa Thi DoChristiane DolecekKerrie E DoyleEleonora DubljaninAndre Rodrigues DuraesHisham Atan EdinurAndem EffiongAziz EftekhariNevine El NahasMaysaa El Sayed ZakiMaha El TantawiHala Rashad ElhabashyShaimaa I. El-JaafaryZiad El-KhatibHajer ElkoutAisha ElsharkawyShymaa EnanyDaniel Adane EndalewBabak EshratiSharareh EskandariehArash EtemadiOluchi EzekannaghaEmerito Jose A. FaraonMohammad FareedAndre FaroFarshad FarzadfarAlebachew Fasil FasilMehdi FazlzadehValery L. FeiginWubalem FekaduNetsanet FentahunSeyed-Mohammad FereshtehnejadEduarda FernandesIrina FilipFlorian FischerCarsten FlohrNataliya A. FoigtMorenike Oluwatoyin FolayanMasoud ForoutanRichard Charles FranklinJoseph Jon FrostadTakeshi FukumotoMohamed M GadGregory M GarciaAugustine Mwangi GatotohReta Tsegaye GayesaKetema Bizuwork GebremedhinYilma Chisha Dea GeramoHailay Abrha GesesewKebede Embaye GezaeAhmad GhashghaeeFarzaneh Ghazi SherbafTiffany K GillParamjit Singh GillThemba G GinindzaAlem GirmayZemichael GizawAmador GoodridgeSameer Vali GopalaniBárbara Niegia Garcia GoulartAlessandra C GoulartAyman GradaManfred S GreenMohammed Ibrahim Mohialdeen GubariHarish Chander GugnaniDavide GuidoRafael Alves GuimarãesYuming GuoRajeev GuptaRahul GuptaGiang Hai HaJuanita A. HaagsmaNima Hafezi-NejadDessalegn H HaileMichael Tamene HaileBrian J. HallSamer HamidiDemelash Woldeyohannes HandisoHamidreza HaririanNinuk HariyaniAhmed I. HasaballahMd. Mehedi HasanAmir HasanzadehHamid Yimam HassenDesta Haftu HayelomMohamed I HegazyBehzad HeibatiBehnam HeidariDelia HendrieAndualem HenokClaudiu HerteliuFatemeh HeydarpourHagos Degefa de HidruThomas R HirdChi Linh HoangGillian I HollerichPraveen HoogarNaznin HossainMehdi HosseinzadehMowafa HousehGuoqing HuAyesha HumayunSyed Ather HussainMamusha Aman A HussenSegun Emmanuel IbitoyeOlayinka Stephen IlesanmiMilena D. IlicMohammad Hasan Imani-NasabUsman IqbalSeyed Sina Naghibi IrvaniSheikh Mohammed Shariful IslamRebecca Q IversChinwe Juliana IwuNader JahanmehrMihajlo JakovljevicAmir JalaliAchala Upendra JayatillekeEnsiyeh JenabiRavi Prakash JhaVivekanand JhaJohn S JiJost B. JonasJacek Jerzy JozwiakAli KabirZubair KabirTanuj KanchanAndré KarchSurendra KarkiAmir KasaeianGebremicheal Gebreslassie KasahunHabtamu Kebebe KasayeGebrehiwot G KassaGetachew Mullu KassaGbenga A. KayodeMihiretu M KebedePeter Njenga KeiyoroDaniel Bekele KetemaYousef Saleh KhaderMorteza Abdullatif KhafaieNauman KhalidRovshan KhalilovEjaz Ahmad KhanJunaid KhanMd Nuruzzaman KhanKhaled KhatabMona M KhaterAmir M KhaterMaryam KhayamzadehMohammad KhazaeiMohammad Hossein KhosraviJagdish KhubchandaniAli KiadaliriYun Jin KimRuth W KimokotiSezer KisaAdnan KisaSonali KochharTufa KololaHamidreza KomakiSoewarta KosenParvaiz A KoulAi KoyanagiKewal KrishanBarthelemy Kuate DefoNuworza KugbeyPushpendra KumarG Anil KumarManasi KumarDian KusumaCarlo La VecchiaBen LaceyAparna LalDharmesh Kumar LalHilton LamFaris Hasan LamiVan Charles LansinghSavita LasradoGeorgy LebedevPaul H LeeKate E LeGrandMostafa LeiliTsegaye Lolaso LenjeboCheru Tesema LeshargieAubrey J LevineSonia LewyckaShanshan LiShai LinnShiwei LiuJaifred Christian F LopezPlaton D LopukhovMuhammed Magdy Abd El RazekD.R. Mahadeshwara PrasadPhetole Walter MahashaNarayan B. MahotraAzeem MajeedReza MalekzadehDeborah Carvalho MaltaAbdullah A MamunNavid ManafiMohammad Ali MansourniaChabila Christopher MapomaGabriel MartinezSanti MartiniFrancisco Rogerlândio Martins-MeloManu Raj MathurBenjamin K MayalaMohsen MazidiColm McAlindenBirhanu Geta MeharieMan Mohan MehndirattaEntezar Mehrabi NasabKala M MehtaTeferi MekonnenTefera Chane MekonnenGebrekiros Gebremichael MelesHagazi Gebre MelesPeter T N MemiahZiad A MemishWalter MendozaRitesh G MenezesSeid Tiku MeretaTuomo J MeretojaTomislav MestrovicWorkua Mekonnen MetekiyaBartosz MiazgowskiTed R MillerGK MiniErkin M MirrakhimovBabak MoazenBahram MohajerYousef MohammadDara K. MohammadNaser Mohammad Gholi MezerjiRoghayeh MohammadibakhshShafiu MohammedJemal Abdu MohammedHassen MohammedFarnam MohebiAli H MokdadYoshan MoodleyMasoud MoradiGhobad MoradiMohammad Moradi-JooPaula MoragaLinda MoralesAbbas MosapourJonathan F. MosserSimin MouodiSeyyed Meysam MousaviMiliva MozafforSandra B MunroMoses K. MuriithiChristopher J L MurrayKamarul Imran MusaGhulam MustafaSaravanan MuthupandianMehdi NaderiAhamarshan Jayaraman NagarajanMohsen NaghaviGurudatta NaikVinay NangiaBruno Ramos NascimentoJavad NazariDuduzile Edith NdwandweIonut NegoiHenok Biresaw NetsereJosephine W. NgunjiriCuong Tat NguyenHuong Lan Thi NguyenQuynhAnh P NguyenSolomon Gedlu NigatuDina Nur Anggraini NingrumChukwudi A NnajiMarzieh NojomiOle F NorheimJean Jacques NoubiapBogdan OanceaFelix Akpojene OgboIn-Hwan OhAndrew T OlagunjuJacob Olusegun OlusanyaBolajoko Olubukunola OlusanyaObinna E OnwujekweDoris V. Ortega-AltamiranoOsayomwanbo OsarenotorFrank B OseiMayowa O OwolabiMahesh P AJagadish Rao. PadubidriSmita PakhaleAdrian PanaEun-Kee ParkSangram Kishor PatelAshish PathakAjay PatleKebreab PaulosVeincent Christian Filipino PepitoNorberto PericoAslam PervaizJulia Moreira PescariniKonrad PesudovsHai Quang PhamDavid M PigottThomas PilgrimMeghdad PirsahebMario PoljakIan PollockMaarten J PostmaFarshad PourmalekAkram PourshamsSergio I PradaLiliana PreotescuHedley QuintanaNavid RabieeMohammad RabieeAmir RadfarAlireza RafieiFakher RahimSiavash RahimiVafa Rahimi-MovagharMuhammad Aziz RahmanMohammad Hifz Ur RahmanFatemeh RajatiChhabi Lal RanabhatPuja C RaoDavide RasellaGoura Kishor RathSalman RawafLal RawalWasiq Faraz RawasiaGiuseppe RemuzziVishnu RenjithAndre M.N. RenzahoSerge ResnikoffSeyed Mohammad RiahiAna Isabel RibeiroJennifer RickardLeonardo RoeverLuca RonfaniEnrico RubagottiSalvatore RubinoAnas M SaadSiamak SabourEhsan SadeghiSahar Saeedi MoghaddamYahya SafariRajesh SagarMohammad Ali SahraianS. Mohammad SajadiMohammad Reza SalahshoorNasir SalamAhsan SaleemHosni SalemMarwa Rashad SalemYahya SalimiHamideh SalimzadehAbdallah M SamyJuan SanabriaItamar S SantosMilena M. Santric-MilicevicBruno Piassi Sao JoseSivan Yegnanarayana Iyer SaraswathyNizal SarrafzadeganBenn SartoriusBrijesh SathianThirunavukkarasu SathishMaheswar SatpathyMonika SawhneyMehdi SayyahAlyssa N SbarraLauren E SchaefferDavid C SchwebelAnbissa Muleta SenbetaSubramanian SenthilkumaranSadaf G SepanlouEdson Serván-MoriAzadeh ShafieesabetAmira A ShaheenIzza ShahidMasood Ali ShaikhAli S ShalashMehran Shams-BeyranvandMohammadBagher ShamsiMorteza ShamsizadehMohammed ShannawazKiomars SharafiRajesh SharmaAziz SheikhB Suresh Kumar ShettyWondimeneh Shibabaw ShiferawMika ShigematsuJae Il ShinRahman ShiriReza ShirkoohiK M ShivakumarSi SiSoraya SiabaniTariq Jamal SiddiqiDiego Augusto Santos SilvaVirendra SinghNarinder Pal SinghBalbir Bagicha Singh SinghJasvinder A. SinghAmbrish SinghDhirendra Narain SinhaMalede Mequanent SisayEirini SkiadaresiDavid L SmithAdauto Martins Soares FilhoMohammad Reza SobhiyehAnton SokhanJoan B SorianoMuluken Bekele SorrieIreneous N SoyiriEmma Elizabeth SpurlockChandrashekhar T SreeramareddyAgus SudaryantoMu'awiyyah Babale SufiyanHafiz Ansar Rasul SuleriaBryan L. SykesRafael Tabarés-SeisdedosTakahiro TabuchiDegena Bahrey TadesseIngan Ukur TariganBineyam TayeYonatal Mesfin TeferaArash Tehrani-BanihashemiShishay Wahdey TekelemedhinMerhawi Gebremedhin TekleMohamad-Hani TemsahBerhe Etsay TesfayFisaha Haile TesfayZemenu Tadesse TessemaKavumpurathu Raman ThankappanAkhil Soman ThekkePurakkalNihal ThomasRobert L ThompsonAlan J ThomsonRoman Topor-MadryMarcos Roberto Tovani-PaloneEugenio TrainiBach Xuan TranKhanh Bao TranIrfan UllahBhaskaran UnnikrishnanMuhammad Shariq UsmanOlalekan A UthmanBenjamin S. Chudi UzochukwuPascual R ValdezSantosh VarugheseYousef VeisaniFrancesco S ViolanteSebastian VollmerFeleke Gebremeskel W/hawariatYasir WaheedMitchell Taylor WallinYuan-Pang WangYafeng WangKinley WangdiDaniel J WeissGirmay Teklay WeldesamuelAdhena Ayaliew WerknehRonny WestermanTaweewat WiangkhamKirsten E WiensTissa WijeratneCharles Shey WiysongeHaileab Fekadu WoldeDawit Zewdu WondafrashTewodros Eshete WondeGetasew Taddesse WorkuAli YadollahpourSeyed Hossein Yahyazadeh JabbariTomohide YamadaMehdi YaseriHiroshi YatsuyaAlex YeshanehMekdes Tigistu YilmaPaul YipEngida YismaNaohiro YonemotoMustafa Z YounisHebat-Allah Salah A YousofChuanhua YuHasan YusefzadehSiddhesh ZadeyTelma Zahirian MoghadamZoubida ZaidiSojib Bin ZamanMohammad ZamaniHamed ZandianHeather J ZarTaddese Alemu ZerfuYunquan ZhangArash ZiapourSanjay ZodpeyYves Miel H ZunigaSimon I HayRobert C Reiner, Jr
Source
The Lancet Global Health, Vol 8, Iss 9, Pp e1162-e1185 (2020)
Subject
Public aspects of medicine
RA1-1270
Language
English
ISSN
2214-109X
Abstract
Summary: Background: Universal access to safe drinking water and sanitation facilities is an essential human right, recognised in the Sustainable Development Goals as crucial for preventing disease and improving human wellbeing. Comprehensive, high-resolution estimates are important to inform progress towards achieving this goal. We aimed to produce high-resolution geospatial estimates of access to drinking water and sanitation facilities. Methods: We used a Bayesian geostatistical model and data from 600 sources across more than 88 low-income and middle-income countries (LMICs) to estimate access to drinking water and sanitation facilities on continuous continent-wide surfaces from 2000 to 2017, and aggregated results to policy-relevant administrative units. We estimated mutually exclusive and collectively exhaustive subcategories of facilities for drinking water (piped water on or off premises, other improved facilities, unimproved, and surface water) and sanitation facilities (septic or sewer sanitation, other improved, unimproved, and open defecation) with use of ordinal regression. We also estimated the number of diarrhoeal deaths in children younger than 5 years attributed to unsafe facilities and estimated deaths that were averted by increased access to safe facilities in 2017, and analysed geographical inequality in access within LMICs. Findings: Across LMICs, access to both piped water and improved water overall increased between 2000 and 2017, with progress varying spatially. For piped water, the safest water facility type, access increased from 40·0% (95% uncertainty interval [UI] 39·4–40·7) to 50·3% (50·0–50·5), but was lowest in sub-Saharan Africa, where access to piped water was mostly concentrated in urban centres. Access to both sewer or septic sanitation and improved sanitation overall also increased across all LMICs during the study period. For sewer or septic sanitation, access was 46·3% (95% UI 46·1–46·5) in 2017, compared with 28·7% (28·5–29·0) in 2000. Although some units improved access to the safest drinking water or sanitation facilities since 2000, a large absolute number of people continued to not have access in several units with high access to such facilities (>80%) in 2017. More than 253 000 people did not have access to sewer or septic sanitation facilities in the city of Harare, Zimbabwe, despite 88·6% (95% UI 87·2–89·7) access overall. Many units were able to transition from the least safe facilities in 2000 to safe facilities by 2017; for units in which populations primarily practised open defecation in 2000, 686 (95% UI 664–711) of the 1830 (1797–1863) units transitioned to the use of improved sanitation. Geographical disparities in access to improved water across units decreased in 76·1% (95% UI 71·6–80·7) of countries from 2000 to 2017, and in 53·9% (50·6–59·6) of countries for access to improved sanitation, but remained evident subnationally in most countries in 2017. Interpretation: Our estimates, combined with geospatial trends in diarrhoeal burden, identify where efforts to increase access to safe drinking water and sanitation facilities are most needed. By highlighting areas with successful approaches or in need of targeted interventions, our estimates can enable precision public health to effectively progress towards universal access to safe water and sanitation. Funding: Bill & Melinda Gates Foundation.