학술논문

An Assessment of the Transparency of Contemporary Technology Education Research Employing Interview-Based Methodologies
Document Type
Journal Articles
Reports - Research
Source
International Journal of Technology and Design Education. Sep 2022 32(4):1963-1982.
Subject
Technology Education
Educational Research
Research Methodology
Accountability
Qualitative Research
Interviews
Educational Researchers
Data Collection
Power Structure
Statistical Analysis
Language
English
ISSN
0957-7572
1573-1804
Abstract
A high level of transparency in reported research is critical for several reasons, such as ensuring an acceptable level of trustworthiness and enabling replication. Transparency in qualitative research permits the identification of specific circumstances which are associated with findings and observations. Thus, transparency is important for the repeatability of original studies and for explorations of the transferability of original findings. There has been no investigation into levels of transparency in reported technology education research to date. With a position that increasing transparency would be beneficial, this article presents an analysis of levels of transparency in contemporary technology education research studies which employed interviews within their methodologies, and which were published within the "International Journal of Technology and Design Education and Design and Technology Education: An International Journal" (n = 38). The results indicate room for improvement, especially in terms of documenting researcher positionality, determinations of data saturation, and how power imbalances were managed. A discussion is presented on why it is important to improve levels of transparency in reported studies, and a guide on areas to make transparent is presented for qualitative and quantitative research.