학술논문

Text‐centered “Talk” in Foreign Language Classrooms: Comparing the Affordances of Face‐to‐face and Digital Social Annotated Reading
Document Type
Academic Journal
Author
Michelson, Kristen (Texas Tech University); Abdennebi, Mourad (University of Arizona); Michelson, Chuck
Source
Foreign Language Annals; 2023 Fall; 56(3): 600-626.  [Journal Detail] American Council on the Teaching of Foreign Languages; Wiley-Blackwell.
Subject
Pedagogy Topics: teaching of language; teaching approaches
Language
ISSN
0015-718X
1944-9720 (electronic)
Abstract
This quasi‐experimental study compares text‐centered dialogs between two groups of intermediate second language (L2) French learners: traditional face‐to‐face (FTF) discussion groups; and groups who annotated and discussed texts through the digital social annotated reading (DSAR) platform, Hypothes.is. All participants read the same articles, with discussions guided by the same reading questions. Participants' dialogs in both conditions were coded based on types of discursive moves, then analyzed through a framework of social, textual, and linguistic affordances. Findings revealed that social affordances emerged significantly more frequently than other affordances among FTF groups while textual affordances emerged significantly more frequently than other affordances among DSAR groups. Findings support the benefits of DSAR tools for more anchored discussions over traditional FTF classroom discussions, with the caution that DSAR tools alone do not necessarily promote deep discussion of foreign language texts. Beyond pedagogical implications, this study suggests an expansion of theoretical frameworks of affordances in future DSAR research.How can we leverage new technologies in designing pedagogical activities that scaffold students in text‐centered discussions of authentic foreign language texts? How can we ensure that we balance the use of new technologies in productive ways without assuming that they will do the work of the teacher?