학술논문

Who (Else) Is the Teacher? Cautionary Notes on Teacher Accountability Systems.
Document Type
Article
Source
American Journal of Education; August 2007, Vol. 113 Issue 4, p635-662, 28p
Subject
Educational accountability
Academic achievement
Teacher evaluation
Educational change
Educational planning
Mathematics education (Secondary)
Reading (Middle school)
Curriculum planning
Language
ISSN
01956744
Abstract
This article examines a premise underlying teacher accountability policies, namely, that annual student learning gains can be attributed to individual teachers. After analyzing data collected in fourth- and fifth-grade reading and mathematics classes in 18 schools, the authors identify forms of instructional design that rely on multiple teachers. These designs — simultaneous, supplemental, and sequential — were pervasive, particularly in higher-poverty schools, raising policyrelevant questions about holding individual teachers responsible for student learning. The authors further argue that accountability systems that focus on individual teachers might adversely affect other promising school reform efforts, such as teacher collaboration and data-based decision making. Reprinted by permission of the publisher.