학술논문

Relationship between method of anastomosis and anastomotic failure after right hemicolectomy and ileo-caecal resection: an international snapshot audit
Document Type
Author
Pinkney, T.Battersby, N.Bhangu, A.Chaudhri, S.El-Hussuna, A.Frasson, M.Nepogodiev, D.Singh, B.Vennix, S.Zmora, O.Altomare, D.Bemelman, W.Christensen, P.D'Hoore, A.Laurberg, S.Morton, D.Rubbini, M.Vaizey, C.Magill, L.Perry, R.Sheward, N.Ives, N.Mehta, S.Cillo, M.Estefania, D.Patron Uriburu, J.Ruiz, H.Salomon, M.Makhmudov, A.Selnyahina, L.Varabei, A.Vizhynis, Y.Claeys, D.Defoort, B.Muysoms, F.Pletinckx, P.Vergucht, V.Debergh, I.Feryn, T.Reusens, H.Nachtergaele, M.Francart, D.Jehaes, C.Markiewicz, S.Monami, B.Weerts, J.Bouckaert, W.Houben, B.Knol, J.Sergeant, G.Vangertruyden, G.Haeck, L.Lange, C.Sommeling, C.Vindevoghel, K.Castro, S.De Bruyn, H.Huyghe, M.De Wolf, E.Reynders, D.van Overstraeten, A. de BuckWolthuis, A.Delibegovic, S.Christiani, A.Marchiori, M., Jr.Rocha de Moraes, C.Tercioti, V., Jr.Arabadjieva, E.Bulanov, D.Dardanov, D.Stoyanov, V.Yonkov, A.Angelov, K.Maslyankov, S.Sokolov, M.Todorov, G.Toshev, S.Georgiev, Y.Karashmalakov, A.Zafirov, G.Wang, X.Condic, D.Kraljik, D.Mrkovic, H.Pavkovic, V.Raguz, K.Bencurik, V.Holaskova, E.Skrovina, M.Farkasova, M.Grolich, T.Kala, Z.Antos, F.Pruchova, V.Sotona, O.Chobola, M.Dusek, T.Ferko, A.Orhalmi, J.Hoch, J.Kocian, P.Martinek, L.Bernstein, I.Sunesen, K. GotschalckLeunbach, J.Thorlacius-Ussing, O.Oveson, A. UthChirstensen, S. DahlGamez, V.Oeting, M.Loeve, U. SchouUgianskis, A.Jessen, M.Krarup, P.Linde, K.Mirza, Q.Stovring, J. OvergaardErritzoe, L.Jakobsen, H. LoftLykke, J.Colov, E. PalmgrenMadsen, A. HustedFriis, T. LindeFunder, J. AmstrupDich, R.Kjaer, S.Rasmussen, S.Schlesinger, N.Kjaer, M. DillingQvist, N.Khalid, A.Ali, G.Hadi, S.Walker, L. RosellKivela, A.Lehtonen, T.Lepisto, A.Scheinin, T.Siironen, P.Kossi, J.Kuusanmaki, P.Tomminen, T.Turunen, A.Rautio, T.Vierimaa, M.Huhtinen, H.Karvonen, J.Lavonius, M.Rantala, A.Varpe, P.Cotte, E.Francois, Y.Glehen, O.Kepenekian, V.Passot, G.Maggiori, L.Manceau, G.Panis, Y.Gout, M.Rullier, E.van Geluwe, B.Chafai, N.Lefevre, J. H.Parc, Y.Tiret, E.Couette, C.Duchalais, E.Agha, A.Hornberger, M.Hungbauer, A.Iesalnieks, I.Weindl, I.Crescenti, F.Keller, M.Kolodziejski, N.Scherer, R.Sterzing, D.Bock, B.Boehm, G.El-Magd, M.Krones, C.Niewiera, M.Buhr, J.Cordesmeyer, S.Hoffmann, M.Krueckemeier, K.Vogel, T.Schoen, M.Baral, J.Lukoschek, T.Muench, S.Pullig, F.Horisberger, K.Kienle, P.Magdeburg, J.Post, S.Batzalexis, K.Germanos, S.Agalianos, C.Dervenis, C.Gouvas, N.Kanavidis, P.Kottikias, A.Katsoulis, I. E.Korkolis, D.Plataniotis, G.Sakorafas, G.Akrida, I.Argentou, M.Kollatos, C.Lampropoulos, C.Tsochatzis, S.Besznyak, I.Bursics, A.Egyed, T.Papp, G.Svastics, I.Atladottir, J.Moller, P.Sigurdsson, H.Stefansson, T.Valsdottir, E.Andrews, E.Foley, N.Hechtl, D.Majeed, M.McCourt, M.Hanly, A.Hyland, J.Martin, S.O'Connell, P. R.Winter, D.Connelly, T.Joyce, W.Wrafter, P.Berkovitz, R.Avital, S.Yahia, I. HajHermann, N.Shpitz, B.White, I.Lishtzinsky, Y.Tsherniak, A.Wasserberg, N.Horesh, N.Keler, U.Pery, R.Shapiro, R.Tulchinsky, H.Badran, B.Dayan, K.Iskhakov, A.Lecaros, J.Nabih, N.Angrima, I.Bardini, R.Pizzolato, E.Tonello, M.Arces, F.Balestri, R.Ceccarelli, C.Prosperi, V.Rossi, E.Giannini, I.Vincenti, L.Altomare, D. F.Di Candido, F.Di Iena, M.Guglielmi, A.Caputi-Iam-Brenghi, O.Marsanic, P.Mellano, A.Muratore, A.Annecchiarico, M.Bencini, L.Bona-Pasta, S. AmoreCoratti, A.Guerra, F.Asteria, C. R.Boccia, L.Gerard, L.Pascariello, A.Manca, G.Marino, F.Casaril, A.Inama, M.Moretto, G.Bacchelli, C.Carvello, M.Mariani, N.Montorsi, M.Spinelli, A.Romairone, E.Scabini, S.Belli, A.Bianco, F.De Franciscis, S.Romano, G. MariaDelrio, P.Pace, U.Rega, D.Sassaroli, C.Scala, D.De Luca, R.Ruggieri, E.Elbetti, C.Garzi, A.Romoli, L.Scatizzi, M.Vannucchi, A.Curletti, G.Durante, V.Galleano, R.Mariani, F.Reggiani, L.Bellomo, R.Infantino, A.Franceschilli, L.Sileri, P.Clementi, I.Coletta, D.La Torre, F.Mingoli, A.Velluti, F.Di Giacomo, A.Fiorot, A.Massani, M.Padoan, L.Ruffolo, C.Caruso, S.Franceschini, F.Laessig, R.Monaci, I.Rontini, M.De Nardi, P.Elmore, U.Lemma, M.Rosati, R.Tamburini, A.De Luca, M.Sartori, A.Benevento, A.Bottini, C.Ferrari, C. C.Pata, F.Tessera, G.Pellino, G.Selvaggi, F.Lanzani, A.Romano, F.Sgroi, G.Steccanella, F.Turati, L.Yamamoto, T.Ancans, G.Gerkis, S.Leja, M.Pcolkins, A.Sivins, A.Latkauskas, T.Lizdenis, P.Saladzin-Skas, Z.Svagzdys, S.Tamelis, A.Razbadauskas, A.Sokolovas, M.Dulskas, A.Samalavicius, N.Jotautas, V.Mikalauskas, S.Poskus, E.Poskus, T.Strupas, K.Camenzuli, C.Cini, C.Predrag, A.Psaila, J.Spiteri, N.Buskens, C.de Groof, E. J.Gooszen, J.Tanis, P.Belgers, E.Davids, P.Furnee, E.Postma, E.Pronk, A.Smakman, N.Clermonts, S.Zimmerman, D.Omloo, J.van der Zaag, E.van Duijvendijk, P.Wassenaar, E.Bruijninckx, M.de Graff, E.Doornebosch, P.Tetteroo, G.Vermaas, M.Iordens, G.Knops, S.Toorenvliet, B.van Westereenen, H. L.Boerma, E.Coene, P.van der Harst, E.Van der Pool, A.Raber, M.Melenhorst, J.de Castro, S.Gerhards, M.Arron, M.Bremers, A.de Wilt, H.Ferenschild, F.Yauw, S.Cense, H.Demirkiran, A.Hunfeld, M.Mulder, I.Nonner, J.Swank, H.van Wagensveld, B.Bolmers, M.Briel, J.van Geloven, A.van Rossem, C.Klemann, V.Konsten, J.Leenders, B.Schok, T.Bleeker, W.Brun, M.Helgeland, M.Ignjatovic, D.Oresland, T.Yousefi, P.Backe, I. FatenSjo, O. HelmerNesbakken, A.Tandberg-Eriksen, M.Cais, A.Traeland, J. HallvardHerikstad, R.Korner, H.Lauvland, N.Jajtner, D.Kabiesz, W.Rak, M.Gmerek, L.Horbacka, K.Horst, N.Krokowicz, P.Kwiatkowski, A.Pasnik, K.Karcz, P.Romaniszyn, M.Rusek, T.Walega, P.Czarencki, R.Obuszko, Z.Sitarska, M.Wojciech, W.Zawadzki, M.Amado, S.Clara, P.Couceiro, A.Malaquias, R.Rama, N.Almeida, A.Barbosa, E.Cernadas, E.Duarte, A.Silva, P.Costa, S.Martinez Insua, C.Pereira, J.Pereira, C.Sacchetti, M.Carvalho Pinto, B.Jorge Vieira Sousa, P.Marques, R.Oliveira, A.Cardoso, R.Carlos, S.Corte-Real, J.Moniz Pereira, P.Souto, R.Carneiro, C.Marinho, R.Nunes, V.Rocha, R.Sousa, M.Leite, J.Melo, F.Pimentel, J.Ventura, L.Vila Nova, C.Copacscu, C.Bintintan, V.Ciuce, C.Dindelegan, G.Scurtu, R.Seicean, R.Domansky, N.Karachun, A.Moiseenko, A.Pelipas, Y.Petrov, A.Pravosudov, I.Aiupov, R.Akmalov, Y.Parfenov, A.Suleymanov, N.Tarasov, N.Jumabaev, H.Mamedli, Z.Rasulov, A.Aliev, I.Chernikovskiy, I.Kochnev, V.Komyak, K.Smirnov, A.Achkasov, S.Bolikhov, K.Shelygin, Y.Sushkov, O.Zapolskiy, A.Gvozdenovic, M.Jovanovic, D.Lausevic, Z.Cvetkovic, D.Maravic, M.Milovanovic, B.Stojakovic, N.Tripkovic, I.Mihajlovic, D.Nestorovic, M.Pecic, V.Petrovic, D.Stanojevic, G.Barisic, G.Dimitrijevic, I.Krivokapic, Z.Markovic, V.Popovic, M.Aleksic, A.Dabic, D.Kostic, I.Milojkovic, A.Perunicic, V.Lukic, D.Petrovic, T.Radovanovic, D.Radovanovic, Z.Cuk, V. M.Cuk, V. V.Kenic, M.Kovacevic, B.Krdzic, I.Korcek, J.Rems, M.Toplak, J.Escarra, J.Gil Barrionuevo, M.Golda, T.Kreisler Moreno, E.Zerpa Martin, C.Alvarez Laso, C.Cumplido, P.Padin, H.Baixauli Fons, J.Hernandez-Lizoain, J.Martinez-Ortega, P.Molina-Fernandez, M.Sanchez-Justicia, C.Gracia Solanas, J. AntonioDiaz de laspra, E. CordobaEchazarreta-Gallego, E.Elia-Guedea, M.Ramirez, J.Arredondo Chaves, J.Gonzalez, P. DiezElosua, T.Sahagun, J.Turienzo Frade, A.Alvarez Conde, J.Castrillo, E.Diaz Maag, R.Maderuelo, V.Saldarriaga, L.Aldrey Cao, I.Fernandez Varela, X.Nunez Fernandez, S.Parajo Calvo, A.Villar Alvarez, S.Blesa Sierra, I.Lozano, R.Marquez, M.Porcel, O.Menendez, P.Fernandez Hevia, M.Flores Siguenza, L.Jimenez Toscano, M.Lacy Fortuny, A.Ordonez Trujillo, J.Espi, A.Garcia-Botello, S.Martin-Arevalo, J.Moro-Valdezate, D.Pla-Marti, V.Blanco-Antona, F.Abrisqueta, J.Ibanez Canovas, N.Lujan Mompean, J.Escola Ripoll, D.Martinez Gonzalez, S.Parodi, J.Fernandez Lopez, A.Ramos Fernandez, M.Castellvi Valls, J.Ortiz de Zarate, L.Ribas, R.Sabia, D.Viso, L.Alonso Goncalves, S.Gil Egea, M. JosePascual Damieta, M.Pera, M.Salvans Ruiz, S.Bernal, J.Landete, F.Ais, G.Etreros, J.Aguilo Lucia, J.Bosca, A.Deusa, S.Garcia del Cano, J.Viciano, V.Garcia-Armengol, J.Roig, J.Blas, J.Escartin, J.Fatas, J.Fernando, J.Ferrer, R.Arias Pacheco, R.Garcia Florez, L.Moreno Gijon, M.Otero Diez, J.Solar Garcia, L.Aguilar Teixido, F.Balaguer Ojo, C.Bargallo Berzosa, J.Lamas Moure, S.J., Enrique SierraFerminan, A.Herrerias, F.Rufas, M.Vinas, J.Codina-Cazador, A.Farres, R.Gomez, N.Julia, D.Planellas, P.Lopez, J.Luna, A.Maristany, C.Munoz Duyos, A.Puertolas, N.Alcantara Moral, M.Serra-Aracil, X.Concheiro Coello, P.Gomez, D.Carton, C.Miguel, A.Reoyo Pascual, F.Valero Cerrato, X.Zambrano Munoz, R.Cervera-Aldama, J.Gonzalez, J. GarciaRamos-Prada, J.Santamaria-Olabarrieta, M.Uriguen-Echeverria, A.Coves Alcover, R.Espinosa Soria, J.Fernandez Rodriguez, E.Hernandis Villalba, J.Maturana Ibanenz, V.De la Torre Gonzalez, F.Huerga, D.Perez Viejo, E.Rivera, A.Ruiz Ucar, E.Garcia-Septiem, J.Jimenez, V.Jimenez Miramon, J.Ramons Rodriquez, J.Rodriguez Alvarez, V.Garcea, A.Ponchietti, L.Borda, N.Enriquez-Navascues, J.Saralegui, Y.Febles Molina, G.Nogues, E.Rodriguez Mendez, A.Roque Castellano, C.Sosa Quesada, Y.Alvarez-Gallego, M.Pascual, I.Rubio-Perez, I.Diaz-San Andres, B.Tone-Villanueva, F.Alonso, J.Cagigas, C.Castillo, J.Gomez, M.Martin-Parra, J.Mengual Ballester, M.Pellicer Franco, E.Soria Aledo, V.Valero Navarro, G.Caballero Rodriguez, E.Gonzalez De Chaves, P.Hernandez, G.Perez Alvarez, A.Soto Sanchez, A.Becerra Garcia, F. CesarAlonso Roque, J. GuillermoRodriguez Arias, F. LopezDel Valle Ruiz, S. R.Sanchez De la Villa, G.Compan, A.Garcia Marin, A.Nofuentes, C.Orts Mico, F.Perez Auladell, V.Carrasco, M.Duque Perez, C.Galvez-Pastor, S.Navarro Garcia, I.Sanchez Perez, A.Enjuto, D.Manuel Bujalance, F.Marcelin, N.Perez, M.Serrano Garcia, R.Cabrera, A.de la Portilla, F.Diaz-Pavon, J.Jimenez-Rodriguez, R.Vazquez-Monchul, J.Daza Gonzalez, J.Gomez Perez, R.Rivera Castellano, J.Roldan de la Rua, J.Errasti Alustiza, J.Fernandez, L.Romeo Ramirez, J.Sardon Ramos, J.Cermeno Toral, B.Alias, D.Garcia-Olmo, D.Guadalajara, H.Herreros, M.Pacheco, P.del Castillo Diez, F.Lima Pinto, F.Martinez Alegre, J.Ortega, I.Nieto Antonio, A. PicardoCaro, A.Escuder, J.Feliu, F.Millan, M.Alos Company, R.Frangi Caregnato, A.Lozoya Trujillo, R.Rodriguez Carrillo, R.Ruiz Carmona, M.Alonso, N.Ambrona Zafra, D.Ayala Candia, B. AmilkaBonnin Pascual, J.Pineno Flores, C.Alcazar Montero, J.Angoso Clavijo, M.Garcia, J.Sanchez Tocino, J.Gomez-Alcazar, C.Costa-Navarro, D.Ferri-Romero, J.Rey-Riveiro, M.Romero-Simo, M.Arencibia, B.Esclapez, P.Garcia-Granero, E.Granero, P.Medina Fernandez, F. J.Gallardo Herrera, A. B.Diaz Lopez, C.Navarro Rodriguez, E.Torres Tordera, E.Arenal, J.Citores, M.Marcos, J.Sanchez, J.Tinoco, C.Espin, E.Garcia Granero, A.Jimenez Gomez, L.Sanchez Garcia, J.Vallribera, F.Folkesson, JoakimSköldberg, FilipBergman, K.Borgstrom, E.Frey, J.Silfverberg, A.Soderholm, M.Nygren, J.Segelman, J.Gustafsson, D.Lagerqvist, A.Papp, A.Pelczar, M.Abraham-Nordling, M.Ahlberg, M.Sjovall, A.Tengstrom, J.Hagman, K.Chabok, A.Ezra, E.Nikberg, M.Smedh, K.Tiselius, C.Al-Naimi, N.Duc, M. DaoMeyer, J.Mormont, M.Ris, F.Prevost, G.Villiger, P.Hoffmann, H.Kettelhack, C.Kirchhoff, P.Oertli, D.Weixler, B.Aytac, B.Leventoglu, S.Mentes, B.Yuksel, O.Demirbas, S.Ozkan, B. BusraOzbalci, G. SelcukSungurtekin, U.Gulcu, B.Ozturk, E.Yilmazlar, T.Challand, C.Fearnhead, N.Hubbard, R.Kumar, S.Arthur, J.Barben, C.Skaife, P.Slawik, S.Williams, M.Zammit, M.Barker, J.French, J.Sarantitis, I.Slawinski, C.Clifford, R.Eardley, N.Johnson, M.McFaul, C.Vimalachandran, D.Allan, S.Bell, A.Oates, E.Shanmugam, V.Brigic, A.Halls, M.Pucher, P.Stubbs, B.Agarwal, T.Chopada, A.Mallappa, S.Pathmarajah, M.Sugden, C.Brown, C.Macdonald, E.Mckay, A.Richards, J.Robertson, A.Kaushal, M.Patel, P.Tezas, S.Touqan, N.Ayaani, S.Marimuthu, K.Piramanayagam, B.Vourvachis, M.Iqbal, N.Korsgen, S.Seretis, C.Shariff, U.Arnold, S.Chan, H.Clark, E.Fernandes, R.Moran, B.Bajwa, A.McArthur, D.Cao, K.Cunha, P.Pardoe, H.Quddus, A.Theodoropoulou, K.Bolln, C.Denys, G.Gillespie, M.Manimaran, N.Reidy, J.Malik, A. I.Malik, A.Pitt, J.Aryal, K.El-Hadi, A.Lal, R.Pal, A.Velchuru, V.Cunha, M. OliveiraThomas, M.Bains, S.Boyle, K.Miller, A.Norwood, M.Yeung, J.Goian, L.Gurjar, S.Saghir, W.Sengupta, N.Stewart-Parker, E.Bailey, S.Khalil, T.Lawes, D.Nikolaou, S.Omar, G.Church, R.Muthiah, B.Garrett, W.Marsh, P.Obeid, N.Chandler, S.Coyne, P.Evans, M.Hunt, L.Lim, J.Oliphant, Z.Papworth, E.Weaver, H.Leon, K. CuinasWilliams, G.Hernon, J.Kapur, S.Moosvi, R.Shaikh, I.Swafe, L.Aslam, M.Evans, J.Ihedioha, U.Kang, P.Merchant, J.Hompes, R.Middleton, R.Broomfield, A.Crutten-Wood, D.Foster, J.Nash, G.Akhtar, M.Boshnaq, M.Eldesouky, S.Mangam, S.Rabie, M.Ahmed, J.Khan, J.Goh, N. MingShamali, A.Stefan, S.Thompson, C.Amin, A.Docherty, J.Lim, M.Walker, K.Watson, A.Hossack, M.Mackenzie, N.Paraoan, M.Alam, N.Daniels, I.Narang, S.Pathak, S.Smart, N.Al-Qaddo, A.Codd, R.Rutka, O.Bronder, C.Crighton, I.Davies, E.Raymond, T.Bookless, L.Griffiths, B.Plusa, S.Carlson, G.Harrison, R.Lees, N.Mason, C.Quayle, J.Branagan, G.Broadhurst, J.Chave, H.Sleight, S.Awad, F.Cruickshank, N.Joy, H.Boereboom, C.Daliya, P.Dhillon, A.Watson, N.Watson, R.Artioukh, D.Gokul, K.Javed, M.Kong, R.Sutton, J.Faiz, O.Jenkins, I.Leo, C. A.Samaranayake, S. F.Warusavitarne, J.Arya, S.Bhan, C.Mukhtar, H.Oshowo, A.Wilson, J.Duff, S.Fatayer, T.Mbuvi, J.Sharma, A.Cornish, J.Davies, L.Harries, R.Morris, C.Torkington, J.Knight, J.Lai, C.Shihab, O.Tzivanakis, A.Hussain, A.Luke, D.Padwick, R.Torrance, A.Tsiamis, A.Dawson, P.Balfour, A.Brady, R.Mander, J.Paterson, H.Chandratreya, N.Chu, H.Cutting, J.Vernon, S.Ho, C. WaiAndreani, S.Patel, H.Warner, M.Tan, J. Yan QiGidwani, A.Lawther, R.Loughlin, P.Skelly, B.Spence, R.Iqbal, A.Khan, A.Perrin, K.Raza, A.Tan, S.
Source
Colorectal Disease. 19(8):e296-e311
Subject
Anastomotic leak
colorectal cancer
Crohn's disease
epidemiology
international
Language
English
ISSN
1462-8910
1463-1318
Abstract
Aim: The anastomosis technique used following right-sided colonic resection is widely variable and may affect patient outcome. This study aimed to assess the association between leak and anastomosis technique (stapled vs handsewn).Method: This was a prospective, multicentre, international audit including patients undergoing elective or emergency right hemicolectomy or ileo-caecal resection operations over a 2-month period in early 2015. The primary outcome measure was the presence of anastomotic leak within 30 days of surgery, determined using a prespecified definition. Mixed effects logistic regression models were used to assess the association between leak and anastomosis method, adjusting for patient, disease and operative cofactors, with centre included as a random-effect variable.Results: This study included 3208 patients, of whom 78.4% (n = 2515) underwent surgery for malignancy and 11.7% (n = 375) underwent surgery for Crohn's disease. An anastomosis was performed in 94.8% (n = 3041) of patients, which was handsewn in 38.9% (n = 1183) and stapled in 61.1% (n = 1858). Patients undergoing hand-sewn anastomosis were more likely to be emergency admissions (20.5% handsewn vs 12.9% stapled) and to undergo open surgery (54.7% handsewn vs 36.6% stapled). The overall anastomotic leak rate was 8.1% (245/3041), which was similar following handsewn (7.4%) and stapled (8.5%) techniques (P = 0.3). After adjustment for cofactors, the odds of a leak were higher for stapled anastomosis (adjusted OR = 1.43; 95% CI: 1.04-1.95; P = 0.03).Conclusion: Despite being used in lower-risk patients, stapled anastomosis was associated with an increased anastomotic leak rate in this observational study. Further research is needed to define patient groups in whom a stapled anastomosis is safe.