학술논문

Probing the chiral magnetic wave with charge-dependent flow measurements in Pb-Pb collisions at the LHC
Document Type
Original Paper
Author
Acharya, S.Adamová, D.Aglieri Rinella, G.Agnello, M.Agrawal, N.Ahammed, Z.Ahmad, S.Ahn, S. U.Ahuja, I.Akindinov, A.Al-Turany, M.Aleksandrov, D.Alessandro, B.Alfanda, H. M.Alfaro Molina, R.Ali, B.Alici, A.Alizadehvandchali, N.Alkin, A.Alme, J.Alocco, G.Alt, T.Altamura, A. R.Altsybeev, I.Alvarado, J. R.Anaam, M. N.Andrei, C.Andreou, N.Andronic, A.Anguelov, V.Antinori, F.Antonioli, P.Apadula, N.Aphecetche, L.Appelshäuser, H.Arata, C.Arcelli, S.Aresti, M.Arnaldi, R.Arneiro, J. G. M. C. A.Arsene, I. C.Arslandok, M.Augustinus, A.Averbeck, R.Azmi, M. D.Baba, H.Badalà, A.Bae, J.Baek, Y. W.Bai, X.Bailhache, R.Bailung, Y.Balbino, A.Baldisseri, A.Balis, B.Banerjee, D.Banoo, Z.Barbera, R.Barile, F.Barioglio, L.Barlou, M.Barman, B.Barnaföldi, G. G.Barnby, L. S.Barret, V.Barreto, L.Bartels, C.Barth, K.Bartsch, E.Bastid, N.Basu, S.Batigne, G.Battistini, D.Batyunya, B.Bauri, D.Bazo Alba, J. L.Bearden, I. G.Beattie, C.Becht, P.Behera, D.Belikov, I.Bell Hechavarria, A. D. C.Bellini, F.Bellwied, R.Belokurova, S.Beltran, Y. A. V.Bencedi, G.Beole, S.Berdnikov, Y.Berdnikova, A.Bergmann, L.Besoiu, M. G.Betev, L.Bhaduri, P. P.Bhasin, A.Bhat, M. A.Bhattacharjee, B.Bianchi, L.Bianchi, N.Bielčík, J.Bielčíková, J.Biernat, J.Bigot, A. P.Bilandzic, A.Biro, G.Biswas, S.Bize, N.Blair, J. T.Blau, D.Blidaru, M. B.Bluhme, N.Blume, C.Boca, G.Bock, F.Bodova, T.Bogdanov, A.Boi, S.Bok, J.Boldizsár, L.Bombara, M.Bond, P. M.Bonomi, G.Borel, H.Borissov, A.Borquez Carcamo, A. G.Bossi, H.Botta, E.Bouziani, Y. E. M.Bratrud, L.Braun-Munzinger, P.Bregant, M.Broz, M.Bruno, G. E.Buckland, M. D.Budnikov, D.Buesching, H.Bufalino, S.Buhler, P.Burmasov, N.Buthelezi, Z.Bylinkin, A.Bysiak, S. A.Cai, M.Caines, H.Caliva, A.Calvo Villar, E.Camacho, J. M. M.Camerini, P.Canedo, F. D. M.Cantway, S. L.Carabas, M.Carballo, A. A.Carnesecchi, F.Caron, R.Carvalho, L. A. D.Castillo Castellanos, J.Catalano, F.Ceballos Sanchez, C.Chakaberia, I.Chakraborty, P.Chandra, S.Chapeland, S.Chartier, M.Chattopadhyay, S.Chattopadhyay, S.Cheng, T.Cheshkov, C.Cheynis, B.Chibante Barroso, V.Chinellato, D. D.Chizzali, E. S.Cho, J.Cho, S.Chochula, P.Choudhury, D.Christakoglou, P.Christensen, C. H.Christiansen, P.Chujo, T.Ciacco, M.Cicalo, C.Cindolo, F.Ciupek, M. R.Clai, G.Colamaria, F.Colburn, J. S.Colella, D.Colocci, M.Concas, M.Conesa Balbastre, G.Conesa del Valle, Z.Contin, G.Contreras, J. G.Coquet, M. L.Cortese, P.Cosentino, M. R.Costa, F.Costanza, S.Cot, C.Crkovská, J.Crochet, P.Cruz-Torres, R.Cui, P.Dainese, A.Danisch, M. C.Danu, A.Das, P.Das, P.Das, S.Dash, A. R.Dash, S.De Caro, A.de Cataldo, G.de Cuveland, J.De Falco, A.De Gruttola, D.De Marco, N.De Martin, C.De Pasquale, S.Deb, R.Del Grande, R.Dello Stritto, L.Deng, W.Dhankher, P.Di Bari, D.Di Mauro, A.Diab, B.Diaz, R. A.Dietel, T.Ding, Y.Ditzel, J.Divià, R.Dixit, D. U.Djuvsland, Ø.Dmitrieva, U.Dobrin, A.Dönigus, B.Dubinski, J. M.Dubla, A.Dudi, S.Dupieux, P.Durkac, M.Dzalaiova, N.Eder, T. M.Ehlers, R. J.Eisenhut, F.Ejima, R.Elia, D.Erazmus, B.Ercolessi, F.Espagnon, B.Eulisse, G.Evans, D.Evdokimov, S.Fabbietti, L.Faggin, M.Faivre, J.Fan, F.Fan, W.Fantoni, A.Fasel, M.Feliciello, A.Feofilov, G.Fernández Téllez, A.Ferrandi, L.Ferrer, M. B.Ferrero, A.Ferrero, C.Ferretti, A.Feuillard, V. J. G.Filova, V.Finogeev, D.Fionda, F. M.Flatland, E.Flor, F.Flores, A. N.Foertsch, S.Fokin, I.Fokin, S.Fragiacomo, E.Frajna, E.Fuchs, U.Funicello, N.Furget, C.Furs, A.Fusayasu, T.Gaardhøje, J. J.Gagliardi, M.Gago, A. M.Gahlaut, T.Galvan, C. D.Gangadharan, D. R.Ganoti, P.Garabatos, C.Garcia, A. T.García Chávez, T.Garcia-Solis, E.Gargiulo, C.Gasik, P.Gautam, A.Gay Ducati, M. B.Germain, M.Ghimouz, A.Ghosh, C.Giacalone, M.Gioachin, G.Giubellino, P.Giubilato, P.Glaenzer, A. M. C.Glässel, P.Glimos, E.Goh, D. J. Q.Gonzalez, V.Gordeev, P.Gorgon, M.Goswami, K.Gotovac, S.Grabski, V.Graczykowski, L. K.Grecka, E.Grelli, A.Grigoras, C.Grigoriev, V.Grigoryan, S.Grosa, F.Grosse-Oetringhaus, J. F.Grosso, R.Grund, D.Grunwald, N. A.Guardiano, G. G.Guernane, R.Guilbaud, M.Gulbrandsen, K.Gündem, T.Gunji, T.Guo, W.Gupta, A.Gupta, R.Gupta, R.Gwizdziel, K.Gyulai, L.Hadjidakis, C.Haider, F. U.Haidlova, S.Hamagaki, H.Hamdi, A.Han, Y.Hanley, B. G.Hannigan, R.Hansen, J.Haque, M. R.Harris, J. W.Harton, A.Hassan, H.Hatzifotiadou, D.Hauer, P.Havener, L. B.Heckel, S. T.Hellbär, E.Helstrup, H.Hemmer, M.Herman, T.Herrera Corral, G.Herrmann, F.Herrmann, S.Hetland, K. F.Heybeck, B.Hillemanns, H.Hippolyte, B.Hoffmann, F. W.Hofman, B.Hong, G. H.Horst, M.Horzyk, A.Hou, Y.Hristov, P.Hughes, C.Huhn, P.Huhta, L. M.Humanic, T. J.Hutson, A.Hutter, D.Ilkaev, R.Ilyas, H.Inaba, M.Innocenti, G. M.Ippolitov, M.Isakov, A.Isidori, T.Islam, M. S.Ivanov, M.Ivanov, M.Ivanov, V.Iversen, K. E.Jablonski, M.Jacak, B.Jacazio, N.Jacobs, P. M.Jadlovska, S.Jadlovsky, J.Jaelani, S.Jahnke, C.Jakubowska, M. J.Janik, M. A.Janson, T.Ji, S.Jia, S.Jimenez, A. A. P.Jonas, F.Jones, D. M.Jowett, J. M.Jung, J.Jung, M.Junique, A.Jusko, A.Kabus, M. J.Kaewjai, J.Kalinak, P.Kalteyer, A. S.Kalweit, A.Kaplin, V.Karasu Uysal, A.Karatovic, D.Karavichev, O.Karavicheva, T.Karczmarczyk, P.Karpechev, E.Kebschull, U.Keidel, R.Keijdener, D. L. D.Keil, M.Ketzer, B.Khade, S. S.Khan, A. M.Khan, S.Khanzadeev, A.Kharlov, Y.Khatun, A.Khuntia, A.Kileng, B.Kim, B.Kim, C.Kim, D. J.Kim, E. J.Kim, J.Kim, J. S.Kim, J.Kim, J.Kim, M.Kim, S.Kim, T.Kimura, K.Kirsch, S.Kisel, I.Kiselev, S.Kisiel, A.Kitowski, J. P.Klay, J. L.Klein, J.Klein, S.Klein-Bösing, C.Kleiner, M.Klemenz, T.Kluge, A.Knospe, A. G.Kobdaj, C.Kollegger, T.Kondratyev, A.Kondratyeva, N.Kondratyuk, E.Konig, J.Konigstorfer, S. A.Konopka, P. J.Kornakov, G.Korwieser, M.Koryciak, S. D.Kotliarov, A.Kovalenko, V.Kowalski, M.Kozhuharov, V.Králik, I.Kravčáková, A.Krcal, L.Krivda, M.Krizek, F.Krizkova Gajdosova, K.Kroesen, M.Krüger, M.Krupova, D. M.Kryshen, E.Kučera, V.Kuhn, C.Kuijer, P. G.Kumaoka, T.Kumar, D.Kumar, L.Kumar, N.Kumar, S.Kundu, S.Kurashvili, P.Kurepin, A.Kurepin, A. B.Kuryakin, A.Kushpil, S.Kuskov, V.Kweon, M. J.Kwon, Y.La Pointe, S. L.La Rocca, P.Lakrathok, A.Lamanna, M.Landou, A. R.Langoy, R.Larionov, P.Laudi, E.Lautner, L.Lavicka, R.Lea, R.Lee, H.Legrand, I.Legras, G.Lehrbach, J.Lelek, T. M.Lemmon, R. C.León Monzón, I.Lesch, M. M.Lesser, E. D.Lévai, P.Li, X.Lien, J.Lietava, R.Likmeta, I.Lim, B.Lim, S. H.Lindenstruth, V.Lindner, A.Lippmann, C.Liu, D. H.Liu, J.Liveraro, G. S. S.Lofnes, I. M.Loizides, C.Lokos, S.Lomker, J.Loncar, P.Lopez, X.López Torres, E.Lu, P.Lugo, F. V.Luhder, J. R.Lunardon, M.Luparello, G.Ma, Y. G.Mager, M.Maire, A.Majerz, E. M.Makariev, M. V.Malaev, M.Malfattore, G.Malik, N. M.Malik, Q. W.Malik, S. K.Malinina, L.Mallick, D.Mallick, N.Mandaglio, G.Mandal, S. K.Manko, V.Manso, F.Manzari, V.Mao, Y.Marcjan, R. W.Margagliotti, G. V.Margotti, A.Marín, A.Markert, C.Martinengo, P.Martínez, M. I.Martínez García, G.Martins, M. P. P.Masciocchi, S.Masera, M.Masoni, A.Massacrier, L.Massen, O.Mastroserio, A.Matonoha, O.Mattiazzo, S.Matyja, A.Mayer, C.Mazuecos, A. L.Mazzaschi, F.Mazzilli, M.Mdhluli, J. E.Melikyan, Y.Menchaca-Rocha, A.Mendez, J. E. M.Meninno, E.Menon, A. S.Meres, M.Mhlanga, S.Miake, Y.Micheletti, L.Mihaylov, D. L.Mikhaylov, K.Mishra, A. N.Miśkowiec, D.Modak, A.Mohanty, B.Mohisin Khan, M.Molander, M. A.Monira, S.Mordasini, C.Moreira De Godoy, D. A.Morozov, I.Morsch, A.Mrnjavac, T.Muccifora, V.Muhuri, S.Mulligan, J. D.Mulliri, A.Munhoz, M. G.Munzer, R. H.Murakami, H.Murray, S.Musa, L.Musinsky, J.Myrcha, J. W.Naik, B.Nambrath, A. I.Nandi, B. K.Nania, R.Nappi, E.Nassirpour, A. F.Nath, A.Nattrass, C.Naydenov, M. N.Neagu, A.Negru, A.Nekrasova, E.Nellen, L.Nepeivoda, R.Nese, S.Neskovic, G.Nicassio, N.Nielsen, B. S.Nielsen, E. G.Nikolaev, S.Nikulin, S.Nikulin, V.Noferini, F.Noh, S.Nomokonov, P.Norman, J.Novitzky, N.Nowakowski, P.Nyanin, A.Nystrand, J.Ogino, M.Oh, S.Ohlson, A.Okorokov, V. A.Oleniacz, J.Oliveira Da Silva, A. C.Onnerstad, A.Oppedisano, C.Ortiz Velasquez, A.Otwinowski, J.Oya, M.Oyama, K.Pachmayer, Y.Padhan, S.Pagano, D.Paić, G.Paisano-Guzmán, S.Palasciano, A.Panebianco, S.Park, H.Park, H.Park, J.Parkkila, J. E.Patley, Y.Patra, R. N.Paul, B.Pei, H.Peitzmann, T.Peng, X.Pennisi, M.Perciballi, S.Peresunko, D.Perez, G. M.Pestov, Y.Petrov, V.Petrovici, M.Pezzi, R. P.Piano, S.Pikna, M.Pillot, P.Pinazza, O.Pinsky, L.Pinto, C.Pisano, S.Płoskoń, M.Planinic, M.Pliquett, F.Poghosyan, M. G.Polichtchouk, B.Politano, S.Poljak, N.Pop, A.Porteboeuf-Houssais, S.Pozdniakov, V.Pozos, I. Y.Pradhan, K. K.Prasad, S. K.Prasad, S.Preghenella, R.Prino, F.Pruneau, C. A.Pshenichnov, I.Puccio, M.Pucillo, S.Pugelova, Z.Qiu, S.Quaglia, L.Ragoni, S.Rai, A.Rakotozafindrabe, A.Ramello, L.Rami, F.Rancien, T. A.Rasa, M.Räsänen, S. S.Rath, R.Rauch, M. P.Ravasenga, I.Read, K. F.Reckziegel, C.Redelbach, A. R.Redlich, K.Reetz, C. A.Regules-Medel, H. D.Rehman, A.Reidt, F.Reme-Ness, H. A.Rescakova, Z.Reygers, K.Riabov, A.Riabov, V.Ricci, R.Richter, M.Riedel, A. A.Riegler, W.Riffero, A. G.Ristea, C.Rodriguez, M. V.Rodríguez Cahuantzi, M.Rodríguez Ramírez, S. A.Røed, K.Rogalev, R.Rogochaya, E.Rogoschinski, T. S.Rohr, D.Röhrich, D.Rojas, P. F.Rojas Torres, S.Rokita, P. S.Romanenko, G.Ronchetti, F.Rosano, A.Rosas, E. D.Roslon, K.Rossi, A.Roy, A.Roy, S.Rubini, N.Ruggiano, D.Rui, R.Russek, P. G.Russo, R.Rustamov, A.Ryabinkin, E.Ryabov, Y.Rybicki, A.Rytkonen, H.Ryu, J.Rzesa, W.Saarimaki, O. A. M.Sadhu, S.Sadovsky, S.Saetre, J.Šafařík, K.Saha, P.Saha, S. K.Saha, S.Sahoo, B.Sahoo, B.Sahoo, R.Sahoo, S.Sahu, D.Sahu, P. K.Saini, J.Sajdakova, K.Sakai, S.Salvan, M. P.Sambyal, S.Samitz, D.Sanna, I.Saramela, T. B.Sarma, P.Sarritzu, V.Sarti, V. M.Sas, M. H. P.Sawan, S.Schambach, J.Scheid, H. S.Schiaua, C.Schicker, R.Schlepper, F.Schmah, A.Schmidt, C.Schmidt, H. R.Schmidt, M. O.Schmidt, M.Schmidt, N. V.Schmier, A. R.Schotter, R.Schröter, A.Schukraft, J.Schweda, K.Scioli, G.Scomparin, E.Seger, J. E.Sekiguchi, Y.Sekihata, D.Selina, M.Selyuzhenkov, I.Senyukov, S.Seo, J. J.Serebryakov, D.Šerkšnytė, L.Sevcenco, A.Shaba, T. J.Shabetai, A.Shahoyan, R.Shangaraev, A.Sharma, A.Sharma, B.Sharma, D.Sharma, H.Sharma, M.Sharma, S.Sharma, S.Sharma, U.Shatat, A.Sheibani, O.Shigaki, K.Shimomura, M.Shin, J.Shirinkin, S.Shou, Q.Sibiriak, Y.Siddhanta, S.Siemiarczuk, T.Silva, T. F.Silvermyr, D.Simantathammakul, T.Simeonov, R.Singh, B.Singh, B.Singh, K.Singh, R.Singh, R.Singh, R.Singh, S.Singh, V. K.Singhal, V.Sinha, T.Sitar, B.Sitta, M.Skaali, T. B.Skorodumovs, G.Slupecki, M.Smirnov, N.Snellings, R. J. M.Solheim, E. H.Song, J.Sonnabend, C.Soramel, F.Soto-hernandez, A. B.Spijkers, R.Sputowska, I.Staa, J.Stachel, J.Stan, I.Steffanic, P. J.Stiefelmaier, S. F.Stocco, D.Storehaug, I.Stratmann, P.Strazzi, S.Sturniolo, A.Stylianidis, C. P.Suaide, A. A. P.Suire, C.Sukhanov, M.Suljic, M.Sultanov, R.Sumberia, V.Sumowidagdo, S.Swain, S.Szarka, I.Szymkowski, M.Taghavi, S. F.Taillepied, G.Takahashi, J.Tambave, G. J.Tang, S.Tang, Z.Tapia Takaki, J. D.Tapus, N.Tarasovicova, L. A.Tarzila, M. G.Tassielli, G. F.Tauro, A.Tejeda Muñoz, G.Telesca, A.Terlizzi, L.Terrevoli, C.Thakur, S.Thomas, D.Tikhonov, A.Tiltmann, N.Timmins, A. R.Tkacik, M.Tkacik, T.Toia, A.Tokumoto, R.Tomohiro, K.Topilskaya, N.Toppi, M.Tork, T.Torres, P. V.Torres, V. V.Torres Ramos, A. G.Trifiró, A.Triolo, A. S.Tripathy, S.Tripathy, T.Trogolo, S.Trubnikov, V.Trzaska, W. H.Trzcinski, T. P.Tumkin, A.Turrisi, R.Tveter, T. S.Ullaland, K.Ulukutlu, B.Uras, A.Usai, G. L.Vala, M.Valle, N.van Doremalen, L. V. R.van Leeuwen, M.van Veen, C. A.van Weelden, R. J. G.Vande Vyvre, P.Varga, D.Varga, Z.Vasileiou, M.Vasiliev, A.Vázquez Doce, O.Vazquez Rueda, O.Vechernin, V.Vercellin, E.Vergara Limón, S.Verma, R.Vermunt, L.Vértesi, R.Verweij, M.Vickovic, L.Vilakazi, Z.Villalobos Baillie, O.Villani, A.Vinogradov, A.Virgili, T.Virta, M. M. O.Vislavicius, V.Vodopyanov, A.Volkel, B.Völkl, M. A.Voloshin, K.Voloshin, S. A.Volpe, G.von Haller, B.Vorobyev, I.Vozniuk, N.Vrláková, J.Wan, J.Wang, C.Wang, D.Wang, Y.Wang, Y.Wegrzynek, A.Weiglhofer, F. T.Wenzel, S. C.Wessels, J. P.Wiechula, J.Wikne, J.Wilk, G.Wilkinson, J.Willems, G. A.Windelband, B.Winn, M.Wright, J. R.Wu, W.Wu, Y.Xu, R.Yadav, A.Yadav, A. K.Yalcin, S.Yamaguchi, Y.Yang, S.Yano, S.Yin, Z.Yoo, I.-K.Yoon, J. H.Yu, H.Yuan, S.Yuncu, A.Zaccolo, V.Zampolli, C.Zanone, F.Zardoshti, N.Zarochentsev, A.Závada, P.Zaviyalov, N.Zhalov, M.Zhang, B.Zhang, C.Zhang, L.Zhang, S.Zhang, X.Zhang, Y.Zhang, Z.Zhao, M.Zherebchevskii, V.Zhi, Y.Zhou, D.Zhou, Y.Zhu, J.Zhu, Y.Zugravel, S. C.Zurlo, N.
Source
Journal of High Energy Physics. 2023(12)
Subject
Collective Flow
Heavy Ion Experiments
Quark Deconfinement
Language
English
ISSN
1029-8479
Abstract
Abstract: The Chiral Magnetic Wave (CMW) phenomenon is essential to provide insights into the strong interaction in QCD, the properties of the quark-gluon plasma, and the topological characteristics of the early universe, offering a deeper understanding of fundamental physics in high-energy collisions. Measurements of the charge-dependent anisotropic flow coefficients are studied in Pb-Pb collisions at center-of-mass energy per nucleon-nucleon collision sNNr3Normr2Normr2Norm = 5.02 TeV to probe the CMW. In particular, the slope of the normalized difference in elliptic (v2) and triangular (v3) flow coefficients of positively and negatively charged particles as a function of their event-wise normalized number difference, is reported for inclusive and identified particles. The slope sNNr3Normr2Normr2Norm is found to be larger than zero and to have a magnitude similar to sNNr3Normr2Normr2Norm, thus pointing to a large background contribution for these measurements. Furthermore, sNNr3Normr2Normr2Norm can be described by a blast wave model calculation that incorporates local charge conservation. In addition, using the event shape engineering technique yields a fraction of CMW (fCMW) contribution to this measurement which is compatible with zero. This measurement provides the very first upper limit for fCMW, and in the 10–60% centrality interval it is found to be 26% (38%) at 95% (99.7%) confidence level.