학술논문
Examining Ecological Constraints on the Intergenerational Transmission of Attachment Via Individual Participant Data Meta-analysis
Document Type
Report
Author
Verhage, Marije L.; Fearon, R.M. Pasco; Schuengel, Carlo; van IJzendoorn, Marinus H.; Bakermans-Kranenburg, Marian J.; Madigan, Sheri; Roisman, Glenn I.; Oosterman, Mirjam; Behrens, Kazuko Y.; Wong, Maria S.; Mangelsdorf, Sarah; Priddis, Lynn E.; Brisch, Karl-Heinz; Arnott, Bronia; Aviezer, Ora; Bailey, Heidi; Behringer, Johanna; Bernier, Annie; Cassibba, Rosalinda; Cassidy, Jude; Coppola, Gabrielle; Costantini, Alessandro; Cyr, Chantal; Dozier, Mary; Ensink, Karin; Finger, Brent; Gojman, Sonia; Harder, Susanne; Hautamaki, Airi; Hazen, Nancy L.; Ierardi, Elena; Jin, Mi Kyoung; Jongenelen, Ines; Leerkes, Esther M.; Lionetti, Francesca; Lyons-Ruth, Karlen; McMahon, Catherine; Meins, Elizabeth; Pace, Cecilia S.; Priddis, Lynn; Raby, K. Lee; Crugnola, Cristina Riva; Sagi-Schwartz, Avi; Schoppe-Sullivan, Sarah J.; Steele, Howard; Steele, Miriam; Tarabulsy, George M.; Vaever, Mette S.; Brice, Patrick J.; Castoro, Germana; Costantino, Elisabetta; George, Carol; Gloger-Tippelt, Gabriele; Howes, Carollee; Jacobvitz, Deborah; Juffer, Femmie; Kazui, Miyuki; Koppe, Simo; Millan, Salvador; Murray, Lynne; Pederson, David R.; Simonelli, Alessandra; Solomon, Judith; Speranza, Anna Maria; Teti, Doug M.; Londen-Barentsen, W. Monique; Ward, Mary J.
Source
Child Development. Nov-Dec, 2018, Vol. 89 Issue 6, p2023, 15 p.
Subject
Language
English
ISSN
0009-3920
Abstract
Byline: Marije L. Verhage, R.M. Pasco Fearon,Carlo Schuengel, Marinus H. van IJzendoorn, Marian J. Bakermans-Kranenburg, Sheri Madigan, Glenn I. Roisman, Mirjam Oosterman, Kazuko Y. Behrens, Maria S. Wong, Sarah Mangelsdorf, Lynn E. Priddis, Karl-Heinz Brisch, Bronia Arnott, Ora Aviezer, Heidi Bailey, Johanna Behringer, Annie Bernier, Rosalinda Cassibba, Jude Cassidy, Gabrielle Coppola, Alessandro Costantini, Chantal Cyr, Mary Dozier, Karin Ensink, Brent Finger, Sonia Gojman, Susanne Harder, Airi Hautamaki, Nancy L. Hazen, Elena Ierardi, Mi Kyoung Jin, Ines Jongenelen, Esther M. Leerkes, Francesca Lionetti, Karlen Lyons-Ruth, Catherine McMahon, Elizabeth Meins, Cecilia S. Pace, Lynn Priddis, K. Lee Raby, Cristina Riva Crugnola, Avi Sagi-Schwartz, Sarah J. Schoppe-Sullivan, Howard Steele, Miriam Steele, George M. Tarabulsy, Mette S. Vaever, Patrick J. Brice, Germana Castoro, Elisabetta Costantino, Carol George, Gabriele Gloger-Tippelt, Carollee Howes, Deborah Jacobvitz, Femmie Juffer, Miyuki Kazui, Simo Koppe, Salvador Millan, Lynne Murray, David R. Pederson, Alessandra Simonelli, Judith Solomon, Anna Maria Speranza, Doug M. Teti, W. Monique Londen-Barentsen, Mary J. Ward Parents' attachment representations and child-parent attachment have been shown to be associated, but these associations vary across populations (Verhage et al., 2016). The current study examined whether ecological factors may explain variability in the strength of intergenerational transmission of attachment, using individual participant data (IPD) meta-analysis. Analyses on 4,396 parent-child dyads (58 studies, child age 11-96 months) revealed a combined effect size of r = .29. IPD meta-analyses revealed that effect sizes for the transmission of autonomous-secure representations to secure attachments were weaker under risk conditions and weaker in adolescent parent-child dyads, whereas transmission was stronger for older children. Findings support the ecological constraints hypothesis on attachment transmission. Implications for attachment theory and the use of IPD meta-analysis are discussed. Article Note: The members of Collaboration on Attachment Transmission Synthesis are provided in Appendix. This work was supported by a grant from Stichting tot Steun Nederland to Mirjam Oosterman and Carlo Schuengel and a grant from the Social Sciences and Humanities Research Council Canada (grant number 430-2015-00989) to Sheri Madigan. We are also grateful for the financial support that enabled researchers to carry out the original studies of which the data are included in this work. None of the authors have any conflicts of interest to disclose. CAPTION(S): Appendix S1. Detailed Information on the Study Selection and Data Selection Process Appendix S2. Descriptives of the Ecological Constraint Variables and Correlations Appendix S3. Results with Disorganized Attachment Included in the Insecure Category Appendix S4. Comparison With the Aggregate Data