학술논문

First M87 Event Horizon Telescope Results. IX. Detection of Near-horizon Circular Polarization
Document Type
article
Author
The Event Horizon Telescope CollaborationKazunori AkiyamaAntxon AlberdiWalter AlefJuan Carlos AlgabaRichard AnantuaKeiichi AsadaRebecca AzulayUwe BachAnne-Kathrin BaczkoDavid BallMislav BalokovićJohn BarrettMichi BauböckBradford A. BensonDan BintleyLindy BlackburnRaymond BlundellKatherine L. BoumanGeoffrey C. BowerHope BoyceMichael BremerChristiaan D. BrinkerinkRoger BrissendenSilke BritzenAvery E. BroderickDominique BroguiereThomas BronzwaerSandra BustamanteDo-Young ByunJohn E. CarlstromChiara CeccobelloAndrew ChaelChi-kwan ChanDominic O. ChangKoushik ChatterjeeShami ChatterjeeMing-Tang ChenYongjun ChenXiaopeng ChengIlje ChoPierre ChristianNicholas S. ConroyJohn E. ConwayJames M. CordesThomas M. CrawfordGeoffrey B. CrewAlejandro Cruz-OsorioYuzhu CuiRohan DahaleJordy DavelaarMariafelicia De LaurentisRoger DeaneJessica DempseyGregory DesvignesJason DexterVedant DhruvSheperd S. DoelemanSean DougalSergio A. DzibRalph P. EatoughRazieh EmamiHeino FalckeJoseph FarahVincent L. FishEd FomalontH. Alyson FordMarianna FoschiRaquel Fraga-EncinasWilliam T. FreemanPer FribergChristian M. FrommAntonio FuentesPeter GalisonCharles F. GammieRoberto GarcíaOlivier GentazBoris GeorgievCiriaco GoddiRoman GoldArturo I. Gómez-RuizJosé L. GómezMinfeng GuMark GurwellKazuhiro HadaDaryl HaggardKari HaworthMichael H. HechtRonald HesperDirk HeumannLuis C. HoPaul HoMareki HonmaChih-Wei L. HuangLei HuangDavid H. HughesShiro IkedaC. M. Violette ImpellizzeriMakoto InoueSara IssaounDavid J. JamesBuell T. JannuziMichael JanssenBritton JeterWu JiangAlejandra Jiménez-RosalesMichael D. JohnsonSvetlana JorstadAbhishek V. JoshiTaehyun JungMansour KaramiRamesh KaruppusamyTomohisa KawashimaGarrett K. KeatingMark KettenisDong-Jin KimJae-Young KimJongsoo KimJunhan KimMotoki KinoJun Yi KoayPrashant KocherlakotaYutaro KofujiPatrick M. KochShoko KoyamaCarsten KramerJoana A. KramerMichael KramerThomas P. KrichbaumCheng-Yu KuoNoemi La BellaTod R. LauerDaeyoung LeeSang-Sung LeePo Kin LeungAviad LevisZhiyuan LiRocco LicoGreg LindahlMichael LindqvistMikhail LisakovJun LiuKuo LiuElisabetta LiuzzoWen-Ping LoAndrei P. LobanovLaurent LoinardColin J. LonsdaleAmy E. LowitzRu-Sen LuNicholas R. MacDonaldJirong MaoNicola MarchiliSera MarkoffDaniel P. MarroneAlan P. MarscherIván Martí-VidalSatoki MatsushitaLynn D. MatthewsLia MedeirosKarl M. MentenDaniel MichalikIzumi MizunoYosuke MizunoJames M. MoranKotaro MoriyamaMonika MoscibrodzkaWanga MulaudziCornelia MüllerHendrik MüllerAlejandro MusGibwa MusokeIoannis MyserlisAndrew NadolskiHiroshi NagaiNeil M. NagarMasanori NakamuraRamesh NarayanGopal NarayananIniyan NatarajanAntonios NathanailSantiago Navarro FuentesJoey NeilsenRoberto NeriChunchong NiAristeidis NoutsosMichael A. NowakJunghwan OhHiroki OkinoHéctor OlivaresGisela N. Ortiz-LeónTomoaki OyamaFeryal ÖzelDaniel C. M. PalumboGeorgios Filippos ParaschosJongho ParkHarriet ParsonsNimesh PatelUe-Li PenDominic W. PesceVincent PiétuRichard PlambeckAleksandar PopStefanijaOliver PorthFelix M. PötzlBen PratherJorge A. Preciado-LópezDimitrios PsaltisHung-Yi PuVenkatessh RamakrishnanRamprasad RaoMark G. RawlingsAlexander W. RaymondLuciano RezzollaAngelo RicarteBart RipperdaFreek RoelofsAlan RogersCristina Romero-CañizalesEduardo RosArash RoshanineshatHelge RottmannAlan L. RoyIgnacio RuizChet RuszczykKazi L. J. RyglSalvador SánchezDavid Sánchez-ArgüellesMiguel Sánchez-PortalMahito SasadaKaushik SatapathyTuomas SavolainenF. Peter SchloerbJonathan SchonfeldKarl-Friedrich SchusterLijing ShaoZhiqiang ShenDes SmallBong Won SohnJason SooHooLeón David Sosapanta SalasKamal SouccarHe SunFumie TazakiAlexandra J. TetarenkoPaul TiedeRemo P. J. TilanusMichael TitusPablo TorneTeresa ToscanoEfthalia TraianouTyler TrentSascha TrippeMatthew TurkIlse van BemmelHuib Jan van LangeveldeDaniel R. van RossumJesse VosJan WagnerDerek Ward-ThompsonJohn WardleJasmin E. WashingtonJonathan WeintroubRobert WhartonMaciek WielgusKaj WiikGunther WitzelMichael F. WondrakGeorge N. WongQingwen WuNitika YadlapalliPaul YamaguchiAristomenis YfantisDoosoo YoonAndré YoungKen YoungZiri YounsiWei YuFeng YuanYe-Fei YuanJ. Anton ZensusShuo ZhangGuang-Yao ZhaoShan-Shan Zhao
Source
The Astrophysical Journal Letters, Vol 957, Iss 2, p L20 (2023)
Subject
Polarimetry
Galaxies
Supermassive black holes
Very long baseline interferometry
Low-luminosity active galactic nuclei
Astrophysics
QB460-466
Language
English
ISSN
2041-8213
2041-8205
Abstract
Event Horizon Telescope (EHT) observations have revealed a bright ring of emission around the supermassive black hole at the center of the M87 galaxy. EHT images in linear polarization have further identified a coherent spiral pattern around the black hole, produced from ordered magnetic fields threading the emitting plasma. Here we present the first analysis of circular polarization using EHT data, acquired in 2017, which can potentially provide additional insights into the magnetic fields and plasma composition near the black hole. Interferometric closure quantities provide convincing evidence for the presence of circularly polarized emission on event-horizon scales. We produce images of the circular polarization using both traditional and newly developed methods. All methods find a moderate level of resolved circular polarization across the image (〈∣ v ∣〉 < 3.7%), consistent with the low image-integrated circular polarization fraction measured by the Atacama Large Millimeter/submillimeter Array (∣ v _int ∣ < 1%). Despite this broad agreement, the methods show substantial variation in the morphology of the circularly polarized emission, indicating that our conclusions are strongly dependent on the imaging assumptions because of the limited baseline coverage, uncertain telescope gain calibration, and weakly polarized signal. We include this upper limit in an updated comparison to general relativistic magnetohydrodynamic simulation models. This analysis reinforces the previously reported preference for magnetically arrested accretion flow models. We find that most simulations naturally produce a low level of circular polarization consistent with our upper limit and that Faraday conversion is likely the dominant production mechanism for circular polarization at 230 GHz in M87*.