학술논문
Botox, dilation, or myotomy? Clinical outcome of interventional and surgical therapies for achalasia.
Document Type
Academic Journal
Author
Gutschow CA; Department of General-, Visceral-, and Cancer Surgery, University of Cologne, Kerpener Strasse 62, 50931, Cologne, Germany. christian.gutschow@uk-koeln.de; Töx U; Leers J; Schäfer H; Prenzel KL; Hölscher AH
Source
Publisher: Springer-Verlag Country of Publication: Germany NLM ID: 9808285 Publication Model: Print-Electronic Cited Medium: Internet ISSN: 1435-2451 (Electronic) Linking ISSN: 14352443 NLM ISO Abbreviation: Langenbecks Arch Surg Subsets: MEDLINE
Subject
Language
English
Abstract
Purpose: Achalasia is a rare, but well-defined primary esophageal motor disorder. Classic therapeutic approaches include botulinum toxin injection, balloon dilation, and surgical myotomy of the lower esophageal sphincter. This report summarizes our experience with different treatment modalities for achalasia.
Methods: Forty-three patients with achalasia treated in our hospital were subdivided according to therapeutic strategy: endoscopic botulinum toxin injection into the lower esophageal sphincter (EBTI; n = 7), endoscopic esophageal balloon dilation (EBD; n = 16), surgical myotomy after failed esophageal balloon dilation (EBD-HM; n = 14), and first-line surgical myotomy (HM; n = 6). Therapeutic efficiency was evaluated comparing standardized symptom scores preoperatively and at follow-up.
Results: There was no mortality and no significant difference between the groups for age, sex, or morbidity. The mean follow-up was at 9, 35, 38, and 17 months. At follow-up, recurrent or persistent symptoms were found in 71.4%, 6.3%, 35.7%, and 16.7% in EBTI, EBD, EBD-HM, and HM, respectively. Considering EBD-HM patients as failures of esophageal dilation, the total rate of recurrent or persistent symptoms after EBD was 50%. Poor symptomatic outcome was correlated to a low esophageal sphincter pressure during pretherapeutic manometry (p = 0.03) and to sigmoid-shaped esophageal dilatation (p = 0.06).
Conclusion: Surgical myotomy is the most reliable first-line therapy for achalasia, particularly in patients with a high sphincter pressure and moderate esophageal dilatation. Botox injection has a high failure rate and should be reserved for exceptional cases. Endoscopic dilation provides about 50% of patients with long-term symptomatic relief; in most cases, failure can be successfully treated surgically.
Methods: Forty-three patients with achalasia treated in our hospital were subdivided according to therapeutic strategy: endoscopic botulinum toxin injection into the lower esophageal sphincter (EBTI; n = 7), endoscopic esophageal balloon dilation (EBD; n = 16), surgical myotomy after failed esophageal balloon dilation (EBD-HM; n = 14), and first-line surgical myotomy (HM; n = 6). Therapeutic efficiency was evaluated comparing standardized symptom scores preoperatively and at follow-up.
Results: There was no mortality and no significant difference between the groups for age, sex, or morbidity. The mean follow-up was at 9, 35, 38, and 17 months. At follow-up, recurrent or persistent symptoms were found in 71.4%, 6.3%, 35.7%, and 16.7% in EBTI, EBD, EBD-HM, and HM, respectively. Considering EBD-HM patients as failures of esophageal dilation, the total rate of recurrent or persistent symptoms after EBD was 50%. Poor symptomatic outcome was correlated to a low esophageal sphincter pressure during pretherapeutic manometry (p = 0.03) and to sigmoid-shaped esophageal dilatation (p = 0.06).
Conclusion: Surgical myotomy is the most reliable first-line therapy for achalasia, particularly in patients with a high sphincter pressure and moderate esophageal dilatation. Botox injection has a high failure rate and should be reserved for exceptional cases. Endoscopic dilation provides about 50% of patients with long-term symptomatic relief; in most cases, failure can be successfully treated surgically.