학술논문

What topic continuity problem?
Document Type
Article
Source
Inquiry. Oct2022, p1-21. 21p. 2 Illustrations, 2 Charts.
Subject
Language
ISSN
0020-174X
Abstract
A common objection to the very idea of conceptual engineering is the topic continuity problem: whenever one tries to ‘reengineer’ a concept, one only shifts attention away from one concept to another. Put differently, there is no such thing as conceptual revision: there's only conceptual replacement. Here, I show that topic continuity is compatible with conceptual replacement. Whether the topic is preserved in an act of conceptual replacement simply depends on what is being replaced (a conceptual tool or a conceptual role) and what the topic under discussion is. Thus, the topic continuity problem only arises from a failure to specify these two things. [ABSTRACT FROM AUTHOR]