학술논문

Use of an Inverted Synthetic Control Method to Estimate Effects of Recent Drug Overdose Good Samaritan Laws, Overall and by Black/White Race/Ethnicity.
Document Type
Article
Source
American Journal of Epidemiology. Oct2022, Vol. 191 Issue 10, p1783-1791. 9p.
Subject
*DRUG laws
*SUBSTANCE abuse laws
*HEALTH policy
*RACISM
*STATISTICS
*NARCOTICS
*CONFIDENCE intervals
*DRUG overdose
*HELP-seeking behavior
*COGNITION
*FEAR
*HARM reduction
*NALOXONE
*DATA analysis
*OPIOID abuse
*TRUST
*POLICE
Language
ISSN
0002-9262
Abstract
Overdose Good Samaritan laws (GSLs) aim to reduce mortality by providing limited legal protections when a bystander to a possible drug overdose summons help. Most research into the impact of these laws is dated or potentially confounded by coenacted naloxone access laws. Lack of awareness and trust in GSL protections, as well as fear of police involvement and legal repercussions, remain key deterrents to help-seeking. These barriers may be unequally distributed by race/ethnicity due to racist policing and drug policies, potentially producing racial/ethnic disparities in the effectiveness of GSLs for reducing overdose mortality. We used 2015–2019 vital statistics data to estimate the effect of recent GSLs on overdose mortality, overall (8 states) and by Black/White race/ethnicity (4 states). Given GSLs' near ubiquity, few unexposed states were available for comparison. Therefore, we generated an "inverted" synthetic control method (SCM) to compare overdose mortality in new-GSL states with that in states that had GSLs throughout the analytical period. The estimated relationships between GSLs and overdose mortality, both overall and stratified by Black/White race/ethnicity, were consistent with chance. An absence of effect could result from insufficient protection provided by the laws, insufficient awareness of them, and/or reticence to summon help not addressable by legal protections. The inverted SCM may be useful for evaluating other widespread policies. [ABSTRACT FROM AUTHOR]