학술논문

Wondering about what you know.
Document Type
Article
Author
Source
Analysis. Oct2018, Vol. 78 Issue 4, p596-604. 9p.
Subject
*QUESTIONING
*INQUISITION
*IGNORANCE (Theory of knowledge)
*THEORY of opposition
Language
ISSN
0003-2638
Abstract
In a series of recent papers, Jane Friedman has argued that attitudes like wondering, enquiring, and suspending judgement are question-directed and have the function of moving someone from a position of ignorance to one of knowledge. Call such attitudes interrogative attitudes (IAs). Friedman insists that all IAs are governed by the following Ignorance Norm: Necessarily, if one knows Q at t, then one ought not have an IA towards Q at t. However, I argue that key premisses in Friedman's argument actually point towards an opposing conclusion; namely, that (i) IAs are not governed by the Ignorance Norm, and (ii) IAs have functions other than moving someone from a position of ignorance to one of knowledge. I conclude that the Ignorance Norm should be rejected. [ABSTRACT FROM AUTHOR]