학술논문
Quality indicators for patients with traumatic brain injury in European intensive care units: a CENTER-TBI study
Document Type
Report
Author
Huijben, Jilske A.; Wiegers, Eveline J. A.; Ercole, Ari; de Keizer, Nicolette F.; Maas, Andrew I. R.; Steyerberg, Ewout W.; Citerio, Giuseppe; Wilson, Lindsay; Polinder, Suzanne; Nieboer, Daan; Menon, David; Lingsma, Hester F.; van der Jagt, Mathieu; Ãkerlund, Cecilia; Amrein, Krisztina; Andelic, Nada; Andreassen, Lasse; Audibert, Gérard; Azouvi, Philippe; Azzolini, Maria Luisa; Bartels, Ronald; Beer, Ronny; Bellander, Bo-Michael; Benali, Habib; Berardino, Maurizio; Beretta, Luigi; Beqiri, Erta; Blaabjerg, Morten; Lund, Stine Borgen; Brorsson, Camilla; Buki, Andras; Cabeleira, Manuel; Caccioppola, Alessio; Calappi, Emiliana; Calvi, Maria Rosa; Cameron, Peter; Lozano, Guillermo Carbayo; Carbonara, Marco; Castaéo-León, Ana M.; Cavallo, Simona; Chevallard, Giorgio; Chieregato, Arturo; Coburn, Mark; Coles, Jonathan; Cooper, Jamie D.; Correia, Marta; Czeiter, Endre; Czosnyka, Marek; Dahyot-Fizelier, Claire; Dark, Paul; De Keyser, Véronique; Degos, Vincent; Corte, Francesco Della; den Boogert, Hugo; Depreitere, Bart; Dilvesi, Dula; Dixit, Abhishek; Dreier, Jens; Dulière, Guy-Loup; Ezer, Erzsébet; Fabricius, Martin; Foks, Kelly; Frisvold, Shirin; Furmanov, Alex; Galanaud, Damien; Gantner, Dashiell; Ghuysen, Alexandre; Giga, Lelde; Golubovic, Jagos; Gomez, Pedro A.; Grossi, Francesca; Gupta, Deepak; Haitsma, Iain; Helbok, Raimund; Helseth, Eirik; Hutchinson, Peter J.; Jankowski, Stefan; Johnson, Faye; Karan, Mladen; Kolias, Angelos G.; Kondziella, Daniel; Koraropoulos, Evgenios; Koskinen, Lars-Owe; Kovács, Noémi; Kowark, Ana; Lagares, Alfonso; Laureys, Steven; Lecky, Fiona; Ledoux, Didier; Lejeune, Aurelie; Lightfoot, Roger; Manara, Alex; Martino, Costanza; Maréchal, Hugues; Mattern, Julia; McMahon, Catherine; Menovsky, Tomas; Misset, Benoit; Muraleedharan, Visakh; Murray, Lynnette; Negru, Ancuta; Nelson, David; Newcombe, Virginia; Nyirádi, József; Ortolano, Fabrizio; Payen, Jean-François; Perlbarg, Vincent; Persona, Paolo; Peul, Wilco; Piippo-Karjalainen, Anna; Ples, Horia; Pomposo, Inigo; Posti, Jussi P.; Puybasset, Louis; Radoi, Andreea; Ragauskas, Arminas; Raj, Rahul; Rhodes, Jonathan; Richter, Sophie; Rocka, Saulius; Roe, Cecilie; Roise, Olav; Rosenfeld, Jeffrey V.; Rosenlund, Christina; Rosenthal, Guy; Rossaint, Rolf; Rossi, Sandra; Sahuquillo, Juan; Sandrad, Oddrun; Sakowitz, Oliver; Sanchez-Porras, Renan; Schirmer-Mikalsen, Kari; Schou, Rico Frederik; Smielewski, Peter; Sorinola, Abayomi; Stamatakis, Emmanuel; Stocchetti, Nino; Sundström, Nina; Takala, Riikka; Tamás, Viktória; Tamosuitis, Tomas; Tenovuo, Olli; Thomas, Matt; Tibboel, Dick; Tolias, Christos; Trapani, Tony; Tudora, Cristina Maria; Vajkoczy, Peter; Vallance, Shirley; Valeinis, Egils; Vámos, Zoltán; Van der Steen, Gregory; van Dijck, Jeroen T. J. M.; van Essen, Thomas A.; van Wijk, Roel P. J.; Vargiolu, Alessia; Vega, Emmanuel; Vik, Anne; Vilcinis, Rimantas; Volovici, Victor; Voormolen, Daphne; Vulekovic, Petar; Williams, Guy; Winzeck, Stefan; Wolf, Stefan; Younsi, Alexander; Zeiler, Frederick A.; Ziverte, Agate; Zoerle, Tommaso; Clusmann, Hans
Source
Critical Care. March 4, 2020, Vol. 24 Issue 1
Subject
Language
English
ISSN
1364-8535
Abstract
Author(s): Jilske A. Huijben[sup.1] , Eveline J. A. Wiegers[sup.1] , Ari Ercole[sup.2] , Nicolette F. de Keizer[sup.3] , Andrew I. R. Maas[sup.4] , Ewout W. Steyerberg[sup.1,5] , Giuseppe Citerio[sup.6,7] , [...]
Background The aim of this study is to validate a previously published consensus-based quality indicator set for the management of patients with traumatic brain injury (TBI) at intensive care units (ICUs) in Europe and to study its potential for quality measurement and improvement. Methods Our analysis was based on 2006 adult patients admitted to 54 ICUs between 2014 and 2018, enrolled in the CENTER-TBI study. Indicator scores were calculated as percentage adherence for structure and process indicators and as event rates or median scores for outcome indicators. Feasibility was quantified by the completeness of the variables. Discriminability was determined by the between-centre variation, estimated with a random effect regression model adjusted for case-mix severity and quantified by the median odds ratio (MOR). Statistical uncertainty of outcome indicators was determined by the median number of events per centre, using a cut-off of 10. Results A total of 26/42 indicators could be calculated from the CENTER-TBI database. Most quality indicators proved feasible to obtain with more than 70% completeness. Sub-optimal adherence was found for most quality indicators, ranging from 26 to 93% and 20 to 99% for structure and process indicators. Significant (p < 0.001) between-centre variation was found in seven process and five outcome indicators with MORs ranging from 1.51 to 4.14. Statistical uncertainty of outcome indicators was generally high; five out of seven had less than 10 events per centre. Conclusions Overall, nine structures, five processes, but none of the outcome indicators showed potential for quality improvement purposes for TBI patients in the ICU. Future research should focus on implementation efforts and continuous reevaluation of quality indicators. Trial registration The core study was registered with ClinicalTrials.gov, number NCT02210221, registered on August 06, 2014, with Resource Identification Portal (RRID: SCR_015582). Keywords: Quality indicators, Benchmarking, Traumatic brain injuries, Intensive care units, Quality of health care
Background The aim of this study is to validate a previously published consensus-based quality indicator set for the management of patients with traumatic brain injury (TBI) at intensive care units (ICUs) in Europe and to study its potential for quality measurement and improvement. Methods Our analysis was based on 2006 adult patients admitted to 54 ICUs between 2014 and 2018, enrolled in the CENTER-TBI study. Indicator scores were calculated as percentage adherence for structure and process indicators and as event rates or median scores for outcome indicators. Feasibility was quantified by the completeness of the variables. Discriminability was determined by the between-centre variation, estimated with a random effect regression model adjusted for case-mix severity and quantified by the median odds ratio (MOR). Statistical uncertainty of outcome indicators was determined by the median number of events per centre, using a cut-off of 10. Results A total of 26/42 indicators could be calculated from the CENTER-TBI database. Most quality indicators proved feasible to obtain with more than 70% completeness. Sub-optimal adherence was found for most quality indicators, ranging from 26 to 93% and 20 to 99% for structure and process indicators. Significant (p < 0.001) between-centre variation was found in seven process and five outcome indicators with MORs ranging from 1.51 to 4.14. Statistical uncertainty of outcome indicators was generally high; five out of seven had less than 10 events per centre. Conclusions Overall, nine structures, five processes, but none of the outcome indicators showed potential for quality improvement purposes for TBI patients in the ICU. Future research should focus on implementation efforts and continuous reevaluation of quality indicators. Trial registration The core study was registered with ClinicalTrials.gov, number NCT02210221, registered on August 06, 2014, with Resource Identification Portal (RRID: SCR_015582). Keywords: Quality indicators, Benchmarking, Traumatic brain injuries, Intensive care units, Quality of health care