학술논문

Global, regional, and national comparative risk assessment of 79 behavioural, environmental and occupational, and metabolic risks or clusters of risks, 1990-2015: a systematic analysis for the Global Burden of Disease Study 2015
Document Type
Author
Forouzanfar, Mohammad H.Afshin, AshkanAlexander, Lily T.Anderson, H. RossBhutta, Zulficiar A.Biryukov, StanBrauer, MichaelBurnett, RichardCercy, KellyCharlson, Fiona J.Cohen, Aaron J.Dandona, LalitEstep, KaraFerrari, Alize J.Frostad, Joseph J.Fullman, NancyGething, Peter W.Godwin, William W.Griswold, MaxKinfu, YohannesKyu, Hmwe H.Larson, Heidi J.Liang, XiaofengLim, Stephen S.Liu, Patrick Y.Lopez, Alan D.Lozano, RafaelMarczak, LaurieMensah, George A.Mokdad, Ali H.Moradi-Lakeh, MaziarNaghavi, MohsenNeal, BruceReitsma, Marissa B.Roth, Gregory A.Salomon, Joshua A.Sur, Patrick J.Vos, TheoWagner, Joseph A.Wang, HaidongZhao, YiZhou, MaigengAasvang, Gunn MaritAbajobir, Amanuel AlemuAbate, Kalkidan HassenAbbafati, CristianaAbbas, Kaja M.Abd-Allah, FoadAbdulle, Abdishakur M.Abera, Semaw FeredeAbraham, BijuAbu-Raddad, Laith J.Abyu, Gebre YitayihAdebiyi, Akindele OlupelumiAdedeji, Isaac AkinkunmiAdemi, ZanfinaAdou, Arsene KouablanAdsuar, Jose C.Agardh, Emilie ElisabetAgarwal, ArnavAgrawal, AnuragKiadaliri, Aliasghar AhmadAjala, Oluremi N.Akinyemiju, Tomi F.Al-Aly, ZiyadAlam, KhurshidAlam, Noore K. M.Aldhahri, Saleh FahedAldridge, Robert WilliamAlemu, Zewdie AderawAli, RaghibAlkerwi, Ala'aAlla, FrancoisAllebeck, PeterAlsharif, UbaiAltirkawi, Khalid A.Alvarez Martin, ElenaAlvis-Guzman, NelsonAmare, Azmeraw T.Amberbir, AlemayehuAmegah, Adeladza KofiAmini, HereshAmmar, WalidAmrock, Stephen MarcAndersen, Hjalte H.Anderson, Benjamin O.Antonio, Carl Abelardo T.Anwar, PalwashaÄrnlöv, JohanArtaman, AlAsayesh, HamidAsghar, Rana JawadAssadi, RezaAtique, SulemanAvokpaho, Euripide Frinel G. ArthurAwasthi, AshishQuintanilla, Beatriz Paulina AyalaAzzopardi, PeterBacha, UmarBadawi, AlaaBahit, Maria C.Balakrishnan, KalpanaBarac, AleksandraBarber, Ryan M.Barker-Collo, Suzanne L.Baernighausen, TillBarquera, SimonBarregard, LarsBarrero, Lope H.Basu, SanjayBans, CarolinaBazargan-Hejazi, ShahrzadBeardsley, JustinBedi, NeerajBeghi, EttoreBell, Michelle L.Bello, Aminu K.Bennett, Derrick A.Bensenor, Isabela M.Berhane, AdugnawBernabe, EduardoBetsu, Balem DemtsuBeyene, Addisu ShunuBhala, NeerajBhansali, AnilBhatt, SamirBiadgilign, SibhatuBikbov, BorisBisanzio, DonalBjertness, EspenBlore, Jed D.Borschmann, RohanBoufous, SoufianeBourne, Rupert R. A.Brainin, MichaelBrazinova, AlexandraBreitborde, Nicholas J. K.Brenner, HermannBroday, David M.Brugha, Traolach S.Brunekreef, BertButt, Zahid A.Cahill, Leah E.Calabria, BiancaRicardo Campos-Nonato, IsmaelCardenas, RosarioCarpenter, DavidCasey, Daniel C.Castaneda-Oquela, Carlos A.Castillo Rivas, JacquelineEstanislao Castro, RubenCatala-Lopez, FerranChang, Jung-ChenChiang, Peggy Pei-ChiaChibalabala, MirriamChimed-Ochir, OdgerelChisumpa, Vesper HichilombweChitheer, Abdulaal A.Choi, Jee-Young JasmineChristensen, HanneChristopher, Devasahayam JesudasCiobanu, Liliana G.Coates, Matthew M.Colquhoun, Samantha M.Cooper, Leslie TrumbullCooperrider, KimberlyCornaby, LeslieCortinovis, MonicaCrump, John A.Cuevas-Nasu, LuciaDamasceno, AlbertinoDandona, RakhiDarby, Sarah C.Dargan, Paul I.das Neves, JoseDavis, Adrian C.Davletov, KairatFilipa de Castro, E.De la Cruz-Gongora, VanessaDe Leo, DiegoDegenhardt, LouisaDel Gobbo, Liana C.del Pozo-Cruz, BorjaDellavalle, Robert P.Deribew, AmareDes Jarlais, Don C.Dharmaratne, Samath D.Dhillon, Preet K.Diaz-Tome, CesarDicker, DanielDing, Eric L.Dorsey, E. RayDoyle, Kerrie E.Driscoll, Tim R.Duan, LeileiDubey, ManishaDuncan, Bruce BartholowElyazar, IqbalEndries, Aman YesufErmakov, Sergey PetrovichErskine, Holly E.Eshrati, BabakEsteghamati, AlirezaFahimi, SamanAquino Faraon, Emerito JoseFarid, Talha A.Sofia E Sa Farinha, CarlaFaro, AndreFarvid, Maryam S.Farzadfar, FarshadFeigin, Valery L.Fereshtehnejad, Seyed-MohammadFernandes, Jefferson G.Fischer, FlorianFitchett, Joseph R. A.Fleming, TomFoigt, NataliyaForeman, KyleFowkes, F. Gerry R.Franklin, Richard C.Fuerst, ThomasFutran, Neal D.Gakidou, EmmanuelaGarcia-Basteiro, Alberto L.Gebrehiwot, Tsegaye TeweldeGebremedhin, Amanuel TesfayGeleijnse, Johanna M.Gessner, Bradford D.Giref, Ababi ZergawGiroud, MauriceGishu, Melkamu DedefoGoenka, ShifalikaCarmen Gomez-Cabrera, MariGomez-Dantes, HectorGona, PhilimonGoodridge, AmadorGopalani, Sameer ValiGotay, Carolyn C.Goto, AtsushiGouda, Hebe N.Gugnani, Harish ChanderGuillemin, FrancisGuo, YumingGupta, RahulGupta, RajeevGutierrez, Reyna A.Haagsma, Juanita A.Hafezi-Nejad, NimaHaile, DemewozHailu, Gessessew BugssaHalasa, Yara A.Hamadeh, Randah RibhiHamidi, SamerHandal, Alexis J.Hankey, Graeme J.Hao, YuantaoHarb, Hilda L.Harikrishnan, SivadasanpillaiMaria Haro, JosepHassanvand, Mohammad SadeghHassen, Tahir AhmedHavmoeller, RasmusBeatriz Heredia-Pi, IleanaFrancisco Hernandez-Llanes, NorbertoHeydarpour, PouriaHoek, Hans W.Hoffman, Howard J.Horino, MasakoHorita, NobuyukiHosgood, H. DeanHoy, Damian G.Hsairi, MohamedHtet, Aung SoeHu, GuoqingHuang, John J.Husseini, AbdullatifHutchings, Sally J.Huybrechts, IngeIburg, Kim MoesgaardIdrisov, Bulat T.Ileanu, Bogdan VasileInoue, ManamiJacobs, Troy A.Jacobsen, Kathryn H.Jahanmehr, NaderJakovljevic, Mihajlo B.Jansen, Henrica A. F. M.Jassal, Simerjot K.Javanbakht, MehdiJayatilleke, Achala UpendraJee, Sun HaJeemon, PanniyammakalJha, VivekanandJiang, YingJibat, TarikuJin, YeJohnson, Catherine O.Jonas, Jost B.Kabir, ZubairKalkonde, YogeshwarKamal, RitulKan, HaidongKarch, AndreKarema, Corine KakiziKarimkhani, ChanteKasaeian, AmirKaul, AnilKawakami, NoritoKazi, Dhruv S.Keiyoro, Peter NjengaKemp, Andrew HaddonKengne, Andre PascalKeren, AndreKesavachandran, Chandrasekharan NairKhader, Yousef SalehKhan, Abdur RahmanKhan, Ejaz AhmadKhan, GulfarazKhang, Young-HoKhatibzadeh, ShahabKhera, SahilKhoja, Tawfik Ahmed MuthaferKhubchandani, JagdishKieling, ChristianKim, Cho-ilKim, DanielKimokoti, Ruth W.Kissoon, NiranjanKivipelto, MiiaKnibbs, Luke D.Kokubo, YoshihiroKopec, Jacek A.Koul, Parvaiz A.Koyanagi, AiKravchenko, MichaelKromhout, HansKrueger, HansKu, TiffanyDefo, Barthelemy KuateKuchenbecker, Ricardo S.Bicer, Burcu KucukKuipers, Ernst J.Kumar, G. AnilKwan, Gene F.Lal, Dharmesh KumarLalloo, RatilalLallukka, TeaLan, QingLarsson, AndersLatif, Asma AbdulBeatriz Lawrynowicz, Alicia ElenaLeasher, Janet L.Leigh, JamesLeung, JanniLevi, MiriamLi, XiaohongLi, YichongLiang, JuanLiu, ShiweiLloyd, Belinda K.Logroscino, GiancarloLotufo, Paulo A.Lunevicius, RaimundasMaclntyre, MichaelMahdavi, MandiMajdan, MarekMajeed, AzeemMalekzadeh, RezaMalta, Deborah CarvalhoManamo, Wondimu Ayele AyeleMapoma, Chabila C.Marcenes, WagnerMartin, Randall V.Martinez-Raga, JoseMasiye, FelixMatsushita, KunihiroMatzopoulos, RichardMayosi, Bongani M.McGrath, John J.McKee, MartinMeaney, Peter A.Medina, CatalinaMehari, AlemMena-Rodriguez, FabiolaMekonnen, Alemayehu B.Melaku, Yohannes AdamaMemish, Ziad A.Mendoza, WalterMensink, Gert B. M.Meretoja, AtteMeretoja, Tuomo J.Mesfin, Yonatan MogesMhimbira, Francis ApolinaryMiller, Ted R.Mills, Edward J.Mirarefin, MojdeMisganaw, AwokeMock, Charles N.Mohammadi, AlirezaMohammed, ShafiuMola, Glen Liddell D.Monasta, LorenzoMontanez Hernandez, Julio CesarMontico, MarcellaMorawska, LidiaMori, RintaroMozaffarian, DariushMueller, Ulrich O.Mullany, ErinMumford, John EverettMurthy, Gudlavalleti Venkata SatyanarayanaNachega, Jean B.Naheed, AliyaNangia, VinayNassiri, NarimanNewton, John N.Ng, MarieNguyen, Quyen LeNisar, Muhammad ImranPete, Patrick Martial NkamedjieNorheim, Ole F.Norman, Rosana E.Norrving, BoNyakarahuka, LukeObermeyer, Carla MakhloufOgbo, Felix AkpojeneOh, In-HwanOladimeji, OlanrewajuOlivares, Pedro R.Olsen, HelenOlusanya, Bolajoko OlubukunolaOlusanya, Jacob OlusegunOpio, John NelsonOren, EyalOrozco, RicardoOrtiz, AlbertoOta, ErikaMahesh, P. A.Pana, AdrianPark, Eun-KeeParry, Charles D.Parsaeian, MahboubehPatel, TejasCaicedo, Angel J. PaterninaPatil, Snehal T.Patten, Scott B.Patton, George C.Pearce, NeilPereira, David M.Perico, NorbertoPesudovs, KonradPetzold, MaxPhillips, Michael RobertPiel, Frederic B.Pillay, Julian DavidPlass, DietrichPolinder, SuzannePond, Constance D.Pope, C. ArdenPope, DanielPopova, SvetlanaPoulton, Richie G.Pourmalek, FarshadPrasad, Noela M.Qorbani, MostafaRabiee, Rynaz H. S.Radfar, AmirRafay, AnwarRahimi-Movaghar, VafaRahman, MahfuzarRahman, Mohammad Hifz UrRahman, Sajjad UrRai, Rajesh KumarRajsic, SasaRaju, MurugesanRam, UshaRana, Saleem M.Ranganathan, KavithaRao, PujaRazo Garcia, Christian AspaciaRefaat, Amany H.Rehm, Colin D.Rehm, JurgenReinig, NikolasRemuzzi, GiuseppeResnikoff, SergeRibeiro, Antonio L.Rivera, Juan A.Rolm, Hirbo ShoreRodriguez, AnnaRodriguez-Ramirez, SoniaRojas-Rueda, DavidRoman, YeseniaRonfani, LucaRoshandel, GholamrezaRothenbacher, DietrichRoy, AmbujSaleh, Muhammad MuhammadSanabria, Juan R.Dolores Sanchez-Nino, MariaSanchez-Pimienta, Tania G.Sandar, LoganSantomauro, Damian F.Santos, Itamar S.Sarmiento-Suarez, RodrigoSartorius, BennSatpathy, MaheswarSavic, MilojeSawhney, MonikaSchmidhuber, JosefSchmidt, Maria InesSchneider, Ione J. C.Schoettker, BenSchutte, Aletta E.Schwebel, David C.Scott, James G.Seedat, SorayaSepanlou, Sadaf G.Servan-Mori, Edson E.Shaheen, AmiraShahraz, SaeidShaikh, Masood AliLevy, Teresa ShamahSharma, RajeshShe, JunSheikhbahaei, SaraShen, JiabinSheth, Kevin N.Shi, PeilinShibuya, KenjiShigematsu, MikaShin, Min-JeongShiri, RahmanShishani, KawkabShiue, IvyShrime, Mark G.Sigfusdottir, Inga DoraSilva, Diego Augusto SantosAlves Silveira, Dayane GabrieleSilverberg, Jonathan I.Simard, Edgar P.Sindi, ShireenSingh, AbhishekSingh, Jasvinder A.Singh, Prashant KumarSlepak, Erica LeighSoljak, MichaelSoneji, SamirSorensen, Reed J. D.Sposato, Luciano A.Sreeramareddy, Chandrashekhar T.Stathopoulou, VasilikiSteckling, NadineSteel, NicholasStein, Dan J.Stein, Murray B.Stockl, HeidiStranges, SaverioStroumpoulis, KonstantinosSunguya, Bruno F.Swaminathan, SoumyaSykes, Bryan L.Szoeke, Cassandra E. I.Tabares-Seisdedos, RafaelTakahashi, KenTalongwa, Roberto TchioLandon, NikhilTanne, DavidTavakkoli, MohammadTaye, Belaynew WasieTaylor, Hugh R.Tedla, Bemnet AmareTefera, Worku MekonnenTegegne, Teketo KassawTekle, Dejen YemaneTerkawi, Abdullah SuliemanThakur, J. S.Thomas, Bernadette A.Thomas, Matthew LloydThomson, Alan J.Thorne-Lyman, Andrew L.Thrift, Amanda G.Thurston, George D.Tillmann, TaaviTobe-Gai, RuoyanTobollik, MyriamTopor-Madry, RomanTopouzis, FotisTowbin, Jeffrey AllenTran, Bach XuanDimbuene, Zacharie TsalaTsilimparis, NikolaosTura, Abera KenayTuzcu, Emin MuratTyrovolas, StefanosUkwaja, Kingsley N.Undurraga, Eduardo A.Uneke, Chigozie JesseUthman, Olalekan A.van Donkelaar, Aaronvan Os, JimVarakin, Yuri Y.Vasankari, TommiVeerman, J. LennertVenketasubramanian, NarayanaswamyViolante, Francesco S.Vollset, Stein EmilWagner, Gregory R.Waller, Stephen G.Wang, JianLiWang, LinhongWang, YanpingWeichenthal, ScottWeiderpass, ElisabeteWeintraub, Robert G.Werdecker, AndreaWesterman, RonnyWhiteford, Harvey A.Wijeratne, TissaWiysonge, Charles SheyWolfe, Charles D. A.Won, SunghoWoolf, Anthony D.Wubshet, MamoXavier, DenisXu, GelinYadav, Ajit KumarYakob, BereketYalew, Ayalnesh ZemeneYano, YuichiroYaseri, MehdiYe, PengpengYip, PaulYonemoto, NaohiroYoon, Seok-JunYounis, Mustafa Z.Yu, ChuanhuaZaidi, ZoubidaZaki, Maysaa El SayedZhu, JunZipkin, BenZodpey, SanjayZuhlke, Liesl JoannaMurray, Christopher J. L.
Source
The Lancet. 388(10053):1659-1724
Subject
Language
English
ISSN
0140-6736
1474-547X
Abstract
Background The Global Burden of Diseases, Injuries, and Risk Factors Study 2015 provides an up-to-date synthesis of the evidence for risk factor exposure and the attributable burden of disease. By providing national and subnational assessments spanning the past 25 years, this study can inform debates on the importance of addressing risks in context. Methods We used the comparative risk assessment framework developed for previous iterations of the Global Burden of Disease Study to estimate attributable deaths, disability-adjusted life-years (DALYs), and trends in exposure by age group, sex, year, and geography for 79 behavioural, environmental and occupational, and metabolic risks or clusters of risks from 1990 to 2015. This study included 388 risk-outcome pairs that met World Cancer Research Fund-defined criteria for convincing or probable evidence. We extracted relative risk and exposure estimates from randomised controlled trials, cohorts, pooled cohorts, household surveys, census data, satellite data, and other sources. We used statistical models to pool data, adjust for bias, and incorporate covariates. We developed a metric that allows comparisons of exposure across risk factors-the summary exposure value. Using the counterfactual scenario of theoretical minimum risk level, we estimated the portion of deaths and DALYs that could be attributed to a given risk. We decomposed trends in attributable burden into contributions from population growth, population age structure, risk exposure, and risk-deleted cause-specific DALY rates. We characterised risk exposure in relation to a Socio-demographic Index (SDI). Findings Between 1990 and 2015, global exposure to unsafe sanitation, household air pollution, childhood underweight, childhood stunting, and smoking each decreased by more than 25%. Global exposure for several occupational risks, high body-mass index (BMI), and drug use increased by more than 25% over the same period. All risks jointly evaluated in 2015 accounted for 57.8% (95% CI 56.6-58.8) of global deaths and 41.2% (39.8-42.8) of DALYs. In 2015, the ten largest contributors to global DALYs among Level 3 risks were high systolic blood pressure (211.8 million [192.7 million to 231.1 million] global DALYs), smoking (148.6 million [134.2 million to 163.1 million]), high fasting plasma glucose (143.1 million [125.1 million to 163.5 million]), high BMI (120.1 million [83.8 million to 158.4 million]), childhood undernutrition (113.3 million [103.9 million to 123.4 million]), ambient particulate matter (103.1 million [90.8 million to 115.1 million]), high total cholesterol (88.7 million [74.6 million to 105.7 million]), household air pollution (85.6 million [66.7 million to 106.1 million]), alcohol use (85.0 million [77.2 million to 93.0 million]), and diets high in sodium (83.0 million [49.3 million to 127.5 million]). From 1990 to 2015, attributable DALYs declined for micronutrient deficiencies, childhood undernutrition, unsafe sanitation and water, and household air pollution; reductions in risk-deleted DALY rates rather than reductions in exposure drove these declines. Rising exposure contributed to notable increases in attributable DALYs from high BMI, high fasting plasma glucose, occupational carcinogens, and drug use. Environmental risks and childhood undernutrition declined steadily with SDI; low physical activity, high BMI, and high fasting plasma glucose increased with SDI. In 119 countries, metabolic risks, such as high BMI and fasting plasma glucose, contributed the most attributable DALYs in 2015. Regionally, smoking still ranked among the leading five risk factors for attributable DALYs in 109 countries; childhood underweight and unsafe sex remained primary drivers of early death and disability in much of sub-Saharan Africa. Interpretation Declines in some key environmental risks have contributed to declines in critical infectious diseases. Some risks appear to be invariant to SDI. Increasing risks, including high BMI, high fasting plasma glucose, drug use, and some occupational exposures, contribute to rising burden from some conditions, but also provide opportunities for intervention. Some highly preventable risks, such as smoking, remain major causes of attributable DALYs, even as exposure is declining. Public policy makers need to pay attention to the risks that are increasingly major contributors to global burden. Copyright (C) The Author(s). Published by Elsevier Ltd.